4 ms·
It doesn't answer all questions. For another example, we won't know how much the results will transfer to other countries. But it's meaningful to see what peop
by skybrian 9y ago
It doesn't answer all questions. For another example, we won't know how much the results will transfer to other countries.
But it's meaningful to see what people will spend the money on, its effect on the local economy (village level), and how this compares to other ways of reducing poverty.
There are still a lot of people who think that people will stop working or spend the money on some wasteful way, and this will tell us whether that's true.
- mehrdadn 9y ago> It doesn't answer all questions. For another example, we won't know how much the results will transfer to other countries. We won't even be confident the results will transfer to the same country at some later time. Lots of things can change over time alone, let alone across populations.
- ttoinou 9y agopeople will stop working or spend the money on some wasteful way That's not really the argument. What does matter is where does the money come from. Cf These handout incomes are to be given as "an absolute constitutional right," and not to be withheld "under any circumstances." This means that the recipients are to continue to get this income not only if they absolutely refuse to seek or take a job, but if they throw the handout money away at the races, or spend it on prostitutes, on whiskey, cigarettes, marijuana, heroin, or what not. They are to be given "sufficient to live in dignity," and it is apparently to be no business of the taxpayers if a recipient chooses none the less to live without dignity, and to devote his guaranteed leisure to gambling, dissipation, drunkenness, debauchery, dope addiction, or a life of crime https://fee.org/articles/income-without-work/ https://fee.org/articles/income-without-work/
- shkkmo 9y agoYour claim is contradicted by your quotes which specifically calls out people not working and spending their money wastefully.
- ttoinou 9y agoThen you did not understand the quote. It's not about an objective morality (what is shameful, wasteful etc. to spend on). Spend the money you successfully exchanged with someone else the way you want it. The morale case with the argument is that citizen should have their say in how their taxes are spend, and that each of one us have different goals so "living in dignity" cannot be accomplished by UBI.
- shkkmo 9y ago> Then you did not understand the quote. Perhaps you picked a bad quote then. That quote pretty explicitly contradicts your claim.
- ttoinou 9y agoThey are to be given "sufficient to live in dignity," and it is apparently to be no business of the taxpayers if a recipient chooses none the less to live without dignity Dignity is subjective ofc. If you think otherwise I can understand how you can interpret the quote in another way :)
- shkkmo 9y agoSince dignity is subjective, how can someone (the taxpayer) have any business having an opinion on whether someone else is living with dignity? I fail to see how the subjectivity of dignity has any relation to your claim that "What does matter is where does the money come from."
- ttoinou 9y agoThey don't have business in it. But they might find how their taxes are spent immoral from their point of view. UBI will never solve the economic problem of "we all should be living in dignity", ours values are subjective.
- PeterisP 9y agoSome people will stop working, and that's perfectly okay, and that's not an argument against UBI - UBI is a solution for an environment with unemployment and unemployable people, so some people stopping working because UBI is sufficient for them is great, it will free up jobs for people who want more than UBI and do want to work. Some people will spend the money on some way that seems wasteful to you, and that's perfectly okay as well - assuming they're sane adults, it's their business to choose which of their needs matter more and spend the money as they wish; we don't want all the UBI to become a transfer to specific companies running dirt cheap apartments with a food supply program, the recipients having a choice is a good thing that facilitates competition. Yes, UBI is not a solution to people with major addictions and mental problems; it's not intended to. It does, however, ensure that a person with a mental or drug problem that can't hold a job isn't necessarily required to get their food by begging or crime.