4 ms·
Eben Moglen is no longer a friend of the free software community
- snvzz 9y agoWhile there might be actually something to it, article lacks so much in detail it's hard to do anything else with it than dismiss it whole. When trying to denounce a person, it's not OK to be glossing over the details to this extent. Pretty much reads as "You can't trust Eben Moglen because I say so."
- ibotty 9y agoIt is Matthew J Garrett's personal blog. He was a member of the EFF and has publicly been involved in the free software community.
- snvzz 9y agoBoth him and Eben are well known. Why should I listen to one over the other? "You can't trust him. Trust me."
- cmiles74 9y agoEben Moglen also has some very real credentials, I don't think that makes it reasonable to take someone's claims at face value. I, too, would like some more details on the issues. The interpretation of the GPL around ZFS is something I believe reasonable people may disagree upon. The claim that he has harassed and threatened people is much more serious, in my opinion, and deserving of some real evidence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eben_Moglen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eben_Moglen
- Operyl 9y agoI dislike articles that allude to wrong doings, but when pushed for more details on rather harsh allegations, refuse to state it. I have no way to verify it happened, and I have to take someone’s possible lie as the one sided truth. EDIT: I'm referring to: "Around the same time, Eben made legal threats towards another project with ties to FSF."
- jordigh 9y agoLinks are provided. For example, the SFLC trying to invalidate SFC's trademark: https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2017/nov/03/sflc-legal-action/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2017/nov/03/sflc-legal-action... This is bizarre to say the least.
- Operyl 9y agoI was referring to: "Around the same time, Eben made legal threats towards another project with ties to FSF."
- jordigh 9y agoWell, that's the exact reference: Eben has sent threats to terminate SFC's trademark. Those are the legal threats.
- carussell 9y agoI think parent poster is referring to this paragraph in particular: > Throughout this period, Eben disparaged FSF staff and other free software community members in various semi-public settings. In doing so he harmed the credibility of many people who have devoted significant portions of their lives to aiding the free software community. At Libreplanet earlier this year he made direct threats against an attendee - this was reported as a violation of the conference's anti-harassment policy. The reason I think this is because when I opened the article there were zero comments here, and after reading the post, I clicked through back here to leave a comment much the same as the one you're responding to. A couple remarks: I'm aware who Matthew Garrett is, and I respect him and his contributions and his overall stance, in that way where when you see someone's name attached to something, it automatically kicks off good feelings. Having said that, we need a term for something like this. (One probably exists.) Wikipedia popularized "weasel words", but this is something more specialized. Something like "proxy words", where rather than tell someone the things that happened, you give them this sort of non-specific, pre-digested proxy for people to derive their judgment from. It operates on almost the same principle as strawman arguments. It may be a good proxy, or it may not be, but for good reason you should always favor reserving your judgment for the real issue when presented with a proxy, rather than accepting the proxy itself. That aside, Bruce Perens's comments in the following two LWN threads are relevant to the overall discussion: https://lwn.net/Articles/738046/ https://lwn.net/Articles/738046/ https://lwn.net/Articles/738279/ https://lwn.net/Articles/738279/
- craigsmansion 9y agoIt's a sad and bewildering affair. My most innocent interpretation of the events is that Eben got seduced by "big picture" thinking: the thought takes hold that there are actions that are against ones principles, but will result in so much popularity and influence that it will be easy to undo the wrongs and still enjoy the fruits of the shortcut to success. History has shown this hardly ever works out (Lindows, Red Hat, ESR, Ubuntu, etc) as intended. It's probably too hard to transfer a fairly complex philosophy by attempting to temporarily raise its popularity.
- jordigh 9y agoStallman calls this ruinous compromise: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/compromise.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/compromise.html
- ibotty 9y ago> It's a sad and bewildering affair. Yes. Eben's departure from free software ideology left "many heartbroken": Bruce Perens, ESR, Bradley Kuhn, MJG.
- zantana 9y agoEben recently had his one day conference the videos of which are here: https://softwarefreedom.org/events/2017/conference/video/ https://softwarefreedom.org/events/2017/conference/video/ If you look at his closing remarks (the last video) he mentions that he mentions being less combative as a strategy to reach more people. I suspect this comes down to less being the same side than having different tactics.