2 ms·
It's hard to take seriously because they take a story about Apple getting the phone out a year early as somehow demonstrating that Apple hadn't properly studied
by mikeash 9y ago
It's hard to take seriously because they take a story about Apple getting the phone out a year early as somehow demonstrating that Apple hadn't properly studied how the security of Face ID compares with Touch ID. It's a total non sequitur.
There's no such thing as "a secure device." There are devices which offer various levels and types of security. If you're a CIA officer carrying classified secrets on your device, you probably don't want to use Face ID. For the average user, it's a nice increase in security.
- coldtea 9y ago>It's hard to take seriously because they take a story about Apple getting the phone out a year early as somehow demonstrating that Apple hadn't properly studied how the security of Face ID compares with Touch ID. It's a total non sequitur. Non sequitur? Sounds like a totally rational argument to me, to the point of being a tautology. Rushed a feature to market by one year == they also rushed the testing.
- mikeash 9y agoThere are a lot of holes in your equation there. Apple never said they rushed the phone. They said they were able to get it out early. These are not the same thing; "rushed" implies that quality suffered, while merely getting it out early could just be due to work going faster than anticipated. Even if the phone as a whole was "rushed," that doesn't mean Face ID was. Maybe it was naturally ready by now. Even if Face ID was rushed, that doesn't mean that the security aspects were rushed. Even if Face ID's security aspects were rushed, that doesn't mean testing was rushed. It's like if you show up early to a meeting and so I accuse you of speeding. Is that sensible?
- coldtea 9y ago>It's like if you show up early to a meeting and so I accuse you of speeding. Is that sensible? No, but it is sensible to consider that if they've estimated 2018 themselves as the initial release date and then put it out in 2017, they didn't "made it naturally" but rather rushed it. I don't say that's 100% proven or anything. But it's very sensible to consider -- in other words plausible. It might be "rushing to conclusions" but it's totally not a "non sequitur", since evidence in support is there, even if you find it lacking.
- mikeash 9y ago> I don't say that's 100% proven or anything. You previously said it was "to the point of being a tautology."
- lolsal 9y agoHow do you know they rushed features to market instead of dropping other features which we don't even know about because they were dropped? Isn't this exactly how people want agile products delivered?
- hungerstrike 9y agoIt's hard to take Apple seriously about Face ID when it's now obvious that security wasn't the goal at all. Face ID is a gimmick to keep attention on the iPhone.
- mikeash 9y agoIn what way is that "obvious"?
- hungerstrike 9y agoEvery single review that I've read has mentioned that it does not work 100% of the time that the reviewer expected it to. That's the first thing that makes it obvious to me because they chose to champion something that does not work over something that does. Biometric security implementations are all gimmicky. The second thing is their claims and their focus on marketing around security. This was easily beaten in its first week in the real world! So it's not really that secure is it? The third thing is that Apple has a long history of choosing gimmicks over actual functionality. The OS X dock is just one example of this.
- mikeash 9y agoNot working 100% of the time when it ought to is evidence that they do care about security. There's always a tradeoff between false positives and false negatives in these systems. Favoring false positives is better for usability, and favoring false negatives is better for security. The most usable biometric system in the world would be one that's hardcoded to return "success" no matter what. The second thing means they maybe didn't succeed to the extent they wanted to, but certainly doesn't tell us that security wasn't even a goal. The third thing is irrelevant to the question at hand.
- mikestew 9y agoEvery single review that I've read has mentioned that it does not work 100% of the time that the reviewer expected it to. Neither does TouchID, and you’ll pry that from my cold, dead, fingers, one of which will probably be hovering over the TouchID sensor.