3 ms·
>> We're starting to find incredibly elegant solutions to problems that have stymied computer scientists for decades. I think by "incredibly elegant solutions"
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> We're starting to find incredibly elegant solutions to problems that have stymied computer scientists for decades.
I think by "incredibly elegant solutions" you mean the typical black-box statistical machine learning algorithm that takes in some data as input and outputs an approximated function that "solves" whatever problem your data was representing.
If that is indeed what you mean (apologies otherwise) I really struggle to see that as "elegant" -or even a solution. We start with some problem too complex to understand and build a complex system we don't quite understand, that solves the problem in a way we don't quite understand. What did we gain? A system that solves the problem - maybe, when it feels like it, depending on the problem, provided enough data etc etc. Our understanding of the problem hasn't changed and therefore our ability to solve it, hasn't.
To give an analogy- it's like a kid at school who can't solve some arithmetic problem they have for homework asking their big sister to solve it for them. The kid now knows the answer to the problem but still doesn't know how to solve it, on their own. They didn't "find a solution"- they found someone who knows the solution.
I think, if you look at the progress we've made as a civilisation in producing knowledge, you'll find that this was always driven by people who solved problems, themselves. And if you think of the kind of people who invoke some higher authority that has all the solutions, you're probably looking at religion.
- jdietrich 9y agoBiological animals are amazingly good at crude statistical approximations. That's how we perform the vast majority of tasks - we make educated guesses that are reasonably close, then correct those guesses as new information becomes available. Computers have historically been very good at getting exact answers to simple problems, but very bad at approximating a solution to more complex problems. Computers that can interact with the real world are computers that can make quick, reasonably accurate guesses based on incomplete information. Hugely important tasks like speech recognition and autonomous driving are practically impossible without using approximate statistical methods. Machine learning is the key framework that allows us to attack those real-world problems.
- thomashop 9y agoyou're completely overlooking the fact that deep neural networks can generalize to unseen data. the kid analogy doesn't work at all.
- kthejoker2 9y agoSomeone didn't watch Jimmy find the warp whistle in The Wizard ... In all seriousness, rapid adaptation to New environments (including video games and math homework) is within small children's neutral capabilities. But they can't discover properties they aren't designed to discover. They're left with scientific method for everything else. Which is just generalizing to unseen data.