4 ms·
A thing is what it does. What you label it with isn't anywhere near as important as what it does. In practice, these "nations" appear to be nothing more than s
by jerf 16y ago
A thing is what it does. What you label it with isn't anywhere near as important as what it does.
In practice, these "nations" appear to be nothing more than special interest groups. Special interest groups already tend to expand well beyond their original goals in the political arena. That doesn't work because the active leadership takes over and speaks for the public; why these would avoid that, I don't know. So, the solution to too many special interest groups is more special interest groups.
Also, I think he uses "Tea Party" like bogeymen. To the extent the movement involves cutting government down, it will actually increase the scope of agreement within the government by cutting down the number of domains in which there is disagreement. In fact, my personal prescription for where we are right now is for a significant return of power to the states. Some things have to be national-scale policy, but the list is much shorter than you think. We don't need a national-scale health care plan. Many of our states are larger than European countries that manage. State plans already exist. We don't need national agreement on any given social issue. If we weren't centralizing all our power, we wouldn't have to spend so much time arguing what the central policy should be.
The other major problem these sort of idealistic ideas have is that it basically promises everybody that it will bring the world closer to their viewpoint, but that can't actually happen. Right now, for better or worse, our government is more liberal than our population, so if your plan is to push our government yet more liberal by empowering the population, err, well, you might want to rethink that plan.
- _pi 16y agoAnother good point about his strategy is that he derives almost everything from the feel good feeling of "You're on the internet, I'm on the internet You can trust me." This is no different than candidates touting their religious affiliation. We're all on the internet, in fact I don't know a person who isn't, and many of those people that I know don't share my politics, let alone my views on life. And most importantly the people who are in the Tea Party also use the Internet. Here's the problem with his concept of nations, look at the UN. Look at congress, they are all abstracts of general political distributions. All of the deadlock, ALL the time. Why? Because there's going to always be a pro-coffee and an anti-coffee nation/interest group/campaign. Sean Tevis can't fix human nature with any amount of money.
- Locke1689 16y agoIn fact, my personal prescription for where we are right now is for a significant return of power to the states. Some things have to be national-scale policy, but the list is much shorter than you think. We don't need a national-scale health care plan. Many of our states are larger than European countries that manage. State plans already exist. We don't need national agreement on any given social issue. If we weren't centralizing all our power, we wouldn't have to spend so much time arguing what the central policy should be. I think you actually underestimate the complexities here. The problem isn't number of people -- you're correct, many states are as large as European countries. However, the states don't have nearly as much self-governing power (as granted by the Constitution) as European countries. In things like healthcare, this makes a big difference. For example, one of the biggest benefits to the federal government is that it can temporarily run a budget deficit during hard times. There are innumerable times (including now) when that would be necessary for a large swath of public services. It would require a rather huge change in federal law in order to make this work on the state level. Another problem you would get is massive problems with the full-faith-and-credit clause. All in all, it may be worth considering that, accounting for modern high-speed transportation and intercommunication and trade, strong states may be an antiquated idea. Right now, for better or worse, our government is more liberal than our population That's difficult to argue. Notably, consider that one person's vote in Wyoming counts 67 times more than a Californian's in the US Senate and 1.264 times a Californian's in the House of Representatives.
- tomjen3 16y agoFor what it is worth Denmark runs a deficit now, and I doubt there is a single state in the US that is anywhere as tiny as Denmark. Granted the Danish economy is more sound than, say California but still.
- randomtask 16y agoThe population of Denmark is 5.5 million, which if it were a US state, would make it the 21st largest state.
- Locke1689 16y ago
- stevis 16y agoNonsense. I'll reply at the top level though so i can answer other's questions, too.
- asnyder 16y agoWhile it's true that a handful of states have health plans, it would be advantageous to have a federal health plan, due to economies of scale. Furthermore, a federal health plan would ensure some consistency from state to state, making it easier to choose between health care, or your livelihood. Remember, some of us were cursed with poor genetics and are a guaranteed loss for any health insurance company. Your statement suggesting that the government is more liberal than the population is unfounded. Recall, in the last Presidential election Barack Obama won on the currently enacted platform by a significant percentage. Furthermore, if people were actually aware and educated in political issues, it's my opinion that the country would lean more leftward. The only reason why any network or news source can possibly suggest the country is a center-right country is due to the vast perpetual amounts of mis-information and political propaganda. It's also my opinion that the "Tea Party" are bogeyman. Their entire platform is empty of anything constructive, instead the platform seeks to incite, destroy, and push people apart. One need only look at Tea Party donor records to see who the Tea Party truly represents.
- anamax 16y ago> One need only look at Tea Party donor records to see who the Tea Party truly represents. How about a link?
- asnyder 16y agoI'm sorry, I didn't realize it was necessary to make it so convenient for you. I expect the readers of HN are capable of doing Google searches or browsing through http://www.opensecrets.org/ http://www.opensecrets.org/. Next time I'll be sure to include a complete list of references.
- natep 16y agoWhile you have been around HN longer than I have, I believe the general feeling of HN is that the burden of proof is on the claimant, which would be you. So yes, please do include a list of references next time.
- rmc 16y agoI find anti-health care movement in America strange. In 50 years time it'll be political suicide to suggest removing it. Much like the 1960s civil rights acts, they were opposed at the time, but will be viewed as important by everyone in a few decades.