3 ms·
If your process doesn't involve stealing IP, why would documenting it increase your risk?
by maxerickson 9y ago
If your process doesn't involve stealing IP, why would documenting it increase your risk?
- detaro 9y agoIf he weren't stealing IP, why would he be taking notes about company IP in a private notebook? Someone asking that question and not liking your answer is the risk.
- maxerickson 9y agoA notebook created on company time obviously belongs to the company, disputing that would certainly be a reason for suspicion, but why would anyone dispute it?
- gknoy 9y agoI take notes about company IP in a notebook _all the time_. Part of my job is to document the things I learn about or create in my notebook, precisely so that we can establish a work timeline on a piece of technology if necessary. I keep dedicated work notebooks, and while most of the time it's a way for me to Write Things during meetings to make sure I prioritize tasks and whatnot, I have quite frequently used them to document new things I'm learning about. Almost anything non-trivial is worth writing about, sketching about, and diagramming the major pieces and relationships. Whether it's a piece of infrastructure that our team might use for packaging and deployment, a workflow for a tool we are building (or needing to cooperate), or even just something cool that a co-worker is presenting about, it ends up in my notebook.
- codemac 9y agoBecause you "stealing" IP does not require that you stole anything intentionally, it matters when you happened to do the same thing. There are patents for things like paxos, TCP, "network servers" and everything else. If you write down that you looked up a wikipedia page about the topic, and then some notes about your implementation - it may look legally like you stealing IP even though you are doing nothing nefarious.
- maxerickson 9y agoMaybe a patent lawyer can weigh in, but I think it does require intent. Like if your notes demonstrated independent discovery, that wouldn't create any liability. You could be prevented from ongoing use of the IP though.
- codemac 9y agoThat's not the impression I got from lawyers in the past, but I think I just have a lot of fear in the area. Getting real legal advice for this is something I should probably do.
- Silhouette 9y agoYou might be thinking of wilful infringement, which in some jurisdictions can significantly increase the penalties for infringing some types of IP rights. This in turn can lead to the perverse position that someone doing R&D in a certain field may be advised by their IP lawyer not to read existing research papers or patents, so that at least if they infringe and get sued, they can honestly say they didn't know and it wasn't wilful. Of course this completely undermines the entire principle of publishing knowledge through academic papers, disclosing inventions through patents, and so on.
- gowld 9y agoNot really. The patent is filed with details so that when the patent expires, the design is ready to be disseminated freely without risk of legal challenge.
- Silhouette 9y agoAnd in the meantime, it is openly disclosed so that others can learn from it and potentially it is available for licensing if it or later inventions based on it are valuable enough. If you weren't going to do that, and you wanted to have a system that discouraged actually looking at what's already out there in case you infringed it knowingly, you might as well just let people file for anything but keep it secret for N years.