6 ms·
Bioethicist proposes adding lithium to US drinking water
- adulau 16y agoThe toxicity of lithium is a reality. To monitor the level of toxicity you need to check the concentration level in the blood. If you start to distribute lithium in water, how can you ensure that the level of lithium remains below toxicity in the blood of each water drinker (even if you control the concentration as you don't control the quantity of water used by everyone)? Lithium is often a salt and what will be the effect of the concentration when cooking or taking a shower? Even if lithium was added in 7up[1] before the fifties, it's not drinking water and you don't take your bath with 7up or cook your potatoes with it... [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_pharmacology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_pharmacology
- hugh3 16y agoSeems more like professional-grade trolling than a serious suggestion. Still, on the offchance they do start doing it, I'll be first in line for rainwater tanks, so I can protect the purity of my precious bodily fluids.
- sliverstorm 16y agoYour precious bodily fluids are about as impure as it gets. I mean, dude- what other aqueous solution can you think of that's 80% water and can stand on it's own like a pair of month-old socks?
- narrator 16y agoBioethics attracts all the weirdos who want to propose really off the wall crazy crap, like drugging the water supply, and call it "ethics". Let's take a look at the Table of Contents of the Journal of Bioethics shall we (http://www.bioethics.net/journal/ http://www.bioethics.net/journal/) * Should Human Beings Have Sex? Sexual Dimorphism and Human Enhancement * The Risks of “Sexual Normalcy” * Humans Should Be Free of All Biological Limitations Including Sex * Response to Open Peer Commentaries on “Human Dignity and Transhumanism: Do Anthro-Technological Devices [nonbiological entities introduced into or attached to the human body] Have Moral Status?” The whole discipline of bioethics is basically about trolling... or they're serious :/.
- palish 16y agoHaha. That is amazing. I thought "Bioethics attracts all the weirdos who want to propose really off the wall crazy crap" until I read that list. People actually get paid to write stuff like that?
- _delirium 16y agoThings vary considerably, partly because there's no real central registry for journal names: If you're the Journal of X, it just means you were the first organization audacious enough to pick that name, not necessarily that you're actually a legitimate representative of field X. There are, fortunately, some somewhat more sane bioethics journals, like the one named Bioethics, which has article titles that at least seem to involve legitimate issues at the intersection of medical practice and ethics, like, "Addiction and Autonomy: Can Addicted People Consent to the prescription of their drug of addiction?": http://www.wiley.com/bw/journal.asp?ref=0269-9702 http://www.wiley.com/bw/journal.asp?ref=0269-9702
- gaius 16y agoAn anything-ethicist is someone who failed in that field but still thinks they ought to get a say in what gets funded. Ignore them.
- EliRivers 16y ago
- _delirium 16y agoThis certainly does seem like a step above anything that's been done before. Fluoride is intended to be basically inert as far as ingestion goes--- its purpose is to improve tooth strength, but not to have any medically noticeable internal effects when the water's drunk. Adding a substance that is medically active when internally ingested as a default drinking-water option would be quite a step. At the very least, we might want to get a lot better handle on what the possible downsides are. There are these studies showing a good preventative association with suicides, but does increasing lithium intake do anything negative? It would be surprising if it had no possible negative effects, so the question is more what they are and how likely/serious they are.
- JacobAldridge 16y agoI must admit, I railed against adding Flouride for many years, mostly from a liberty / choice perspective, before finally accepting almost a century of scientific evidence and becoming a supporter. I need to know more about the science, both positive and negative effects, before doing the same here, but it is a nifty precendent. As with fluoride, I wouldn't want my community to be the first to test it - perhaps if I can convince my neighbours to support a local nuclear power plant we would be spared being guinea pigs on the lithium issue.
- justsee 16y agoOne thing that's always been like a junk-science beacon for me in regards to water fluoridation is the decree that the ppm of fluoride in water varies depending on whether you're in a hot climate or a cold climate because "people who live in warm climates tend to drink more water". That and systemic reviews such as the York review (http://www.york.ac.uk/inst/crd/pdf/summary.pdf http://www.york.ac.uk/inst/crd/pdf/summary.pdf) which basically states there has been very little high-quality studies done on the effects of water fluoridation. Admittedly that systemic review was released in 2000, and unfortunately for conspiracy theorists the York review concluded there may be a slight benefit and at worst a slight disbenefit to water fluoridation, but in their executive summary they did say: "Given the level of interest surrounding the issue of public water fluoridation, it is surprising to find that little high quality research has been undertaken" That's almost half a century since we've been touting the 'scientifically proven' benefits of water fluoridation, which I just find stunning. So unlike yourself I'm very unimpressed with the scientific evidence, and have come to the conclusion that a half-baked health policy was implemented in an age of questionable scientific rigour. Human and establishment tendency to refuse to admit fault or error has guaranteed this rather flaky practice continues in many parts of the west today.
- angusgr 16y agoI wouldn't want my community to be the first to test it At the levels they are talking about, it seems like there are communities who for decades or longer have been "testing" drinking water with the proposed levels of lithium. Of course, that's assuming that the deliberately introduced lithium is in the same form, with the same chemical availability. I would hope that would be a requirement if anyone actually decided to try and do this.
- darushimo 16y agoSerenity?
- wisty 16y agoMore like Equilibrium, given the effects of lithium. Of course, we are talking about really small doses. It does beg the question though. If small doses are effective, why do people only get prescribed massively higher doses?
- sliverstorm 16y agoA prescription is an intervention, and uses higher levels to achieve dramatic change over a short period of time. This is proposing small doses because the target range is lifetime
- biotech 16y agoI think the gp was referencing the movie "Serenity". Good movie :)
- darushimo 16y agoyea i was, both title and storyline. :)
- KevinMS 16y agoMaybe they should check, or already have, if small doses of lithium make citizens more compliant and less critical of authority, especially with increasing the dosage of lithium in the water :)
- nphase 16y ago"One person's right to drink lithium-free water is no greater than another's right to drink lithium-enhanced water." Um... If you feel this strongly about it, then go put lithium in your water. Don't make me buy bottled water. I've been on lithium before. I'd prefer to spend the rest of my life as far away from ingesting it as possible.
- nphase 16y agoAlso, I highly doubt anyone has done a study on what tiny amounts of lithium ingested regularly would do to your kidneys. There is a reason your doctor wants you to get semi-regular kidney function tests if you're on lithium.
- stuaxo 16y agoI am curious what the original 7up with lithium was like.
- palish 16y agoI've been on lithium before. I'd prefer to spend the rest of my life as far away from ingesting it as possible. Care to explain?
- camperman 16y agoI won't speak for him but I've been on it before for the treatment of bipolar disorder. It works for some people. It didn't work for me - too poisonous - and I'm on something else now. But I don't blame his reaction; there were horrible side effects.
- jim_h 16y agoEver see the movie 'Equilibrium'..? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equilibrium_%28film%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equilibrium_%28film%29 I think we need to make changes to how we live our lives before we resort to using drugs if we can avoid it. What's next? Dieting drugs in our water?
- sliverstorm 16y agoIt's not like this is an anti-obesity drug to fight poor life choices and life styles. I really hope you don't feel that the majority of suicides were by people who simply made 'poor life choices' and needed to change how they lived. And, even when the condition can be remedied by life changes, good or bad (is moving to Seattle and suffering from depression deserving of criticism?) doesn't it make sense to buy time by treating the major life threatening symptoms, i.e. trying to kill yourself?
- jim_h 16y agoWhat are the majority of suicides caused by? (I am actually curious.) I'm merely saying that living a healthy, active and happy life would produce good results and help to avoid needing to take drugs. Is that wrong? Naive?
- Qz 16y agoNaive, yes.
- jim_h 16y agoWell, you can't avoid all drugs, but you would agree that it would reduce the ones you can actively avoid. Right? Naive or not, I think an active healthy lifestyle is something that we should all strive for. Work and hope for the best.
- Qz 16y agoWe should all strive for it, but the reality is that most people who don't have an 'active healthy lifestyle' arrived at that condition before they were adults. People who learn unhealthy habits in their childhood or adolescence have a tremendously hard time breaking those habits or even recognizing that they are unhealthy. I speak as someone who, despite my parents best intentions, was not raised to approach life in a 'healthy active' manner, and have only arrived at that point after leaving my parents' well-meaning clutches. So, the people who this would most help are generally not that way by choice or even responsibility, so to talk of their right to not drink lithium water seems off the mark. I'd love to give people the right not to have incapable parents, because that would do a whole lot more for this cause than anything else.
- euccastro 16y agoRegarding the success story provided as precedent: I don't know the quantities involved, but if it is known that swallowing a toothpaste tube's worth of fluoride can kill a child, I'm not comfortable with the idea of tainting the drinking water with even "safe" amounts of this poison just so it will briefly pass by your teeth in its way to your digestive tract. Sounds reckless and extremely disrespectful to me. http://www.fluoridealert.org/toothpaste.html http://www.fluoridealert.org/toothpaste.html
- maxjg 16y agoSo I think what you're trying to say is that it's an international Communist conspiracy to sap and impurify all of our precious bodily fluids?
- narrator 16y agoAnytime anybody brings up fluoride somebody else brings up Dr. StrangeLove, it might as well be a knock knock joke. I wish people would actually look into the science. People thought DDT was unquestionably great too.
- billswift 16y agoBanning DDT was one of the stupider things the government has done. The EPA studies showed no reason for it; the first EPA administrator just up and did it - against the professional scientists' recommendations. Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, which was the original "justification" for it was pure BS.
- arethuza 16y agoI must confess, you have an astonishingly good idea there.
- euccastro 16y agoNo, I'm saying it's a national capitalist trick to save a few bucks by risking your health.
- 16y ago
- prodigal_erik 16y agoThis seems likely to bring a bunch of people to being almost but not quite miserable and hopeless enough to commit suicide, without any plans to ever rescue them from that state. To me that sounds more sadistic than helpful.
- fuzzythinker 16y agoReally, why is this on HN?
- exit 16y agowill the decline in suicide represent people who are no longer depressed, or people who are slightly less depressed but constantly at the edge of committing suicide?
- ivancho 16y agoThe bullshit is strong in this one. Look, I have 4 data points, 2 each in some very psychotic societies. We are going to extrapolate to the entire world and then try and add some psychoactive substances to their water. Seriously, I've been near a couple of politicians - we can totally pull this off.