4 ms·
I get where you're going with this, and think it's a great question. But I don't think it's as plausible as you do. It's possible that a massive musical AI/idi
by wpietri 9y ago
I get where you're going with this, and think it's a great question. But I don't think it's as plausible as you do.
It's possible that a massive musical AI/idiot savant could eventually produce an infinite amount of pleasant background music sans lyrics. But for music people are actually listening to, I don't think we're anywhere close.
But even if you're right, it won't matter. When Prince and David Bowie died, people weren't primarily upset because there would be no new songs in a particular style. It was because they'd formed a deep emotional connection to the artist. To the artist's personality as expressed both through their music and through their presence in the world. As another example, hip hop and Latin music are valuable to me not just for the sounds, but for the window into cultures that I didn't grow up in. I don't just enjoy the tune.
What you're really talking about is not just AlphaSong, but something close to solving the Strong AI problem so well that you can create totally believable synthetic characters. At best you situate a synthetic mind in a real culture, which I think would end up like Vanilla Ice: extractive and disconnected from the tradition. Or do you make a bunch of synthetic minds generate their own synthetic culture? It would be interesting, but I'm not sure it would displace much.
Even if you're entirely right, though, that AlphaGo produced superhumanly good synthetic music, I suspect it won't matter much. Long ago the technology of photography produced superhumanly good synthetic image reproductions. Human art mostly turned away from strict representation, and human artists seized on photography and turned it into an art form in its own right. Synthetic instruments allow anybody to simulate a arbitrary number musicians, but people still go to the orchestra and still see live bands. We could eat take-out or go only to restaurants, but people still have dinner parties and enjoy cooking together. People are social animals.