3 ms·
Young people were excluded from the referendum vote. Certain demographics living outside of the UK - who are normally allowed to vote in elections - were exclu
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
Young people were excluded from the referendum vote.
Certain demographics living outside of the UK - who are normally allowed to vote in elections - were excluded from the referendum vote.
A non-trivial number of ballots for foreign residents were sent out too late to be counted.
The original Parliamentary Act for the referendum explicitly defined it as advisory.
Most referenda are run on the basis that a super-majority is required for any significant constitutional change.
The suggestion that the referendum was truly representative and binding is an horrific travesty of democracy.
- blibble 9y agoI don't think you could be more intellectually dishonest if you tried > Young people were excluded from the referendum vote. same franchise as a general election, and the past AV referendum > Certain demographics living outside of the UK - who are normally allowed to vote in elections - were excluded from the referendum vote. same franchise as a general election, and the past AV referendum > A non-trivial number of ballots for foreign residents were sent out too late to be counted. too few to have have changed the outcome (Leave had a majority of more than 1.2 million) > The original Parliamentary Act for the referendum explicitly defined it as advisory. the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty means it is impossible to have a truly binding referendum: they are all advisory as nothing can bind parliament, even a referendum result > Most referenda are run on the basis that a super-majority is required for any significant constitutional change. all past UK referendums have been 50%+1, as was the Scottish independence referendum you might not like the result, but it was still perfectly legitimate
- tom_mellior 9y ago> it is impossible to have a truly binding referendum: they are all advisory as nothing can bind parliament, even a referendum result That may be the case in theory: Even if Parliament made a law saying a referendum was binding, it could later undo it. But they didn't even pretend it was binding, although there was a precedent from the alternative vote referendum, which was explicitly binding according to the act authorizing it. That also would have saved all the High Court hoopla that followed.
- Silhouette 9y agoThat isn't a very strong argument. The enabling legislation for the referendum infamously didn't say anything about the specific consequences of a decision either way. In particular, and contrary to comments by someone else in this discussion, it also didn't say anything specific about being binding or not on any specific party to do any specific thing. However, in the debates on the legislation, MP after MP, up to and including government ministers, stood up in the House and said that they intended to give voters the final say in the decision. You can read this in Hansard, and it was really very clear what those MPs thought they were voting for. The leaflet, distributed to all households in the UK by the government at taxpayers' expense, also gave a very clear and unambiguous statement to the same effect. Absent evidence to the contrary, it seems reasonable to assume that ordinary people voting in the referendum also thought they were voting for what had been described in the official information about it. The whole non-binding issue only really hit the headlines after the fact, when it started to look like the losing side in the referendum's best opportunity to overturn the result. That's also the time when lots of people in the UK who weren't constitutional lawyers suddenly started being experts on parliamentary sovereignty. (If you want to really heat up a discussion, ask some of those people where the principle of parliamentary sovereignty comes from, throw in a few difficult questions about whether it has any robust legal foundation or democratic authority at all, and then point out that even if it does the principle itself has nothing to do with Parliament being sovereign over the people but rather over other branches of the government.) I'm actually a moderate when it comes to Brexit itself, but I do have an intense dislike of using sophistry to undermine democracy and civilised government, and I'm sorry to say that there has been more of that than I've seen at any time in my adult life since the Brexit issue became so divisive.
- tom_mellior 9y ago> That isn't a very strong argument. Not sure what you're referring to. The fact that there was precedent that MPs could have copied and pasted to be on the safe side and avoid the Supreme Court having to decide? It's their job to make good laws, not just to give speeches suggesting what their unwritten intentions may be. > The leaflet, distributed to all households in the UK by the government at taxpayers' expense, also gave a very clear and unambiguous statement Yes, but as we know, the entire point of the court case was that that statement was not the government's to give. > The whole non-binding issue only really hit the headlines after the fact That may well be, but it does not invalidate the legal argument behind it. Don't take my word for it. Don't take the words of "lots of people in the UK who weren't constitutional lawyers". Take the Supreme Court's. Do you really think its ruling is "using sophistry to undermine democracy and civilised government"? I understand that you dislike the way these debates have developed. I don't understand why you don't blame this on the MPs who had the power to prevent it.
- Tech-Noir 9y ago> Most referenda are run on the basis that a super-majority is required for any significant constitutional change. What percentage was required in the Scottish independence referendum? What percentage was required in the EU/EC exit/remain referendum of 1975? What percentage was required in the referendum to join the EU/EC in the first place, in 1973? (The latter being a trick question. There was no referendum to join at all, zero, yet a majority being required (and achieved) to leave is deemed a "horrific travesty of democracy" by people who voted differently.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]