7 ms·
> if it's your primary residence you get capital gains relief on the first $500k. Yes, I know. But our appreciation is substantially more than that. The high
by lisper 9y ago
> if it's your primary residence you get capital gains relief on the first $500k.
Yes, I know. But our appreciation is substantially more than that. The higher it goes, the more expensive it becomes to make a move.
> which is less impactful since you've already made a profit on it
Only if we move to a less expensive area. If we make a local move, that "profit" just gets rolled in to the next house. There's no way to cash out without leaving the area.
> Clarification - you can't afford to move in the general vicinity, but you could certainly move to Nevada (for example).
Yes, exactly right. What we really want to do, but can't because it's too expensive, is downsize. This would not be the case if prices were stable.
- ttul 9y agoAwww poor baby. You’ve made more than $500K, much of which will be untaxed, simply by owning a house. Jesus fucking Christ. Cry me a river. Most people would trade their arm in for that kind of leveraged gain.
- el_benhameen 9y agoYou arguably have a point (so does the parent), but this isn’t the way to express it in a respectful discussion.
- dalacv 9y agoBut does ttul really get his point across at how he really feels without the colorful words?
- grzm 9y agoLikely they could. "Colorful words" are often used to elicit an emotional response, and emotion can significantly impair one's ability to self-reflect and remove bias. If the goal is civil, substantive discourse (as is the goal of HN), all parties involved need to keep this in mind when commenting. That does take additional effort, but it's worth it to keep HN one of the better places to engage on the internet.
- Danihan 9y agoI dislike the notion that discourse needs to be respectful at all times. Discourse shouldn't be baselessly disrespectful, sure. But the robotic, tsk tsk, shaming attitude that gets thrown around on forums whenever someone expresses any negative emotion gets old too. In any case, complaining about having to pay capital gains tax on gains OVER $500k really is the ultimate first world, privileged problem.
- chaostheory 9y agoMaybe if the comment added to the conversation somehow it'd be more tolerable. However, all the comment does is insult someone without adding anything interesting. It's a waste of space and time for everyone else reading it. It doesn't belong in HN.
- Danihan 9y agoExpressing incredulity and frustration at the obtuseness of someone's complaint doesn't seem especially useless to me. Why is expressing emotional reactions pointless, in your mind? Doing so gives everyone more information about the reactions they might expect to their concerns... it enforces social norms, etc.
- chaostheory 9y ago> Why is expressing emotional reactions pointless, in your mind? Doing so gives everyone more information about the reactions they might expect to their concerns The problem is that the comment provides nothing else. You can do the same thing in a more civil and constructive way. Just look at your comments. You are providing logic and rationale for your argument. I don't agree with you, but you're adding to the discussion. Now compare that to "I'm sick of you people. Stop whining about other people's comments you big baby". Someone can correct me, but that doesn't belong here and that rule has been around since the beginning of HN. It's been written and clear along with the reasons why. It's the way things have been done here. If someone doesn't like it, they can post on reddit instead. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html "Be civil. Don't say things you wouldn't say face-to-face. Don't be snarky. Comments should get more civil and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive. When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. 'That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3' can be shortened to '1 + 1 is 2, not 3.'"
- rebuilder 9y agoThat's purely a paper profit. As the parent said, they can't afford to move to a similar apartment, so they're unwilling to sell. That probably goes for a lot of other homeowners in the area, which seems likely to contribute further to higher prices. Seems pretty dysfunctional to me.
- lisper 9y agoI'm not asking anyone to feel sorry for us. I'm just pointing out that rising prices are not a panacea for owner-occupied primary residences. The result is bad for everyone because people like us end up staying in houses that are too big. That takes housing stock off the market and drives prices up even further. That's good for investors, but bad for everyone who wants to buy a house to live in.
- stevehawk 9y agoLet's say the house didn't go up in value.. where would that leave you? Would you be any more capable to sell? (Serious question, not a rhetorical or sarcastic one.. just seems to me you'd still be in a hole, just a different hole)
- jblow 9y agoThe hole would be smaller, thus more likely to be affordable with wages / savings / etc.
- bzbarsky 9y ago> Would you be any more capable to sell? Quite possibly, yes. Let's plug in some plausible numbers. Say someone buys a 3-bedroom house for $300k (they have kids). At the same time, 1-bedroom houses sell for $200k. Time passes, the kids grow up and move out. Say house prices didn't change at all. You sell for $300k, buy for $200k, pay some agent fees, have $85k or so left over. Now say prices went up and the 3-bedroom house is $1,500,000. You sell, have a $1.2e6 capital gain. $500k is deductible, you pay taxes on the remaining $700k. That's taxed at 20% federal plus the ACA 3.8% investment income tax (because your income is way over that boundary) plus state capital gains taxes. In California, capital gains are taxed the same as other income, at first glance; let's be charitable and assume you avoid the higher tax brackets (12.3%) and get taxed at an effective 10% here. That's 33.8% tax. So your after-tax sale proceeds are $500k + 0.662*$700k = $963k. Note that your house went up in price by 5x. If the smaller one did too, it costs $1 million and you can't pay for it anymore. If it went up by more than that (e.g. if the primary inflation was in land prices, which it often is) you might be even more in the hole. Things are even worse if you're trying to sell and buy something equivalent instead of downsizing.
- yawz 9y ago> You’ve made more than $500K Nope! This is all speculative until you need to "sell & move". If you want to move to another place in the same area, guess what, you've probably made nothing. With all the taxes and fees that you have to pay on the sale price you can't buy the equivalent of your house. You can only capitalize on that appreciation if you move somewhere considerably cheaper. Not only that, the owner faces higher (in some cases much higher) property taxes due to increasing house prices, which is totally out of their control. I'm not suggesting that they're in a bad spot. It's just not the "jackpot" that your post is suggesting.
- mbesto 9y ago> With all the taxes and fees that you have to pay on the sale price you can't buy the equivalent of your house. So why on earth would someone want to sell their house and buy an equivalent house in the same area...?
- ghaff 9y agoIn all fairness, I can see wanting to, say, downsize and move to a more walkable community relatively nearby. (Or, for that matter, move out of an expensive urban condo and move somewhere with more room--although that will harder in the Bay area specifically.) To the degree that market value of the two is similar, the financial hit will be substantial. But a lot of this is true with moving generally when you're living somewhere that's OK but isn't really optimal for you any longer.
- nitrogen 9y agoSwitch schools or districts, change neighbors, move closer to work, change floorplans, move closer to family, etc.
- sliverstorm 9y agoIn short, what is important to people in their residence changes. Friend of mine bought a house he and his wife loved. Five years later he came to understand what owning a Dr Horton house means, and they wanted a better-built house.
- astura 9y agoExcept you can really only "cash out" in a meaningful way if you sell and relocate to a cheaper area/somewhere without a housing bubble, which is extremely disruptive to your life.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoThere are financial instruments that will allow you to cash out if you own property while continuing to live in it for as long as you want to e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_mortgage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_mortgage
- astura 9y agoI said "in a meaningful way."
- BatFastard 9y agoI am the only one not seeing "reply" links on some of these posts? I see others of the same depth with reply links... Edit: Actually it's just the one from davidw
- astura 9y agoHN has rate limiting on replies. Reply button should appear after a few minutes.
- sliverstorm 9y agoSuppose they move horizontally to a similar house. I don't know, they want one story instead of two. Since a rising tide lifts all boats, the new purchase is about even with the old sale- but they also owe taxes. So within this window, they are objectively worse off than your average Joe who can move across town without owning those taxes. Anyone trading up is also impacted as well. Suppose you bought a condo at 100k, and SFH was 200k. In five years you want to trade up, but the market went up 100%. Your condo sells for 200k, but the SFH costs 400k. Despite the lovely appreciation on your condo, you'd probably prefer if the market hadn't moved. Sure, there's people who have it worse. Owning any home at all puts them in better shape than most of the world. But it's still not enviable to be unable to move within your community.
- losteverything 9y agoThese comments are helpful because this is how people think. When a suit or Talbots customer argues over a price at Wal-Mart you should hear the similar type of tone the cashier takes after they leave. Especially if they argue for a buck or two. This is real world
- sctb 9y agoIt doesn't matter what you're responding to; the guidelines ask us not to post like this. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mbesto 9y agoBut you don't realize a net loss from moving to a smaller home in the same area. The only hinderance is paying a higher tax % (because of CA), but you'll likely net more positive cash (because of the transaction) + the absolute value of your new taxes will be less. I'm still not sure why exactly the issue is. You literally can afford to downsize and you'll make a ton of money doing so. > If we make a local move, that "profit" just gets rolled in to the next house. Huh? That's not how it works... 2008 - Buy house for $1M 2017 - Sell house for $2M 2017 - Buy new house for $1M (but smaller size) Congrats you have an asset worth $1M you've just made $1M in cash. Now net out fees and you have a downsized home and are more liquid than you were before, but with slightly less wealth than you had yesterday (due to netting of fees associated with the transaction).
- bzbarsky 9y ago> 2017 - Buy new house for $1M (but smaller size) Assuming there's anything on the market for $1M. The problems start when there isn't.
- mbesto 9y agoBut if you're downsizing then yes there is a cheaper house. That's how the housing market generally works ($ per square foot * # of square feet). > The problems start when there isn't. And the market always opens up when there isn't because it means the demand goes higher and thus creates new sellers. That also "rises the tide" and increase everyone in the area's house prices. So it nets it self out.
- ng12 9y agoI feel like you're really making your own problem here -- you want to downsize while keeping a large portion of your equity. The ratio of profit you make moving from a $2m house to a $1m house is the same as moving from a $200k house to a $100k house in a "stable" area.
- lisper 9y agoThis has nothing to do with equity (except insofar as equity is part of your net worth). This has to do with the actual cost of a move, that is, the difference in your net worth at the end of the day once all the dust settles. The higher prices go, the higher that cost goes. It's easiest to see that when considering a purely lateral move, but the cost of a move doesn't really depend on the cost of what you buy with the proceeds of the sale, it just makes the math easier if the prices are the same. We put a certain positive intrinsic value on a local move (and a very high negative intrinsic value on a remote move), because we like the area but the house we're in is not ideal. If the cost of a local move is less than this intrinsic value, we'll move, otherwise we won't. The higher prices go, the higher the actual cost of moving goes, and the less likely we are to move.
- mbesto 9y ago> The higher prices go, the higher the actual cost of moving goes Sans CA taxes, this is relative to the increase of wealth you've accumulated. So yes in the absolute it's higher, but relatively speaking you've still are earning more money in liquidity during the transaction. > This has to do with the actual cost of a move, that is, the difference in your net worth at the end of the day once all the dust settles. I think I finally understand your position now. The cost isn't prohibitive, it's the negative impact on your wealth. Which is true. The reason I and others are reacting strongly to your position is because your conflating transactional costs (expenses, fees, etc) with wealth (accumulation of assets). Two very different things that use a common medium to interact (i.e. currency). Here's the predicament. Your implying that you can transfer assets (wealth) without any transactional costs. This is just not how the market for any asset transfer works (stocks, cash, etc), because someone or some system has to be setup to broker the transaction. What your essentially complaining about is why you have to pay fees to complete an asset transfer. I know very few markets were transferring assets doesn't incur a fee. I don't know what to tell you other than this is basically economics 101. CA taxes on the other hand - that's something to complain about. CA taxes inadvertently nudge people to hold on to property longer, reducing supply and thus driving overall prices up.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoMy understanding was that you can avoid all capital gains taxes via "1031 like kind exchange": you sell your house, buy one elsewhere for about the same amount, and pay no capital gains taxes?
- secabeen 9y agoThat only works for business property.
- mercutio2 9y ago1031 is only for business property. Specifically doesn’t apply to primary residence. But CA Prop 60 allows Californians over 55 to downsize their house and maintain the same tax basis they had before the exchange, which very well might apply here, although IIRC it has weird county by county restrictions.