4 ms·
> But this is risky, because the bubble's only going to burst when the government gets around to changing policies. Out of curiosity, how would the govt change
by rdtsc 16y ago
> But this is risky, because the bubble's only going to burst when the government gets around to changing policies.
Out of curiosity, how would the govt change their policy to improve the situation? Should they just stop subsidizing the loans? Or should they let students declare bankruptcy if their promised dream job doesn't matterialize when they graduate?
I think regulating the deceptive marketing should also be considered. There is a huge discrepancy between the advertised ROI and actual ROI. People should be made aware of the actual ROI of a college degree. Then a lot less will be willing to spend $100K to get a piece of paper after 4 year that turns out not to help them much after all.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoOut of curiosity, how would the govt change their policy to improve the situation? Not subsidizing the loans would be a good idea. Another proposal would be enforcing some transparency/separability. For example, the govt could demand that colleges break down there costs more granularly than they do - $X for instruction, $Y for the gym, $Z for student activities, etc. They could also demand that all such fees (besides instruction) are optional to the student, and that subsidies only apply to instruction. Colleges waste a LOT of money on irrelevancies, and such a mechanism could reduce some of the waste.
- tokenadult 16y agoFor example, the govt could demand that colleges break down there costs more granularly than they do The government already does do this, in mandatory reports to the federal IPEDS database. And a private foundation has published the information on a user-friendly website, so that even if colleges don't report to the public directly how they spend their money, discerning members of the public can find this out by looking it up. Compare http://www.collegeresults.org/search1b.aspx?institutionid=182290 http://www.collegeresults.org/search1b.aspx?institutionid=18... to http://www.collegeresults.org/search1b.aspx?institutionid=166027 http://www.collegeresults.org/search1b.aspx?institutionid=16... for example.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoNice database, but not remotely as granular as what I'm proposing. I want colleges to break down all the excludible services and students can pick and choose among them. I.e., a menu of some sort: Class/credits $x Computer lab access $? Yacht Club $? Student Theatre $? Intramural sports $? Latino Center $? Annual Rock Concert $? (Not made up) Career services $? The govt should subsidize only class/credits, and any colleges accepting subsidies must allow students to pick and choose among the rest. I.e., if you don't want to use computer labs or the gym, you don't have to pay for them. A lot of the cost of college is caused by colleges wasting money on unnecessary frills, and the system I propose would create a downward pressure on the cost of frills. (Another major component of cost is waste/fraud/abuse/administration, but I don't see an easy way to eliminate that.)
- eclark 16y agoSchool should be about a lot more then just the in class learning. While the social things are not as easily defensible, without them a student does not become as well rounded a person.
- rdtsc 16y agoIt is hard to apply those across the board. Perhaps there should be fees associated with participation in any of those extra-currilar socialization events. If the student wants to participate they should pay for it. Other students and their parents shouldn't have to pay to subsidize others' "socialization". I for instance, didn't live on campus. Yet some of my tutition went to paying for various activities and "nice-to-have" social things others did participate in. I would have liked to opt-out and get a cheaper tuition instead.
- pmichaud 16y agoI once worked at a software company where a big deal has been made for software + hardware. It was a lot of hardware, and the software was maybe 10% of the overall cost, which was approaching $1million. Then the company backed out and said they just wanted the software. All of a sudden, our software became 90% of the overall cost, and hardware was 10%. All your idea would accomplish is making the credits super expensive and the extras super cheap.
- gyardley 16y agoThere's a lot the government could do (and some things it already does), but unfortunately, everything can be manipulated - and if it can be manipulated, it will be manipulated. Perhaps the most effective thing would be to only give Title IV funding to programs whose students reach a minimum 'employed in the field' percentage a certain period of time after graduation. Hard to police and implement, but most directly relevant. Simpler to implement would be a reduction in the overall percentage of revenue an institution can get from Title IV programs, which would force the institutions to either reduce tuition or deliver an education valuable enough to satisfy a private-sector lender.