4 ms·
> Are you sure? Yes. A quick google for "foregone conclusion doctrine" will turn up a bunch of fairly-recent news about this. > It's the same problem with en
by kelnos 9y ago
> Are you sure?
Yes. A quick google for "foregone conclusion doctrine" will turn up a bunch of fairly-recent news about this.
> It's the same problem with encryption keys. Just because you had it yesterday doesn't mean you have it today. People actually lose or forget things, especially under stress.
Yes, and that's part of the problem. I'm not saying I agree with how all this works, just stating that's how it is.
There are limits, of course. If the court cannot establish that you know (or at least knew) the password/phrase/key. "I forgot" can certainly be a legitimate defense, but it of course depends on whether or not a judge believes you. If we could use "I don't remember" as an unquestioned excuse, we could get away with anything.
> That's one of the main purposes of protection against self-incrimination -- so that the government can't claim you know something that you don't and then hold you in contempt for not telling them.
That's not what we're talking about here. We're talking about things the government affirmatively knows that you either have or know. Unfortunately, of you no longer have or know that thing, the burden is on you to prove that you don't, which is difficult.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> Yes, and that's part of the problem. I'm not saying I agree with how all this works, just stating that's how it is. You have to keep in mind that judges make rulings that conflict with the rulings of other judges all the time. It means one of them is wrong and it takes a higher court (or legislative action) to sort it out. Pointing to lower court rulings in the news doesn't mean the issue is settled. > If we could use "I don't remember" as an unquestioned excuse, we could get away with anything. That is obviously nonsense. People are regularly convicted without being compelled to say or do anything. The government simply has to prove their case without the defendant's testimony. > We're talking about things the government affirmatively knows that you either have or know. Unfortunately, of you no longer have or know that thing, the burden is on you to prove that you don't, which is difficult. But that's the point. They should have to prove that you have it, not that you had it. And when the thing is the contents of your mind, it's impossible for them to prove that without your cooperation, and impossible for you to disprove it. The burden that something can't be proven in a criminal proceeding is supposed to fall on the government, not the accused.