7 ms·
> No, not being political in the workplace means someone values their stable income more than they value the need to talk about their opinions. Support of the
by wpietri 9y ago
> No, not being political in the workplace means someone values their stable income more than they value the need to talk about their opinions.
Support of the status quo is a political choice. There is no neutral.
Also, the option to "stay out of politics" is something not afforded to everybody. As a financially comfortable white guy with in-demand skills, I can do it. But if you are on the sharp end of any of America's ingrained biases, you may not be able to.
See, for example, all the women now able to come forward about workplace harassment. Their speaking out, their striving for workplaces where they are free of abuse: those are inevitably political actions. So too is ignoring or resisting that movement.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jpttsn 9y agoI don’t care about sports. Does that mean I support the latest Super Bowl winner? Not everyone can afford not to care about sports. Does that mean I have to care about sports?
- confounded 9y agoYour argument only makes sense if you view politics as optional entertainment and identity-decoration. While this is increasingly the character of American politics, this is not what politics is about. Politics is ultimately a contest over resources (financial, social, etc). Whether or not you get them determines whether you’ll have a short life of misery or a long life of luxury. Politics is the contest over who gets them, framed as who deserves them. If you have no interest in this contest, then either you have the luxury of little incentive to change it, or you genuinely believe that the current system is fair and equitable. I’m yet to meet another human (of any political leaning) in the latter category. It is difficult to reconcile saying that you care about other humans, but you don’t care about politics. The same cannot be said of the Super Bowl.
- burntsushi 9y agoYou (and probably others) have dramatically shifted the goalposts here. It went from "not wanting to voice political opinions in the work place" to "not caring about politics." Those two things are drastically different and cannot and should not be considered the same.
- wpietri 9y agoNot voicing a political opinion is distinct from not being political. Spending 40+ hours a week supporting the status quo while helping maintain the norm that "political" opinions (that is, ones that take issue with the status quo) shouldn't be voiced is unavoidably a political act. It may be a reasonable one, and I'm not taking issue with people who do it. I just object to taking about it in a way that pretends that it isn't also political.
- burntsushi 9y agoPardon me while I refuse to indulge in your war over definitions. Meanwhile, the meaning of the phrase "I don't talk politics at work" is perfectly clear.
- wpietri 9y agoSure. And if xupypd had said that originally, maybe it would have been clearer. But what he said was it'd be "wise to separate work and politics". That's not possible.
- burntsushi 9y agoIt is possible: don't talk about it. It's only impossible if you see the world in black and white.
- wpietri 9y agoYou're the one seeing it a polarized way, your imaginary perfect separation between work and politics. Consider, for example, unionization. In our culture, it's seen as heavily "political" right now. Consider the actions that trigger unionization: stewards of capital using their bargaining power to disadvantage laborers. That too is political, but is often treated as if it weren't. There are places where the opposite applies: unionization is seen as normal, and therefore apolitical, while the power of capital is seen as strongly political. What makes something accepted in some places and not in others? That too is politics. You're being political right now by trying to control what is even classified as political.
- gaius 9y agoSupport of the status quo is a political choice. There is no neutral. The "status quo" is "the person who was elected gets to be President". It's OK for you not to believe in democracy per se, or in a specific flavour of it, that's Freedom. But let's call a spade a spade shall we?
- ubernostrum 9y agoThe "status quo" is "the person who was elected gets to be President". He gets to be President until he's impeached, loses an election, or is declared unable to discharge his duties using the procedure in the 25th Amendment. And... that's it. He doesn't get a guarantee that nobody will criticize him or his agenda. He doesn't get a guarantee that nobody will try to rally legislative support to prevent his agenda being enacted. He doesn't get a guarantee that nobody will use the courts to challenge his executive orders. He doesn't get a guarantee that the courts will allow any executive order he issues. He doesn't get a guarantee that state and local governments will assist federal initiatives. He doesn't get a guarantee that large donors will support him or his preferred candidates and causes. There are many, many ways to challenge a sitting President without removing him from office. You don't have to challenge him, but the fact that you choose not to is a political choice, not an apolitical one, since it constitutes acceptance of and complicity in whatever he manages to do as a result of not being challenged. Neutrality and "apolitical" stances are never neutral or apolitical. They always constitute acceptance of whatever will happen in the absence of your explicit action, since if you didn't want that stuff to happen you had an opportunity to challenge it and actively chose not to.
- gaius 9y agoit constitutes acceptance of and complicity in whatever I'm not sure you really believe that, here's an experiment to find out: did your feelings about Hillary change at all as a result of the Weinstein thing? Do you feel complicit in all Weinstein's deeds? Or substitute any of the many Hillary-supporters caught up in scandals now. Just as an experiment of course.
- ubernostrum 9y ago
- bobthechef 9y agoSupport is not the same as toleration, indifference, or complacency. That being said, they are choices, as you say, though awareness and fear do affect culpability (something that seems to be implied in your comment).
- wpietri 9y agoFor a system you are outside of, sure. But we're talking about a system that people are actively participating in. E.g., the people who spend 50 hours a week working at Uber are supporting Uber, whatever their attitude toward it. I suppose the possible exception is somebody who goes in and consciously sabotages the place for 50 hours a week, but that's the edgiest of edge cases.