5 ms·
Intuit lobbies against California's free tax filing service
- lurkinggrue 16y agoShouldn't that read "Intuit has no idea how to compete without crying to the government."
- jwhitlark 16y agoWell, in this case it looks like they're competing with the government. Still, I'm not a fan of what they're trying to do. Of course, the Accountant's lobby and Congress have been conspiring to provide lifetime employment for tax preparers for decades, so it's really not anything new. If we really wanted to save money, we'd reform the tax system, not provide band-aids like this program.
- sliverstorm 16y agoUnless we shift to a HIGHLY regressive tax system, I don't see how we can simplify the tax system more than incrementally.
- ams6110 16y agoA tax system with progressive rates does not need to be complicated. The complexity comes from insane number of special taxes and exceptions built into the system in an attempt to manipulate people's behavior or as political favors to certain groups.
- jrockway 16y agoIs this a bad thing? Is saying "we'll give you $5000 off your taxes if you buy a hybrid car" worse than saying "we'll throw you in jail unless you buy a hybrid car"? That's the alternative. (You could argue that we don't need the government because humans are self-organizing and all that, but do we really want to go that far?) Complicated taxes are a necessary evil. But it would be nice if the government just sent me a bill at the end of the year saying "oh hai, write us a check for $12345" and that was the end of it.
- philwelch 16y agoIs there any reason the government couldn't just put a direct $5,000 subsidy on hybrid cars? Or, even better, redesign its infrastructure policy to favor energy efficiency? (Considering all the things the federal government does to encourage cheap gasoline, a $5k tax credit for cars that use slightly less gasoline is nothing.)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Retric 16y agoThe alternative is grants paid to hybrid car manufactures or car dealership or car buyer. The only reason we don't use that far simpler system is government spending that looks like a "tax break" is some sort of fetish among the Republican party. Edit: Democrats often do the same thing, just not to the same extent.
- orangecat 16y agoIs this a bad thing? Is saying "we'll give you $5000 off your taxes if you buy a hybrid car" worse than saying "we'll throw you in jail unless you buy a hybrid car"? That's the alternative. If gas consumption is too high, why not increase the gas tax and let individuals figure out the best way to deal with it? Maybe for some people the best solution is to reduce their commute rather than buy a new car.
- m_eiman 16y agoThat's what we're doing over here in Europe.
- loewenskind 16y ago>That's the alternative. There are vastly more alternatives than that. I'm really surprised to see this post from you. You could leave income tax alone and just add in a big sales tax on non-hybrid cars, for example.
- philwelch 16y agoExample of a progressive, simplified income tax form: IRS FORM A Name: ______________________________________________ Social Security Number: ___-__-____ OR State ID Number: ____________ 1. Total individual income from all sources: Records available to the IRS show your income to be at least $XXXXXXX. _________________ 2. If line 1 is less than $33,000, enter again here. If line 1 is $33,000 or more, enter $33,000 here: Records available to the IRS show this amount to be at least $XXXXXXX. _________________ 3. If line 1 is less than $66,000 but $33,000 or more, subtract $33,000 and enter the difference here. If line 1 is $66,000 or more, enter $33,000 here: Records available to the IRS show this amount to be at least $XXXXXXX. _________________ 4. If line 1 is less than $100,000 but $66,000 or more, subtract $66,000 and enter the difference here. If line 1 is $100,000 or more, enter $34,000 here: Records available to the IRS show this amount to be at least $XXXXXXX. _________________ 5. If line 1 is less than $500,000 but $100,000 or more, subtract $100,000 and enter the difference here. If line 1 is $500,000 or more, enter $400,000 here: Records available to the IRS show this amount to be at least $XXXXXXX. _________________ 6. If line 1 is $500,000 or more, subtract $500,000 and enter the difference here: Records available to the IRS show this amount to be at least $XXXXXXX. _________________ 7. Sum the following: 10% of line 2, 20% of line 3, 25% of line 4, 30% of line 5, and 40% of line 6. THIS IS YOUR TOTAL INCOME TAX. Enter it here: Records available to the IRS show this amount to be at least $XXXXXXX. _________________ 8. Calculate 10% of line 1. THIS IS YOUR TOTAL SOCIAL SECURITY TAX. Enter it here: Records available to the IRS show this amount to be at least $XXXXXXX. _________________ 9. Add lines 7 and 8 here: Records available to the IRS show this amount to be at least $XXXXXXX. __________________ Records available to the IRS show your total tax withholding to be $XXXXXXX. If this is greater than or equal to line 9, you may submit this form for a tax refund. If this is less than line 9, submit this form along with the attached payment form below (IRS FORM P). Submit this form and any necessary payments by April 15. Forms received after April 15 are ineligible for any tax refund. If additional payment is due to the IRS but not received by April 15, penalties will be added to your tax liability, as described on IRS FORM X. FAILURE TO PAY INCOME TAXES IS A FEDERAL CRIMINAL OFFENSE PUNISHABLE BY UP TO 5 YEARS IN PRISON. "Total individual income" includes wages, salaries, tips, revenue from sale of capital assets, stock dividends, and inheritance of cash assets. It does not include acquisition of non-cash assets including real or personal property, securities, or other capital assets. However, any sale or liquidation of non-cash assets may then become subject to income tax. In general, one-time transactions of less than $1,000 may be omitted. Detailed rules are available in IRS DOCUMENT I, available at http://www.irs.gov/documents/i/ or at your local library or post office. For any recurring transactions, or one-time transactions of $1,000 or above, IRS Form R or O should have already been submitted to the IRS. We have enclosed copies of those forms in this mailing. If any of these forms are in error, file a copy of IRS FORM C to appeal for a correction. About one page, and in the best case you just copy down the numbers the IRS already gave you and mail it in after 5 minutes of thought. Note that the exact rate structure is an arbitrary guess on my part, but is even more progressive than the current system.
- ams6110 16y agoIf we really wanted to save money, we'd reform the tax system, not provide band-aids like this program. Exactly! As a taxpayer I want the tax code to be simplified so that I don't need to use a computer or pay someone to prepare my return.
- rdtsc 16y agoBut think about all the starving accountants. Think about their children!!!
- DrJokepu 16y agoThey could compete with the government. They would need better, more integrated products for that than the tool the government offers. But of course, to do that, they would need a vision.
- Aaronontheweb 16y agoThis is somewhat of a silly move for Intuit - the free programs that California aren't something that I, as a California resident, am going to trust, namely because I don't feel that I can get support for it like how I can from Intuit and that I don't think I can hold the state accountable like how I can Intuit in case of a screw-up. I suspect that there are going to be a lot of long-time TurboTax users like me who feel the same way.
- robrenaud 16y agoThere are surely some people using the free services. Presumably with time, the user satisfaction with these programs will increase as bugs get ironed out and word of mouth helps spread them. You seem to believe that just because you will not use the states tax software that no one will, which seems to be a error in generalization. From a profit maximization perspective, I completely understand how Intuit's rent seeking behavior is justified. On the other hand, it almost certainly socially suboptimal.
- Aaronontheweb 16y agoFrom my comment "I suspect that there are going to be A LOT of long-time TurboTax users like me who feel the same way." From yours "You seem to believe that just because you will not use the states tax software that NO ONE will, which seems to be a error in generalization." Seems to me like you made an error in reading comprehension.
- daveungerer 16y agoI think the key issue here is that when a government imposes administrative procedures on its citizens (e.g. tax returns), it should be entirely logical for said government to provide free software that reduces the administrative load. In fact, this should be the norm. You can't accuse the state of anti-competitive behaviour in this case, because the market you're serving wouldn't even exist if they hadn't created tax filing procedures to begin with. Or, as I like to think of it, governments, by necessity, introduce a certain amount of friction into our lives, and have every right to try and reduce that friction. If your business is built on reducing that friction, you simply need to ensure that your service stays ahead of the free service, because your profits are not a right.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- btilly 16y agoYour "clarification" is incorrect. The article claims that the cost of this software is paid for by the fact that tax returns that use this software cost the government less to process than alternatives. So there is nothing but a win here for the taxpayers, they get to save time and money. Of course Intuit isn't happy because they don't get to make a profit on a product that nobody wants to buy.
- lakeeffect 16y agoI dont think this about self interest, Political democracy. I think this is California Hippies significantly price gouging the competition out of its Highest profit margin customers. And Big Business is like you are price gouging us, when we are suppose to be price gouging them. Those customers that are the quick and easy returns, might file themselves through the state. I would imagine consumers general risk aversion with regards to government oversight would be the determinate for logical consumers adoption of these government goods with a relevant weight with regards to the price savings and the resulting of a comparable net return. If the california system is off in its returns or doesn't produce returns similar results as previous year. The customer is going to intuit next time. The false positive is the trick for Califronia to catch in order to make their system a success. The guy that had someone doing his taxes for years. Really basic, but now that guy started a business, or bought a house and the deductions are not standardized enough for the flag to call a higher level of deductions. This guy uses the system for years and now he finds out from his friend that intuit does it much better, and tax preparation service steps in and wham.. They have a wow loyalty customer. This is just market signaling that the actuary boys at Intuit think that the free deal is going to be a winner for customers. Or false signaling, you tell me.
- lakeeffect 16y agoWas it the hippi or big business building tools for small business that generally offended you. Resulting in the downing voting of the analysis. For it is definitely sound.
- sandGorgon 16y agoIs Calfile or ReadyReturn open source ? This would be a great asset in deploying similar systems in... say.. developing nations.
- loewenskind 16y agoSilly. I would expect the pay services to still have an advantage because most people are probably going to expect a free government service to not highlight all the potential tax breaks for you. But given Intuit has taken this tact, perhaps they don't work as hard as they should be to justify their cost...