11 ms·
Wow, what an uncreative attack. Let's say you control decently over 51% of mining power and want to destroy bitcoin. What do you do? Keep in mind that this g
by amluto 9y ago
Wow, what an uncreative attack. Let's say you control decently over 51% of mining power and want to destroy bitcoin. What do you do?
Keep in mind that this gives you two significant powers. First, you can more or less unilaterally dictate the new consensus blockchain, subject to the usual constraints that you can't create transactions that weren't appropriately signed. That is, you can't spend other people's money or directly destroy it. Second, you have a limited ability to replace the consensus with something else.
The first power, by itself, allows you to block certain transactions from ever occurring. You could pick some subset of coins and prevent them from being spent. This could be targetted against exchanges, random users, or maybe even be based on geography. The goal (according to the article) is presumably to undermine confidence.
The second power can be used a lot more insidiously than just double-spending your own coins. How about tracking all inbound transfers to some exchange over some period of time and then undoing them? Now that exchange is out a lot of coins. For extra fun, could use your consensus-choosing power to effectively lock down the coins that you just stole from the exchange so their original owners don't have them either.
There are probably even more interesting things you could do, too.
- w-ll 9y agoAnyone can track Bitcoin transactions; That IS the blockchain. Undoing them will just result in a chain that they are still in the original wallets keys, you STILL cant steal them. And the window for doing this is likely an hour or 2 at tops, but still very unlikely. An exchange might credit you on a few confirmed blocks, but after 6 (an hour) its pretty much confirmed, and any withdraws on the same chain will fail once the 51% attack is over.
- gpm 9y agoYou didn't steal them for you, you stole them for the original owner who tried to transfer them to the exchange. In theory with 51% hashing power you could undo exchanges going back as long as you want, as long as you dedicated your entire hashing power to doing so from the point you are trying to revert to. You will get the longer chain so once you publish it it will take over. In practice I'm not sure if there are controls against very old forks from coming in and becoming the 'right one'.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- w-ll 9y agoNo, it is the exchanges who's coins are "stolen", but still not really. 51% hashing doesn't allow you to `undo exchanges going back as long as you want`. There is a small time frame with exchanges/merches that accept <6 block confirmations that a transaction could be reversed. And if a fork in the chain is happens (it does more often than not that 2 blocks get made and 1 is orphaned,) all other miners switch to the longer chain as soon as a fork is detected.
- amluto 9y agoYou seem to be assuming that, once 6 confirmations have happened, a transaction is set in stone. This isn't true at all. It's true that, once 6 confirmations have happened, a transaction is highly unlikely to disappear in the absence of the 51% attack, but the whole point here is that we're assuming that a 51% attack is occurring.
- QML 9y agoAgreed, it’s much easier to create a fork and sow discord within the community than it is to launch a 51% attack.
- rtkwe 9y agoWould one mitigation against this attack be for exchanges and anyone doing irreversible transactions on the edge where bitcoin interfaces with the real world to wait for more confirmations? To the reverse the transaction would then require going back and creating a lot of blocks to have the longest chain again.