4 ms·
Wow, the argument of the text is almost completely disconnected from the title: it's ostensibly about where star scientists choose to locate, but in reality tal
by TulliusCicero 9y ago
Wow, the argument of the text is almost completely disconnected from the title: it's ostensibly about where star scientists choose to locate, but in reality talks only about where star scientists choose to migrate. These are very different things.
If a star scientist chooses to remain where they began being a star scientist, that itself is a decision. And it's an obviously important one: a high-tax state may well be able to offset receiving migrating scientists if it creates more in the first place.
The account for this, you'd want to look at where star scientists start out, or simply look at per capita star scientists for each state. To ignore this strongly biases the article in favor of low-tax states.
I suspect that in practice, high-tax states tend to have more star scientists per capita than low-tax ones, simply because part of what they've done with greater tax revenue is invest into higher education that helps create those scientists. This would be not unlike how so many tech companies are headquartered in high cost metro areas, because those areas are more successful at creating those businesses, not at convincing businesses started elsewhere to move there.
- avs733 9y agoThe conclusions seem explicitly misaligned with the title. The title implies agency and choice, the conclusions don't come anywhere near making that inference Title: Where star scientists choose to locate: the impact of US state taxes Conclusion: Overall, we conclude that state taxes have a significant effect on the location of star scientists. There is absolutely no causal link established in their data. They simply hypothesize one and then use it as a title. Edit: Its also a summary (by the authors) of an actual research article that on a brief read is much more circumspect but still commits many of the same logical sins https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20150508 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20150508