5 ms·
I'm really tired of hearing moralizing about people picking the wrong college major. Unless you have a crystal ball and can see four years into the future you'
by emodendroket 9y ago
I'm really tired of hearing moralizing about people picking the wrong college major. Unless you have a crystal ball and can see four years into the future you're better off just studying something you care about; you've got a whole lifetime to do stuff you don't really want to do.
- the_gastropod 9y agoI think this general idea, popular though it is, is troubling. At 17 years old, what kid knows what their life passion will be? How can they have a life passion without much life experience or knowledge? Why do we expect people to work a "whole lifetime" doing stuff they don't really want to do? I think encouraging young people to learn marketable, in demand skills, in order to get a good paying job is solid advice. I wish this advice were coupled with encouraging some frugality, which would free most people up to do what they really want to do, without much concern for finances, by the time they're 30.
- emodendroket 9y ago> I think this general idea, popular though it is, is troubling. At 17 years old, what kid knows what their life passion will be? Well, they don't, of course; that's why so many of them end up changing their majors. At least it's a better ideal than asking 17-year-old kids to anticipate what the job market will be like in four years. > Why do we expect people to work a "whole lifetime" doing stuff they don't really want to do? How many people would be doing the exact same job they're doing now if they had no need for the money? It's not zero percent, but it's certainly not 100 percent either.
- the_gastropod 9y ago> At least it's a better ideal than asking 17-year-old kids to anticipate what the job market will be like in four year At virtually any time in modern history, majoring in engineering is going to be more lucrative than majoring in History or English. Accounting, mathematics, law, etc. all have pretty high likelihood of continuing to be lucrative fields. Let's also not discount trade schools. Electricians, plumbers, HVAC workers, masons, etc. make solid livings, and get to start their careers ~4 years earlier. These are good options that we often neglect / look down upon. > How many people would be doing the exact same job they're doing now if they had no need for the money? It's not zero percent, but it's certainly not 100 percent either. Yea. I assume it's much closer to 0 than than 100 percent.
- emodendroket 9y agoInteresting you mention law, since there's an epidemic of unemployed and underemployed graduates of law schools with huge debt burdens they cannot afford to pay. Which I think illustrates my point rather nicely.
- komali2 9y agoThe problem is some kids get one shot at college, via scholarship or otherwise, and some universities (including mine) have no barrier to entry to a given college (say engineering) if you declare it your major on entry, but have extraordinary transfer requirements.
- pc86 9y agoThat whole system sounds ridiculous. If I'm paying five or six figures to attend a university I should be able to register for whatever class I want and change my major at any time.
- komali2 9y agoWell I don't disagree, but at a state school with 40,000 in the undergrad class I guess they need barriers.
- emodendroket 9y agoWell it sounds like what really should be changed is the transfer requirements then.
- dragonwriter 9y agoFor the most part, they have barrier at entry in the form of evaluating against a different competitive pool of applicants and a different limited number of slots.
- jrs95 9y agoI'd be tired of it if most of the people complaining about having a degree and not being able to get a job didn't major in something which is obviously not a good choice if you want to make money. What I am tired of is anyone suggesting that getting something like an Art History degree is a good idea for someone who doesn't already have enough money sitting around that they're not going to have to worry about their income. Pursuing your dreams is great and everything but not when you have to make the resulting poverty everyone else's problem.
- emodendroket 9y agoThis is exactly the kind of moralizing I meant
- RepressedEmu 9y agoI didn't think the grandparent comment is "moralizing". They aren't saying your choice of major is "good" or "bad". They are saying that when you make a sub-optimal(in relation to expected future income) degree choice then you should expect a sub-optimal result and take responsibility for your own decisions rather than complain about "the economy" or "the system" or "capitalism in general".
- emodendroket 9y agoYes, that's an argument I'd characterize as moralizing.
- jrs95 9y agoI'm not saying doing what I described is immoral. It's just incredibly stupid.
- emodendroket 9y agoTalking about how it's your personal responsibility to pay for your degree and you're to blame if you can't get a job, because you chose the wrong degree, is exactly what I am talking about.
- scarface74 9y agoWhat I “don’t really want to do” for the rest of my life is be unemployable because I got an Ancient Chinese Art History degree and struggling paying off student loan debt in the process. I’ve never told my children to “pursue their dreams” as their career without one eye toward being able to support themselves. Scott Adams sums it up perfectly.... https://www.slideshare.net/Scottadams925/goals-are-for-losers-passion-is-overrated https://www.slideshare.net/Scottadams925/goals-are-for-loser...
- emodendroket 9y agoGetting a degree in liberal arts does not make you "unemployable," as argued in the article this discussion is about.
- scarface74 9y agoThe study the article linked to in support of his argument didn't say anything about liberal arts majors are more employable - just that social skills make you more employable. http://www.nber.org/digest/nov15/w21473.html http://www.nber.org/digest/nov15/w21473.html I can attest to the idea that improving my social skills played a large part in the rapid ascent in my career over the past nine years compared to the nine years prior being stuck in a dead end job.
- emodendroket 9y agoI thought the proposition we were discussing was whether liberal arts majors are "unemployable," not whether or not they're "more employable" (than whom?).
- scarface74 9y agoThe study that was cited by the article doesn't mention whether people with liberal arts degrees are employable - just people with "social skills".
- 9y ago