5 ms·
I first encountered GTD in 2007. After about 8 years of trying, I finally accepted that GTD didn't work for me. I think any workflow management has to be tailo
by BeetleB 9y ago
I first encountered GTD in 2007. After about 8 years of trying, I finally accepted that GTD didn't work for me.
I think any workflow management has to be tailored to your personality. I digged that from the start and did not fall into the trap of being 100% David Allen compliant.
Some of my issues:
- My lists grow long. Way too long. I recall he suggests looking at the Someday/Maybe during the weekly review. That just overwhelmed me.
- Not enough attention is paid upon "upkeep". I know you're supposed to clean things out every week, but it was a lot of work, and mentally draining. David Allen did not seriously address cognitive load.
- I could never work out a system to handle "Waiting For" tasks. Managing it all on paper was impossible. And software never seemed to get it right.
- Although he talks about the 10000 ft view, etc - I felt he didn't give any real advice on looking at the bigger picture. GTD is an excellent way of focusing on minor projects while neglecting major ones. One needs to prioritize, and he just expects you to prioritize somehow.
Those are the ones I remember off the top of my head.
It definitely was not a waste of time, though. Some positives that came out of it:
- Not treating your Inbox as a TODO list
- Getting a filing cabinet (this paid dividends immediately)
- Making me learn more about org-mode customization in my attempts to implement GTD in it.
- Self knowledge about what works for me and what doesn't.
GTD is the flow that everyone goes through before encountering what works for them.
I later discovered the One Minute Todo List (http://www.michaellinenberger.com/TheOneMinuteTo-DoList-Ebook.pdf http://www.michaellinenberger.com/TheOneMinuteTo-DoList-Eboo...). This filled in a lot of the gaps in GTD. His explanation of work stress in his book was very relevant to me.
However, even that didn't fully work for me, and I continue on my quest.
Lately, the thing I'm realizing one thing: As long as I don't control my inputs, nothing will work for me. Inputs are things like:
- Work my boss gives me
- RSS/Facebook/Twitter/News feeds
- Email
- Pretty much anything else that feeds into your TODO lists
Allowing a lot of stuff to get in to your inbox (GTD inbox, not email inbox) will make managing it much harder. Take a deep look at what category of items get in there, and start applying limits. I'm experimenting doing that with email by making incoming email based on whitelist only: If the sender's address is not in my whitelist, it will not show up in my inbox, and the the sender will get an email with instructions on how to get their quarantined email into my inbox (i.e. prove there is a human behind the email) as well as their email address in my whitelist.
- Tempest1981 9y agoWhat's a good tool for managing the various lists/projects? I've tried Google Docs, Apple Notes, and Txt files. I'm good at making giant "inboxes". From there I move them into 20-30 separate files, but it's tedious -- trying to find the right GDocs tab in Chrome. Then it's hard to pick out the top must-do items from the 20-30 lists.
- BeetleB 9y ago>What's a good tool for managing the various lists/projects? I've tried Google Docs, Apple Notes, and Txt files. Dunno, frankly. I use Org Mode. It's good enough. Others use TaskWarrior. >Then it's hard to pick out the top must-do items from the 20-30 lists. Which gets to my point of "If you don't limit inputs, nothing will work". I mean, you can make it work if you have huge lists, but your system will be heavy on maintenance. So for me the challenge isn't "How do I handle so much data?" but "How do I make sure my lists are not long?" I'm debating switching to anti-TODO lists. Decide my focus for the next month/year/whatever. Pick a few projects I want to do in them. Everything else (incoming or in existing lists) go into a "Do not do" list. Once I'm done with my current projects, I'll examine that "Do not do" list and decide on another project. This way I don't spend too much time babysitting lists. Yet another system to try.
- Tempest1981 9y agoI think GTD has the concept of a "Maybe Someday" list. Edit: or "Someday Maybe": https://facilethings.com/blog/en/someday-maybes https://facilethings.com/blog/en/someday-maybes
- dredmorbius 9y agoOrg mode or index cards, for me.