8 ms·
PowerPC Notebook Block Diagram
- j-pb 9y agoI'm not sure if this was posted here to make fun of how little progress they've made in 3 months, to commend them how much progress they've made, or to just introduce the project. I am confused, impressed that somebody still wants to make a powerpc laptop, but also underwhelmed by what essentially amounts to a generic description of a computer.
- stmw 9y agoWell, the diagram itself wasn't that interesting, but sounds like they did a lot of work on the BoM and such, which is could easily take that long even for folks who have done it before.
- wallacoloo 9y agoThe block diagram seems to be missing one or two things, too. How does the SoC query the battery charge, for example? Or is this accomplished as a push-based API from the System PSU (the only power-related component connected directly to the SoC)?
- Ecco 9y agoI quite don't understand the appeal. If you want a PPC laptop, just buy an iBook G4, they sell for $30 on eBay…
- jchw 9y agoI'm guessing POWER has surpassed what a laptop from 2003 can do since the iBook G4 was released. What if you want a better display? More expansion? A GPU? Bluetooth 4? I'd be surprised if an iBook G4 can run a modern Linux stack.
- abrowne 9y ago32-bit PPC was recently dropped from Ubuntu (and Debian IIRC).
- floatboth 9y agoIt can run Ubuntu-MATE 16.04, OpenBSD, MorphOS and more. It's barely usable for web browsing. Even with upgraded hardware (1.25GB RAM and a CF card instead of hard drive) Firefox on Ubuntu and TenFourFox on Mac OS X Tiger are really damn slow. OWB (WebKit) on MorphOS is a bit better, but still not what I'd use for everyday work.
- mattkevan 9y agoYeah, I was really hoping Linux could resurrect my old PowerBook G4. It had great specs for its day and was still in great shape. After trying a whole load of options, Lubuntu 14.04 was the best but there wasn’t anything which provided a modern web experience. I briefly thought of trying to make a Raspberry Pi casemod with it before realising how hard it would be - seemed a shame to get rid of a perfectly good screen and enclosure just because the processor is no longer supported.
- saagarjha 9y agoiBook G4 on Mac OS X Tiger is slow. It's borderline unusable compared to any Intel Mac, even if you stick to "stock" (i.e. use Safari for web browsing, Mail for mail, etc.). I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.
- AHTERIX5000 9y agoMe neither. Also the "Why PPC" isn't exactly convincing. I'd happily buy a non-x86 notebook but I don't see any reason for choosing PPC honestly.
- petecox 9y agoLinux used to be a thing on the Playstation 3 too until Sony's management intervened.
- turblety 9y agoEvery day, more and more people are understanding just how little control they have over the processors that run in their Intel and AMD chips [1][2]. Maybe soon there will be enough people who care to stop giving Intel and AMD money and fund projects like these ones. OpenPOWER seems to be quite open and free. Normally it's quite expensive though, although their main products seem to be aimed at servers. Thought saying that, you always pay. Pay hard cash for a computer, or pay your privacy and freedom. 1. https://libreboot.org/faq.html#intelme https://libreboot.org/faq.html#intelme 2. https://libreboot.org/faq.html#amd https://libreboot.org/faq.html#amd
- jchw 9y agoIt's a balancing act. I don't believe I need absolute 100% control of all things going on in my computer; if I did, I wouldn't be able to utilize it anyways. It's pretty telling that Intel ME has been largely invisible to even savvy users until recently. Having competition is probably part of what's needed to ensure that there's some control. The problem is that none of the competition is currently approaching it from a user freedom standpoint. After all, most companies making processors are publicly traded and even if they weren't, need to sell a huge volume of them to break even and have decent per-unit costs. So trying to target what is unfortunately a very tiny niche of users isn't going to go well. And for the truly paranoid, it's impossible to prove that the processor wasn't tampered with, that there isn't a ring below yours. You can really only ever get to the point of being able to reasonably doubt the existence of it, which won't satisfy everyone. I think Intel is digging its own grave by taking the worst stances on issues of user freedom. Eventually, if Intel ME's power over the machine continues to increase, something bad is going to happen as a result of it, and it's going to erode the already fragile trust people have in them. The ME exploit was part 1 of that. But what about companies like AMD, or the hundreds of ARM manufacturers that take a more passive route of not caring about user freedom? There's no imaginable consequence for that. And there's no real benefit of reversing course, either. I can't see a future where open computing will be anything more than an extreme niche with sub-par options. One of the better scenarios I can think of is that computing as we know it today becomes a niche itself and a lot of the users do value privacy and security. This seems plausible the better that Chromebooks and phones and tablets get; the average user won't need a computer tower or a laptop with 16 GB of RAM. But I imagine it won't be good news for the prices we currently enjoy :)
- aequitas 9y ago"Why PowerPC?: The PowerPC architecture design is newer than the other successful CPU architectures. ..." This if like saying a screensaver of a fire is better than actual fire in your fireplace since its newer. Ignoring the fact it doesn't come close to half the features of a real fire (except for maybe the risk of burning your house down). But as a long term Apple user from before the the x86 era I can't deny there sentiment of going with the underdog :)
- gcb0 9y agoi'd guess you can emulate a PPC (for non-memory intensive tasks) on a modern x86 faster and with less power than running a PPC natively. I might be completely off. and with parallelization and containers fad, which benefit a lot from memory and context changes, they would have more luck funding servers for VM farms than laptops.
- saagarjha 9y agoHuh? Emulation is always slower than anything running natively on comparable hardware, since there's an extra layer of abstraction. Do you mean something else here?
- gcb0 9y agonope. mean exactly it. You forget the fact that x86 is leaps ahead on clock speed of any PPC. if you are at 1/8th of the bare metal performance, ona top of the line average x86 cpu from today, you still have more than the best PPC money can buy. Even for memory and IO intensive tasks, where they are supposed to shine because of the obscenely huge in-cpu caches (when compared to x86) if you remember that the PPC state of the art IO standard is from 2004 and it could barely handle dual gigabit NICs. I might be completely off and not knowing newer PPC offerings, but I doubt there are any since the early 2000's, when i last looked into all this. tl;dr there is no "comparable" ppc in terms of clock speed to x86.
- saagarjha 9y ago
- LeonM 9y agoI see a SATA controller in the laptop, with 2 internal SATA ports for a CD and HD, there is also a PS/2 'mouse'. I don't get it, are they designing a 'retro' style notebook like the old iBook? Or have the designers been sleeping under a rock for the pas 10 years? edit: imac->ibook
- dsr_ 9y agoI don't understand the objection. If these incredibly useful ports are not present, they cannot be used. If they are present, they can be used, but you don't have to do so. This isn't a single laptop design: this is a prototype for building lots of different machines. If you want a NUC-style tiny brick computer, you can build one from this. If you want a RAID server, you can build a small one directly or a medium-sized one by adding a PCIe controller. It's never going to appeal to an ultrabook buyer, since it would be really difficult to engineer all the other components for ultra light weight, but you could replace the vast majority of non-gaming cheap laptops with this. Oh, and integrated touchpads are usually connected with PS/2, SMbus or I2C.
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y ago> integrated touchpads are usually connected with PS/2, SMbus or I2C. Yeah, my laptops mostly show up as PS2 devices. So long as usb is present, I support having other ports.
- LeonM 9y ago> This isn't a single laptop design: this is a prototype for building lots of different machines. OK, then it makes sense. The website isn't clear about that.
- zdw 9y agoThe PS/2 port is probably for the wide range of trackpad/keyboard components that still use that still use that protocol internally, not a physical external port. Lots of devices do this - even high end network gear that have a "USB" port externally wire it to a USB to Serial converter internally, where Serial is the actual protocol in use.
- dawnbreez 9y agoUnfortunately, the first question that popped into my head was not "awesome, a processor that won't spy on me" but "will it be x86 compatible?". I know, it's heresy--you should only need open-source software, and as long as you can get a compiler running, open source software should work. However, the vast majority of users simply won't care, not if they have to give up their favorite software. "I can't use Photoshop? But I need it!" If you want an open processor to take off, it'll need some kind of x86 compatibility.
- putinontheritz 9y agoThis. I think it’s an interesting idea, however it will be relegated to hobbyists and enthusiasts, not the main stream.
- tom_mellior 9y agoWine+QEMU seems to be a reasonable way of executing many Windows programs on non-x86-64, non-Windows platforms. Alternatively, you could install a real Windows in a full-system emulator and run on that. It's not like there are no options at all.
- dawnbreez 9y agoI wasn't as concerned about Windows-only programs as I was about non-open x86 programs in general. While there's definitely more closed Windows programs, there are Linux builds of closed-source tools which are only available for x86. That having been said, I need to look into QEMU.
- stephenr 9y agoAs someone who ran x86 software (primarily Windows at the time) via software emulation (virtualpc) on production PowerPC hardware (Apple PowerMac) I have to disagree. If you don't need x86 compatibility, PPC is fine, and for open source stuff it's probably reasonably well supported in major distros. But pretending you can have anywhere close to reasonable performance of x86 binaries on even the newest PPC chips is hopeful at best and realistically a fanciful notion.
- microcolonel 9y agoI'm thinking that the next architecture to break into PC/mobile will probably come through Chromebooks, but will nonetheless need a well-performing dynamic binary translator for a popular architecture or two (better than QEMU, which is apparently okay-but-not-great).
- rbanffy 9y agoIt's a bit sad it won't be able to compete in price with low-end laptops. I seriously doubt the CPU is more powerful than a Core i3.
- mwcampbell 9y agoIf PowerPC is such a great architecture, then why did Apple transition the Mac platform to x86 about 12 years ago? Has PowerPC gotten much better since then?
- Moto7451 9y agoI think the main driver is there’s common ground between some of the engineers who are PPC fans and some that are Amiga/Morph OS fans. Amiga runs on m68k and PPC so this means they can get some more modern hardware for their platform.
- mpe 9y agoThat had basically nothing to do with the architecture. The key reason was likely the diverging requirements between laptop (Apple) and server (IBM) chips.
- hapless 9y agoSpecifically, IBM had no real roadmap for the PPC 970 series (G5), and could not offer pricing that matched Intel.
- Fnoord 9y agoThe rumor back then was because the G5 wouldn't fit in a laptop format, and the G5 became far too hot. So Apple went to Otellini (Intel) for a deal. They swapped once before architecture within macOS: from m68k to PPC. I don't know about it enough to know if that's true or false, perhaps someone else can verify?
- sengork 9y agoJust like in the 1990s PowerPC laptop was even mentioned in the movie Hackers not to mention Apple's own devices.
- hapless 9y agoThese guys are working with an Amiga vendor who has done a series of designs around the Applied Micro PowerPC 440 series SoCs (systems-on-a-chip). The block diagram clearly indicates an SoC. (IBM POWER, the fast PPC chips, are not SoCs!) I infer that this is another PPC 440 design. Those chips top out at 1.2 GHz with just a couple cores, and they are a legacy product as far as Applied Micro is concerned -- AM is now focused on their ARM products. At best, this project is a very pokey laptop from a near-dead Amiga OEM. At worst, it's a scam.
- mcbridematt 9y agoI suspect it is a NXP/Freescale T-series, 2x64-bit DDR4 and PCIe3.0 lanes lines up with the T4240. https://www.nxp.com/products/microcontrollers-and-processors/applications-processors/qoriq-platforms/t-series/qoriq-t4240-t4160-t4080-multicore-communications-processors:T4240 https://www.nxp.com/products/microcontrollers-and-processors... These are popular CPU's in the networking world, but Freescale halted further PowerPC core development in favour of licensing cores from ARM.
- sanxiyn 9y agoCPU is NXP T208x, see https://www.powerpc-notebook.org/campaigns/electrical-schematics-notebook-powerpc-motherboard-donation-campaign/ https://www.powerpc-notebook.org/campaigns/electrical-schema... It has 4 cores of 1.8 GHz.