4 ms·
Don't worry, we are working on robots that will replace these employees. Then they'll not even have what to eat. On a serious note, I don't think this is Amazo
by csomar 9y ago
Don't worry, we are working on robots that will replace these employees. Then they'll not even have what to eat.
On a serious note, I don't think this is Amazon issue. Stop blaming individual companies. You can't expect them not to compete and cut costs.
It is the responsibility of the government to set and enforce the minimum wage and provide social services for the lower tier.
- subway 9y agoIt's everyone's responsibility.
- csomar 9y agoThat's exactly my point. You can't expect people to behave, let alone corporations. You have to regulate them.
- subway 9y agoMy point is societal pressure doesn't have to end with laws. If a company wants to play the 'but-it-isnt-illegal' game, they should still be subject to suffering a rejection by the public, and as members of the public, we have a moral obligation to reject those companies.
- csomar 9y agoThat would have worked if people did really act on "I don't consume from non-responsible company". But people pick cheapest, or nicest, or trendiest. They don't give a crap about the company practices.
- krapp 9y agoThe problem is, society interacts with companies as consumers, not citizens. Markets optimize for price and convenience, not ethical business practices, and market forces speak louder than societal pressure. Unless Amazon does something to spark mass outrage on the scale of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire, then society is going to be happy as long as they get their Kindles and Echos delivered on time.
- coldtea 9y ago>On a serious note, I don't think this is Amazon issue. Stop blaming individual companies. You can't expect them not to compete and cut costs. Well, I can very much expect them -- and chose to do business with companies that do care. But true, the social protection/minimum wage should also be set by law. Only that's a minimum limit -- I expect better than that. In the end, I don't want businesses that merely say "compete to the full and fuck everything else".
- csomar 9y ago> Well, I can very much expect them -- and chose to do business with companies that do care. I'm 100% certain that most people will go with "cheapest" or "more convenient" regardless.
- coldtea 9y agoMost people would also kill other people if it was not for the inconvenience of being caught -- as they also harass, bully, and lots of other things. Not the best criterion, what most would do. Especially since it's more like "what most would do given a society that raised them like we do and given them the motives that we do".
- bjelkeman-again 9y agoNo. Most people would not kill, that is BS.
- dragonsky67 9y agoIf that is the case in your community, then I'm glad I don't live there. I believe most places in the world, even some of the poorest and most desperate set a higher standard than "kill to survive". Given a chance most people will naturally form communities that will try to protect themselves from harm. Destructive behaviour is not a forgone conclusion and as soon as people start to understanding this they will stop being scared of their neighbours.
- ImSkeptical 9y ago
- Finnucane 9y agoRight. “It’s a business” excuses all behavior. It’s all good as long as it makes a profit! I’m sure that made I.G. Farben’s managers sleep better during WWII.
- everdev 9y agoToxic work environments eventually change or fail. If talented people don't like it there they'll leave. If consumers don't like the company they'll stop supporting it. There are other economic systems, but that's how capitalism works.
- coldtea 9y ago>Toxic work environments eventually change or fail. How soon that happens? Because it worked wonders for Walmart or McDonalds all these years. >If talented people don't like it there they'll leave. That would only matter if their operation depended on talented people. Which is not really required for McDonalds, Walmart, or Amazon (at the order handling side). At best, those companies have to keep upper management and logistics people happy -- and can continue to screw the replaceable workers forever. >If consumers don't like the company they'll stop supporting it. Most of the masses don't care as long as the price is right. Few stopped buying Nike after the sweatshop complaints, at best they took their "word" that the issue has been solved (and they just moved manufacturing around through various third world countries and added more plausible deniability layers). The hundreds of millions of lower middle class and poorer people have the same problems themselves in their jobs, which makes them thing that is just how things are. The companies know how to put on a "humane" facade, and lots of jobs are not even public facing (the customer wont ever see an Amazon warehouse). And their friends, the media, were they advertise, will give them all the good public relations they need.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoThats not how capitalism works, thats what the theory predicts. The sibling comment has plenty of examples of it not working. Anyone who knows just enough econ to be dangerous quotes this kind of crap without acknowledging all the counterexamples we see in the world. Experiment & Observation > Theory.
- sumedh 9y ago> I don't think this is Amazon issue. Stop blaming individual companies. People in Amazon's warehouses were fainting because of heat and exhaustion. They finally installed an AC after protests.