4 ms·
I've tried to think of something that hardware manufacturers could do to grant access to law enforcement and minimize abuse potential. The best I could come up
by criddell 9y ago
I've tried to think of something that hardware manufacturers could do to grant access to law enforcement and minimize abuse potential.
The best I could come up with would be to make decryption possible iff law enforcement had physical possession of the phone and if the act of decryption would make the phone unusable after (e.g. hardware access requires blowing some fusible links) and if the acquired data was still encrypted with a key that only the device manufacturer can provide.
I'd prefer to see no concessions made, but if decryption is going to be required, it should be expensive, require possession of the device and the cooperation of multiple parties.
- strictnein 9y agoThis type of thing needs to be considered, because I think people are really fooling themselves if they think Apple, et al won't be required to do this within the next 5-10 years. There will be an incident that turns public opinion on this to such a degree that it will be inevitable.
- cortesoft 9y agoHow would it even work? How would some random hardware feature stop me from using PGP in user space?
- coldcode 9y agoNone this sort of thing could only be done in hardware.
- loup-vaillant 9y agoIt wouldn't. But convincing people may be easy. Just wait for the next bomb to go off or something, then say they were using encryption in their communication.
- bo1024 9y agoFor example, by logging all of your keystrokes / input actions and storing them. (edit: this is why people are so concerned about things like Intel ME)
- cortesoft 9y agoLogging them where? Intel ME doesn't have some huge storage location or anything.
- bo1024 9y agoWell, sending them over the network in real time is one option, or if we are talking custom hardware as in this discussion, then it could be made with local storage (and wouldn't need to be all that big...).
- willstrafach 9y agoThat can be blocked. Not to imply that your concern is invalid, but it would be difficult to enforce something like this when a countermeasure can easily be created.
- cortesoft 9y agoSending them over the network would be trivial to detect and block, since you could just look at the outgoing packets on the switch the computer is connected to.
- pjc50 9y agoI've certainly considered proposing this kind of "smash the piggybank" protocol, but it also needs to come with penalties for abuse and mandatory compensation for the value of the device. Otherwise it's going to be just like TSA smashing your luggage.
- cortesoft 9y agoBut what would stop someone from skipping the hardware encryption and just using a different encryption program? It would be technically impossible to prevent someone from using a different encryption scheme that doesn't touch this hardware encryption device.
- criddell 9y agoNothing stops that. It's the same as with the old telephone system. The government can do a wiretap but you are always free to use an encrypting telephone if you are worried about that.