9 ms·
There are tons of things inflating house prices. The most important for Sweden are - Deduction of interest expenses from income tax. - Too long mortgages (100
by alkonaut 9y ago
There are tons of things inflating house prices. The most important for Sweden are
- Deduction of interest expenses from income tax.
- Too long mortgages (100 years or more) means nominal prices are high which add to the risk
- Historically big mortgages (90, 100 or even 110% of the cost could be financed - yes
negativev down payments existed in the early 2000's).
- Rent control of almost all flats, meaning no one will build places to rent, only to buy.
- Extremely low interest rates as the central bank refuses to look at housing costs and interest rates when aiming for the inflation target.
This is the recipe for disaster. Now, it's not ALL doom and gloom, a lot has actually improved. Down payments have been 15-25% for some time now, mortgages are no longer infinite, and banks are using max-multiple-of-household-income caps (typically 4-5x) to limit lending. I think the situation now is a bit brighter than it would have been if we had been hit by a big correction in 2008 (which we were not). Many would welcome a controlled price correction (say 10-15%), and it IS expected since all the above changes have yet NOT changed the prices downward, even though the pool of prospective buyers gets smaller and smaller the more restrictive lenders are. It would be very welcome to see the correction now that both domestic and global economy is decent, interest rates are low etc.
- selectodude 9y ago> Too long mortgages (100 years or more) means nominal prices are high which add to the risk That is absolutely bananas. Almost like a Chinese-style 99 year lease. Your kids might be dead by the time it's paid off, you'll never own it. Edit: apparently the AVERAGE mortgage term is 140 years! Just recently the Swedish government limited the maximum mortgage term to 105 years. That is some absolutely stupid policy.
- opportune 9y agoAs an American I am absolutely shocked anybody thought that was a good idea. If an average person making $50k/year finds it affordable to pay $1200/month on housing, they're just going to shop for a house that will yield that desired monthly payment. When interest rates are low, how is this not a recipe for runaway housing costs? What's worse is that this is actually a huge subsidy for landlords, unless their mortgage terms are limited to be much shorter. A landlord can afford the downpayment to finance many homes at low interest rates, whereas a poorer person may be able to make the payments on such a mortgage, but can't save up enough to afford a down payment.
- njarboe 9y ago"shocked"; a bit of sarcasm perhaps? A 30 year loan is not much different really. Too long. It was rare in the US before various government subsidies and encouragements. First, Fannie Mae (1938), securitizing FHA backed home mortgages. Next, Freddie Mac (1970), securitizing home loans not backed by the US government.
- opportune 9y agoShocked because it seems obvious to me that this would have undesirable effects down the road. It also funnels even more money into banks because the net effect is that homeowners are essentially renting from banks for most of their lives until they get a significant windfall. In the US, we saw what happens when you make getting a mortgage "easy". People bought more house than they could afford and got screwed.
- moduspol 9y agoWow. And I've seen people here (justifiably) roll their eyes over 6 and 7 year auto loans. A 140 year mortgage can't possibly be appreciably different from renting.
- alkonaut 9y ago> A 140 year mortgage can't possibly be appreciably different from renting. The fact that as a homeowner ("owner") you can deduct interest rates, means that by "renting from the bank" you have a 30% rebate compared to renting from a landlord, and obviously you have no landlord taking a cut on top of that. So apart from the risk of depreciation, people seem to have little interest in owning their homes outright. So people pay off quickly in the beginning to get some margin on their valuation, but after that when the loan is e.g. 50% of the valuation, people might prefer buying a car to paying off $10k per year on their home. And it's probably better to have a mortgage fixed at 50% forever with 2-3% interest rate, and avoid the car loan with 5% interest.
- votepaunchy 9y agoThe landlord is also getting the “30% rebate” by claiming interest as a business expense to offset rent revenue.
- marvin 9y agoYes, but landlords also pay taxes on profits. As a homeowner, you won't pay tax on the difference between rental cost and your mortgage interest payment.
- kgwgk 9y agoIn some countries you get taxed on the imputed rent (the amount of rent that you would be paying gets added to your taxable income). https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/09/03/taxing-homeowners-as-if-they-were-landlords/ https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/09/03/taxing-homeown...
- alkonaut 9y ago> Your kids might be dead by the time it's paid off, you'll never own it. Exactly right. I don't know anyone who buys with the intention to own. Effectively you rent it from the bank. I don't mind, I mean I don't mind renting from the bank. I pay off my mortgage (2% per year, so 50 years) but only as long as its reasonably high, in order to lower interest rate costs and reduce the risk of being under water. I have no interest in paying it off completely, so I'll stop paying 2% per year when the mortgage is down to e.g. 40% of the value. Obviosly as a banks have zero interest in your customers loans shrinking, it's lost revenue! The big downside of very long mortgages is that it brings up nominal prices, and thus the volatility
- mhandley 9y agoIn the UK, around a fifth of mortgages are interest-only, which I guess is effectively an infinite-term mortgage. In comparison, at least you're paying some part of the capital back on a 100 year mortgage. Of course, both are storing up trouble for the future. https://www.ft.com/content/4e0377e6-6ad4-11e7-bfeb-33fe0c5b7eaa https://www.ft.com/content/4e0377e6-6ad4-11e7-bfeb-33fe0c5b7...
- manarth 9y agoDoes the FT article give any details of how that fifth is broken down? I suspect they'd be predominantly buy-to-let; my understanding is that there are significant barriers to getting an interest-only residential mortgage.
- charlesdm 9y agoIf you're getting an interest only mortgage, at least you know what you're getting into. They're great for investment properties and other investments, not so much for your main residence. Then again, there is the problem of refinancing when the end date comes due, which is probably why you have 100+ years mortgages in Sweden.
- awjr 9y agoI would agree that my interest only mortgage is storing up trouble for my future. However given I bought my 1st house in 1996 with no deposit, the reality is that interest only has worked well given that I have leveraged the housing market over 20 years and have now have a mortgage that is around 40% of the value of the house and is probably enough to move somewhere significantly less expensive and retire. However I recognise that my gain is also a problem for my teenage daughter who will struggle immensely to get on the housing ladder. In the UK, it really does not help that housing is considered an investment opportunity. I have a feeling rent control is the only way we will ever get to the point where we remove this 'investment' opportunity. More interestingly, it's within landlord's interest to work with developers to ensure whole developments are primarily bought up by landlords to maintain the value of housing stock.
- conanbatt 9y ago
- alkonaut 9y ago> Just recently the Swedish government limited the maximum mortgage term to 105 years. That is some absolutely stupid policy. It is a bad situation. But on the other hand you can't just change the max mortgage to 30 years either, or remove the interest tax deduction over night, as that would immediately create the problem you were trying to avoid to begin with (an unstable housing market). I think what they are doing to mortgage lengths is entirely sensible now: they are increasing the required down payments (effectively 25% now) and then requiring a higher pace of repayment initially. That's when it really matters to stability. E.g. if people pay off 3%/year for the first 10 years of their mortgage, it doesn't really matter whether they have a 30, 40 or 100 year mortgage. They will have paid it down to around half the valuation which lowers the risk.
- staticelf 9y agoAlso to add to that, an extreme number of new people immigrating to Sweden, especially under 2014-2016 [1] (which is my personal belief that is the leading cause to the biggest increases in prices). Many municipalities also letting up to 25% of these new people jump ahead the queues leaving Swedes to be even more forced to buy an apartment instead of renting [2]. Also in Sweden for apartments, you don't own it. Most apartments for sale is so called "Bostadsrätter" which means you own a percentage of the association that owns the apartment building(s). If the association/organization has a bad economy and can't pay the debt they could be forced to sell the entire apartment building(s) and you'd loose your apartment while still having a loan to the bank. Of course you would get that % of the profit, but since it selling in a time of crisis, that would mean you would most likely get significantly less than you otherwise would do. It doesn't even matter if you have a good economy, the association must have it as well. Lots of those associations or organizations have a really shitty economy and are sensitive to market changes. Especially in Gothenburg and Stockholm. [1] https://www.migrationsverket.se/images/18.5bc6881815e14db67502366/1510566869185/Total_s%C3%B6k.png https://www.migrationsverket.se/images/18.5bc6881815e14db675... [2] http://sverigesradio.se/sida/artikel.aspx?programid=98&artikel=6457520 http://sverigesradio.se/sida/artikel.aspx?programid=98&artik... EDIT: If you downvote / disagree, please explain why? What I stated is pure fact a with a touch of stated opinion which is backed by the numbers. EDIT 2: I've added sources for the stuff regarding to immigration.
- estomagordo 9y agoI don't even have enough karma to downvote you, but I'll make sure to come back to this thread when I'm above 500 :)
- staticelf 9y agoBy that time your apartment at/in Södermalm will probably be worth half of what you bought for ;)
- wjnc 9y agoI upvoted. I guess it's the first few words that suggest a racist / popularist post, but it's ontopic IMHO. You point to an influx of people in the age range that usually rents an apartment. Such local equilibria are quite instable. It only takes a few hundred excess renters to destabilize a local (regulated) market for housing. That leads to crowding out where those that usually would rent, but can afford to buy will buy. A few more buyers will lead to the a dysequilibrium in the next market. One thing - you expect upward pressure on prices, with more people competing for the same number of houses. The OP is about falling prices.
- expertentipp 9y ago> Too long mortgages (100 years or more) This is basically a mortgage and reverse mortgage in one package, isn't it?
- alkonaut 9y ago> This is basically a mortgage and reverse mortgage We don't have a specific term for "mortgages" as meaning home loans - we treat them as any bank loan. I hadn't heard the term "reverse mortgage" before, so had to look it up. It's not quite that (interests are always paid).
- kgwgk 9y agoMortgage is just sort for mortgage loan = hypotekslån.
- charlesdm 9y ago100 year mortgages? Why is this? Because prices are too high for average folks to purchase otherwise, or because people prefer "owning" (renting from a bank) instead of renting from a landlord?
- alkonaut 9y ago> Because prices are too high for average folks to purchase otherwise Yes. In a sell to the highest bidder, you aren't going to win with the amount you can borrow over 30 years, if the people bidding against you borrow on 50 or 100 years. Simple as that. So without any caps, people will request long mortgages simply to be able to win these auctions. Should be noted that this is now developing backwars again, and "peak insanity" was early 2000's. What we are seeing now is to a large extent the effect of common sense on the prices. The attempts to stop the insanity over the last 5-10 years (e.g. down payments went from 5, to 10, to 15 to 20 % etc) unfortunately coincided with negative interest rates, meaning people could still push prices up. Now we are finally seeing the effect. > or because people prefer "owning" (renting from a bank) instead of renting from a landlord? Yes, there is effectively zero renting of 1-family homes. If you rent, it's a flat. And there are very few flats to rent. A LOT of the people having to buy these expensive homes would rather rent, but there is nothing to rent.
- charlesdm 9y agoMakes sense. So, if you don't mind me asking, how much are people paying for an average home? How much is an average salary?
- alkonaut 9y agoVaries, of course. Average house is basically $100 to $350k but the average in Stockholm is probably around $1M depending on what areas you count. Not sure what the average salary is, but loan caps now are ~5 times the household (gross) salary. which sets the equation somewhat. So a couple buying a stockholm home at $1M today (which isnt an uncommon price) would be borrowing say 75-80% of that, so making at least $1Mx0.8/5 as a couple or $1Mx0.8/5/2 each, or $80k/year. That's a good salary, but more commonly this couple would be selling something they made a nice profit on, and borrow less, lowering the income requirement. This equation could be cut in 2 for a more average (4MSEK house, not 8MSEK) city or cut in 3 for more rural areas. Salaries fall off slower than house prices do, so rural areas spend less on housing than city dwellers.