3 ms·
To address the argument from authority, the presumption there is that the existing expertise has been self selected by a rational and efficient market, which in
by dnautics 9y ago
To address the argument from authority, the presumption there is that the existing expertise has been self selected by a rational and efficient market, which in the government contracting sphere is very much not necessarily rational, and I think you'd have a hard time finding an efficient market anywhere.
It's pretty clear that from first principles, reusable rockets are a win[0]. The question of actualizing those principles can only be assessed by actually doing it, and is likely to be highly empirical. Unless there have been secret launches we don't know about, the ESA cannot possibly have good insight about whether or not it's valuable.
[0] then why haven't they done it yet? As a constrained market, none of the contractors who normally build rockets have had to yet. Moreover, I presume a lot of the computational engineering would not have been so easy 10-20 years ago, much less in a large contracting company with established folkways.
- namelost 9y agoI agree with what you're saying and I'd also like to add that SpaceX could have failed. Based on the evidence available in 2002 there was no reason to think that reusable rockets were necessarily going to work. Musk is a gambler, and this time he won, but other times he has failed. The reason he can gamble is because SpaceX is funded by private money.