4 ms·
Granted, I didn't read the whole article, but I didn't really get how the author went from "authors write about advanced Nazi societies that are clearly oppress
by StavrosK 9y ago
Granted, I didn't read the whole article, but I didn't really get how the author went from "authors write about advanced Nazi societies that are clearly oppressive and evil" to "authors want Nazi societies". Can someone explain? Right now it seems to me that the article has some gaping holes (the average alt-right is a 20-something male working in IT, but so is the average libertarian).
- oblio 9y ago> average alt-right is a 20-something male working in IT How so? Or is it just because "alt-right" is an internet construct, normal people just call them "far-right"?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- StavrosK 9y agoI don't really know, that's what the article claimed. It seems odd to me, but I guess they have their sources? But yeah, over here we usually call them "neo-Nazis", as there's a lot of overlap.
- candiodari 9y agoI've only heard that term used to refer to groups in Western Europe. Those groups, incidentally, are very different from what is called the "alt-right" online.
- StavrosK 9y agoVery possibly (I'm from Greece, and Golden Dawn are Neo-Nazis). What's the difference between them and alt-right?
- candiodari 9y agoWell for one thing, they alt-right hate the association with Nazis, whereas Neonazi groups in Western Europe are quite open about that connection. They talk and glorify Hitler, (often publicly, which is where a lot of problems are created), profess their hate on Jews, give the Nazi salute, etc. They don't have much of an economic agenda, if any at all, whereas the online groups such as the alt-right are defined by their economic agenda. Neo-Nazis are also much more like the Nazis were: they are a youth movement. Most of what they do is not all that political. They organize parties. They go to soccer matches. They organize ping pong tournaments. They have biker clubs/gangs. They hang out in cafes. (I'm talking about North West Europe, don't know about Golden Dawn) The alt right is much more about extreme laissez-faire, associated with the republican party (Tea Party, etc). You have the same group on the left, sometimes referred to as the alt-left (as in associated with democrats), but the ideology is the same, they're about extreme laissez-faire and small government. Of course this is "very different" from the alt-right. Except, other than the association with the other large US party I can't find any real difference. The funny thing is that of course anti-immigration attitudes (immigration, the concept of moving countries, as opposed to immigrants, the people), historically, was far more associated with the left than the right. You can understand the reasoning too: if the state is to control worker outcomes, then of course the state must strictly control competition. Otherwise, companies simply undercut eachother by hiring cheap labour overseas. So the State must tightly control the borders, for goods and for people, so as to prevent that from happening. Immigration, which directly affects the most important market that socialists want to control, the labour market, must be very tightly controlled if the government is to succeed. I would even go so far as to say it makes very little sense, even today, for ostensibly leftist parties to be pro-open-borders. That is in direct opposition to their stated aims and clearly (and strongly) works against their stated aims. But of course the solution to that conundrum is simple : the entirety of the US is simply extreme-right, extreme laissez-faire. Including Obama, of course, who "nationalized" healthcare into a private sector solution (leftists worldwide went WTF), and spent (sorry "loaned") almost 8 trillion dollars of government money to keep capitalism running.
- StavrosK 9y agoThat's very insightful, thank you for the explanation.
- candiodari 9y agoThe author seems to be complaining that this society isn't sufficiently depicted as morally abhorrent. The "alt-right", according to the article's author, is complaining that it's too much depicted as such. In reality the author is trying to defend the absurd point that Nazis put existing corporate leadership in charge of the economy. This seems to be a veiled attempt to depict both the current administration, full of business leaders, and proposals of libertarians to put Silicon Valley business leadership in charge of the government as Nazis. This is absurd. Like all socialist totalitarians, Nazis put government bureaucrats in charge of corporations entirely, rather than the other way around. Both left "middle management" in place for a while, but of course soon those bureaucrats realize that positions are the new currency and start trading them, so managers get replaced and it becomes a true government company, like the railways. There are many huge differences between, say, Russia's communism and the Third Reich, but this is not one of them. Nazis, like all totalitarian socialists, believe that their ideology should totally determine all actions by everyone, everywhere, about everything. As a simple banal illustration: both Nazism and Communism (and other forms of real socialism) required jokes to be approved. Jokes, just used in a conversation between 2 people. You cannot imagine how normal this was: both had government bureaucrats whose job it was to compile acceptable things to say to neighbors and publish this information. They both had government rules about what kinds of hats were acceptable, and you could get arrested for even just getting it wrong. Scientific efforts by the Nazis were exceptional in many ways, but not how they were funded. The thing people forget about Nazis is that they were incredibly popular, especially amongst the young crowd. People in high schools, people going to universities, people creating new and exiting "startups". That was their base. Conservatives were their big (real) enemy.
- StavrosK 9y agoThank you, that seems like a good analysis of the article. It does, indeed, sound absurd.