6 ms·
I think this article is complete nonsense. The author presents no evidence to support the claim that credentials are stored in the clear.
by dboreham 9y ago
I think this article is complete nonsense. The author presents no evidence to support the claim that credentials are stored in the clear.
- iancarroll 9y agoWell, to be fair, short length limitations are odd in that if the password is put through a KDF, the output is always the same length, so it shouldn’t really matter how long the user’s password is.
- onion2k 9y agoit shouldn’t really matter how long the user’s password is It doesn't, which is by password rules are usually driven by two factors. The first is an attempt to increase entropy (eg must have a number and a capital letter), and the second is trying to ensure memorability (eg a length limit). Neither of these have anything to do with the database schema. Password rules don't tell you anything about how the password is stored.
- daveFNbuck 9y agoIf the password length limit is about memorability, it's pretty weird that their password guidelines suggest starting with a 57-character passphrase and then doing a bunch of difficult to remember obfuscations.
- bradknowles 9y agoEven if they’re not, Yahoo used MD5, and LinkedIn used SHA-1. With the latest version of Hashcat, some cloud GPUs, and a little money, it wouldn’t take much to crack.
- throwaway92782 9y agoWhat sucks is how hard it is to do anything when you're on the inside and know just how dangerous the systems are, and management has no interest in fixing things. A former employer of mine is a government agency with millions of accounts, with SSN and every kind of PII imaginable, they have actually been breached (millions of SSNs lost) ... and they still don't hash passwords. Would love to out them, but the management is vindictive as hell so I can't come up with a good way to out the place without great risk to myself. I'm sure many have been in this situation - we need a safe way for people like us to speak up before breaches happen.
- jlgaddis 9y agoAn anonymous e-mail to someone like Brian Krebs, perhaps?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago>A former employer of mine is a government agency with millions of accounts, with SSN and every kind of PII imaginable, they have actually been breached (millions of SSNs lost) ... and they still don't hash passwords. So the costs of the breach haven't been high enough to provoke action, which means they're probably making the right decision if one assumes that hashing the passwords would require a significant modification of their software, infrastructure, or processes.
- throwaway92782 9y agoGuessing you'd feel differently if it was you, or a family member, who had their identity breached along with information about every bad situation in your life. And no, the costs aren't high to change it. The code to do it has been done for a long time. It got mired in political grandstanding, and that's it.
- throwaway92782 9y agoAlso to pile on - running that way is a clear violation of that government's policies, and they have blatantly lied about other security issues to other (customer) government agencies that are trying to do the right thing. It's not just a matter of choosing cost savings over security, it's also about breaking the law.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoOf course I'd probably feel more strongly if I were affected, but that's true of any policy isn't it? That has nothing to do with the correctness of the decision. I think we should end mortgage tax deductions. Most homeowners would disagree. The fact that they are personally negatively affected is irrelevant to whether or not ending mortgage tax deductions should be done.
- politelemon 9y agoFWIW - the author seems to jump to conclusions quite a bit, from their other piece on DuoLingo: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15678928 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15678928
- daveFNbuck 9y agoThe author does not make a claim that credentials are stored in the clear. The author only says that he cannot think of a good reason for the limitation and asks for help from readers in explaining why this limitation exists. He says that the only reasons he can think of are similar to storing passwords in plaintext, but makes no claim that these are the actual reasons.