3 ms·
The way it's reported is confusing but after a second, more careful read-through, I still can't see that the "engine" they learn is anything like an ordinary ga
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
The way it's reported is confusing but after a second, more careful read-through, I still can't see that the "engine" they learn is anything like an ordinary game engine that can be compared by a human player's inputs.
Specifically, they don't mention anywhere that their engine was played by a human- to prove its playability. Maybe that's an omission or they didn't consider it important, but it makes it very hard to figure out if this is at all possible.
Finally, there's this bit on the 4th page (next to the algorithm box) where they say:
"At this point we can guarantee that we have an engine that can
predict the entire sequence of frames from the initial frame.
Notably this means that the engine can only reflect changes that
actually occur in the input sequence of parsed frames".
I take this to mean that, given a specific starting frame, their engine wil always predict the same sequence- which must mean its prediction does not take into account player input.
But it's true that this point is very hard to figure out.
>> Maybe they are generating these rules conditional on the player input without telling the training process what the input was.
Basically, yeah- that's my understanding.