4 ms·
There's a huge difference between bomb making and crypto. To make a bomb, you need to gather materials and then carry out some difficult, dangerous steps to tur
by mikeash 9y ago
There's a huge difference between bomb making and crypto. To make a bomb, you need to gather materials and then carry out some difficult, dangerous steps to turn them into explosives and assemble a bomb. Then if you want another bomb, you have to do it again. If you want a bigger bomb, you need more materials. Consider that any random person can easily buy some ammonium nitrate, but if you try to buy enough to blow up a building without a legitimate reason, you'll run into major obstacles with the law.
Crypto is different. Once you set up crypto, you have it forever. Crypto that can encrypt 1kB can also encrypt 1TB. Crypto that works for one person can easily be made to work for a million people. Computers handle all the hard parts, and there's no obstacle to scale.
It's true that the government could require big companies to put in a master key. The problem is that criminals would trivially bypass such a requirement. There's no computer equivalent to requiring all ammonium nitrate sellers to report sales. And in the other direction, there's no physical equivalent to the havoc that would occur if the master key ever leaked. The risks and benefits are completely topsy turvy for a master key scheme.
Note that the government doesn't really try to restrict bomb making instructions, just bomb making materials. With crypto, the instructions are the only thing there is. There's no such thing as crypto materials, unless you propose to regulate CPUs in general.
- cmsj 9y agoYou also don't have to build crypto from first principles, we have plenty of reusable software components at all layers of computing, that implement strong crypto.
- mmjaa 9y agoThis whole thing is a straw man. It is we the people who should be dismantling the security state, in order to solve the terror/war problem - we sure as hell don't need career experts dictating this. The public truly needs to fight back on this. Crypto is Math. Broken crypto is broken Math. But Math is broken anyway, because we can't really stop people using Math to hurt us. After Crypto being banned, what next? The Golden Rule? We can't have Math, because "Terrorism". The only solution is an open and honest society, in which sufficient resources are applied, at the human being level, to ensure that terrorism doesn't happen. Like, we could deploy battleships with bombs all we want, but those same battleships would go a long way towards actually making peace in the world, by healing it instead. But, we "can't do that", apparently, because "Threats/Force/Terror are more important". Let we, the people, continue to use crypto to undo the need for such power structures as the NSA, and all the rest of the spooks ..
- jasonjayr 9y ago> There's no computer equivalent to requiring all ammonium nitrate sellers to report sales. Say, perhaps, every processor had a 2nd processor attached, that would run code not modifiable by the owner? With little public information about it's full capabilities? That had full unfettered access to the primary processor, it's memory, and I/O Ports? And insist that it's mandatory to the function of the primary processor? Sounds a lot like Intel'S ME?
- mikeash 9y agoYep, but you're not going to do something like that with all the embedded CPUs out there, and they're still quite capable of crypto.
- rtkwe 9y agoHow does the ME determine if I’m running an encryption algorithm using a legal compromised key vs running illegal encryption with a non compromised key? And more importantly how does this ME turned spy actually determine what is encryption and what isn’t? It’d have to determine on the fly if all the operations on your computer were encryption-like because otherwise just tweaking the code so the outputs are identical but the instructions and memory access are vastly different would completely bypass the ME-snitch.