6 ms·
> I have been tinkering around the same idea for a while, thinking that the state of a country's democracy matters way more than its research output. While I a
by dheera 9y ago
> I have been tinkering around the same idea for a while, thinking that the state of a country's democracy matters way more than its research output.
While I agree with democracy as a whole, I think
0. A thorough understanding of the state of China is needed. In order for democracy to actually work, you need a population that is educated enough to make the right choices for the country. You also need to fight corruption first, or else people will take advantage of the democratic system. In the past 40 years there have been a lot of much higher priority things to the average Chinese citizen than having a fully democratic system. The last thing people want is another period of socioeconomic upheaval and chaos. Stability is the first priority of many. Democracy will come with time and I'm sure everyone wants it, but most people don't want to lose well-being on the road to get there.
1. Democracy isn't the biggest driver of scientific advancement. It's kind of irrelevant. Rather, you need:
- capitalism to distribute money to things that people want (China has a booming VC and startup ecosystem now)
- government funding for longer-term scientific research that has not yet identified a business model, and a system to distribute that funding to people that are worthy of it (funding is there in China; the distribution system needs improvement)
- education that trains the individual to self-learn and nurtures self-exploration rather than rote memorization (work is needed here in China and throughout Asia); education should encourage taking side projects and research seriously, if not more seriously, than classes
- good universities with skilled faculty (there are a few world-class institutions in China, but far too few good universities for China's population -- hence the competition)
Another issue is what defines progress. We have defined it thus far as GDP. But in the future we need new methods of defining progress. The world cannot just grow indefinitely, and we are hitting environmental and resource constraints in a number of ways already.
- cabalamat 9y ago> Democracy will come with time It is not obvious to me that this is the case. > and I'm sure everyone wants it Really? I doubt if Xi Jinping does.
- leggomylibro 9y agoXi Jinping believes fervently in the idea of "one man, one vote." He is the man, and he has the vote.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoWhen growth stumbles as it inevitably will thing may get quite difficult for China.
- freddie_mercury 9y ago> In order for democracy to actually work, you need a population that is educated enough to make the right choices for the country. You also need to fight corruption first, or else people will take advantage of the democratic system I'm not sure what this means, given that the U.S. was uneducated and had massive, widespread corruption throughout the 19th century...but I've never heard anyone put forward the argument that democracy didn't work for the first 150 years of the U.S.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mark_edward 9y agoit really didn't. democracy was highly restricted for the first 150 years of the U.S.
- js8 9y agoActually, that's not true in the U.S. Before the WWI, there was a strong movement (which was killed by federal government because of the WWI) to direct democracy in many U.S. states and it left with the democracy that's modern comparatively to many countries even today. I don't think it's a coincidence that the two most democratic countries, USA (at least at local level) and Switzerland are also among the most successful ones. The "they have to wait until they are ready" argument was always a red herring regarding democracy. It's like with any other skill, you don't learn by waiting until you're ready to become an expert, you learn by doing.
- mark_edward 9y agoI'm not against democracy. I'm just saying, by WWI women couldn't vote, most black people couldn't vote (though the legal right was there since the 14th and 15th amendment, white terror and legal disenfranchisement effectively suppressed the black vote) , so you're talking a majority of the population disenfranchised, that's a quite restricted democracy.
- 9y ago
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoI think you would agree with Deirdre N. McCloskey who, in her tome Bourgeois Dignity: Why Economics Can't Explain the Modern World[1], thoroughly thrashes out the idea that the thing that made the difference is the dignity of the middle class to be able to bring an innovation to market. None of the items you've listed do it alone, but taken together and with the cultural idealisation of innovating and bringing to market a novel idea or product, we have been able to create the world as we know it today. https://www.amazon.com/Bourgeois-Dignity-Economics-Explain-Modern/dp/0226556743 https://www.amazon.com/Bourgeois-Dignity-Economics-Explain-M...