4 ms·
The idea that Article 50 is unilaterally reversible is an odd one. I know that one of the people that helped write it says it was written with that intent, but
by Nursie 9y ago
The idea that Article 50 is unilaterally reversible is an odd one. I know that one of the people that helped write it says it was written with that intent, but the wording gives no indication or mechanism to reverse it.
And if it is unilaterally reversible, surely that's a really bad thing? There are two reasons I can think of for that. Firstly, countries might start to use it as a form of leverage and brinkmanship in order to extract concessions or exert their will over the EU. And secondly, if the EU doesn't want a country to leave for whatever reason, it's a huge incentive to stall and mess up any sort of talks or prospective trading relationship in order to scare them or force their hands. Basically it allows for a lot more "playing politics" and makes for a far less honest exit process.
A retraction of A 50 followed by a multilateral vote to accept or reject that reversion, I can see that working.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoPractically speaking, if the United Kingdom on January 1st, 2019 declares its previous Article 50 declaration was unlawfully issued, I have a hard time seeing the EU gathering the stomach to essentially enforce sanctions against the United Kingdom. This could all end up being a weird "did you know Britain isn't technically in the EU?" factoid in a hundred years.
- Nursie 9y ago>> Practically speaking, if the United Kingdom on January 1st, 2019 declares its previous Article 50 declaration was unlawfully issued I'm not quite sure how that would work, given article 50 was issued after an act of parliament.
- blibble 9y agothe Act in question: http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2017/9/pdfs/ukpga_20170009_en.pdf http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2017/9/pdfs/ukpga_201700... very simple and unambiguous saying that, the UK parliament can declare things to be unlawful retroactively, so it's possible just at "bernie can still win" levels of possibility
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> article 50 was issued after an act of parliament I think everyone believes the Article 50 declaration was properly done. But proper isn't politics. Parliament can say whatever it wants. If on March 30th, 2019 Britain says it's in the EU, a disagreeing EU member would need to begin enforcing customs, tariffs, et cetera. If nobody, or nobody who matters, does that the rule goes unenforced. It reminds me of an oversight in the North Dakota Constitution, which did not contain a clause required for accession [1]. (It was later added.) Laws are just codified conventions; the EU has an enforcement problem in that it cannot enforce, only its member states can. [1] http://newsfeed.time.com/2011/07/14/because-of-constitution-error-north-dakota-is-not-a-state-and-never-has-been/ http://newsfeed.time.com/2011/07/14/because-of-constitution-...
- fleitz 9y agoExactly, the EU and UK are soveriegns, they'll do whatever they want, lots of countries ratified EU treaties after their populations voted against it. The same can happen in reverse. The EU wants to heavily penalize the UK to prevent others from leaving. Similar, to how in Vancouver the federal gov't says pot is illegal, but no one will ever bust you for it.
- PeachPlum 9y agosee also: Presented to Parliament by the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs by Command of Her Majesty, February 2016 2.1 The result of the referendum on the UK’s membership of the European Union will be final.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoGenuine question, what does that line mean? Is it saying, the UK will have to leave the EU (for whatever definition of "leave") if that side of the vote wins. Is it saying that the UK cannot change its mind ever i.e. it cannot rejoin even after a change of governtment and a second referendum?. Or is it just saying, the result of the vote is the result?
- namelost 9y agoIt was a government policy, not a law. It is basically meaningless.
- pknight 9y agoIt is only odd in that it gives a leaving member that changes it mind some leverage against the EU, an escape hatch effectively. The author of the document and others have also admitted that nobody thought the document would ever be put to use - it is not a battle tested document. And it's silent on whether it can be unilaterally revoked or not. But as a matter of law the weight of opinion leans in favour of the option of unilateral revocation as long as it meets the principle of sincere cooperation. Unilateral revocation as a means of extracting additional concessions runs foul of that, so it really only works if it is part of a genuine u-turn. Imagine though if the leaving member decided to revoke A50 as a means of resetting the negotiation or forcing the EU into concessions: it wouldn't work. Any subsequent attempt to withdraw by the member will be met with a much harsher EU. No additional legal devices are needed to drive this home. The EU can decide to impose bigger concessions, more conditions and higher costs to any future agreement. The leaving member needs a deal at some point, so the EU will always have the upper hand here they are just more likely to raise the costs on the leaving member if it engages in such shenanigans.
- Nursie 9y agoAll of which is more room for playing politics, rather than the purpose which seemed obvious to me - a statement that a state is in the process of leaving the EU, which allows for a period of time for parties to negotiate the most advantageous future relationship for both of them. When you change it from that pure form, you give opportunity for all sorts of perverse motivations to creep in.
- pknight 9y agoPerhaps but there are plenty of scenarios in which unilateral revocation of an intent to leave is entirely justified. What if a band of member states block a reasonable deal from happening even against the interest of the other member states? What if the leaving member endures a change in government and comes to a different view? What if unilateral revocation is the only means to save millions of jobs and avoid economic carnage? And what protections would the leaving member have (still a fully signed up paying member during the 2 year time frame mind you) if the EU27 wasn't negotiating in good faith?