4 ms·
The cynic in my thinks that the "vote with your wallet" slogan has been coined by those who want to prevent better regulation. Upvoted for that sentence alone.
by mikestew 9y ago
The cynic in my thinks that the "vote with your wallet" slogan has been coined by those who want to prevent better regulation.
Upvoted for that sentence alone. We have government because I can’t build a road by myself. I also can’t individually smack a company upside the head and tell them “cut it out, this isn’t the society I want to live in”.
- DataWorker 9y agoGlobalization means passing the laws you’re talking about amounts to protectionism. That’s not very popular with anyone but Trump.
- SapphireSun 9y agoI think the bigger idea is that there should be a broader system of international mutual aid. We can't drag down our own labor standards because someone else's is terrible. We need to help raise them up. Only international cooperation can prevent us from accelerating in a race to the bottom.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoWe can't build a road by ourselves. We as individuals CAN decide where we spend your money. Two very different scenarios. You very different level of civic duty. Could regulation help? Sure, Uncle Sam gets lucky from time to time :) But it is never as powerful as the market. Until the market says "screw Amazon" Amazon will continue to do what rewards it and its shareholders.
- SerLava 9y ago>We as individuals CAN decide where we spend your money. Yeah, but then most people just don't care. I'm just really glad nobody is asking me to boycott slave-produced southern cotton if I really want slavery to go away.
- chiefalchemist 9y ago> "Yeah, but then most people just don't care." Well, there ya go! :) People don't care about where they spend their money. They don't care about their own people health. But the problem is Amazon, the ACA, etc. If most people don't want to be held responsible for their own decisions, with what logic do they argue holding someone else responsible. To be clear, there certainly are things gov / legislation can do. But that doesn't give individuals a free pass on their civic duties.
- closeparen 9y ago"I don't want to live in a society where people have to $thing, so let's ban $thing and punish the companies involved in it" is approximately the most destructive fallacy of our time. Making upper-middle-class the minimum allowable lifestyle doesn't give everyone an upper-middle-class standard of living. It just punishes those who don't already have it. We're going to keep ratcheting up the minimum allowable job, housing, food, etc. until a tiny minority of liberal elites are congratulating each other for having eradicated exploitation and all the liberated victims of exploitation are unemployed, homeless, and starving. I don't want to live in a society where people have to live in RVs and work in Amazon warehouses. But banning Amazon warehouses (or RVs) isn't going to help. We need redistribution, retraining, a real social safety net, healthcare, etc. so that people actually have better options than exploitative employment situations. Then it isn't even necessary to ban them, because no one would want them anyway.
- pedasmith 9y agoMore destructive than, "oil companies can spill oil anywhere" (Nigeria) or "let's kill everyone from the 'wrong' ethnic group" (Rwanda) or "let's exploit orphans" (Ireland)?
- closeparen 9y agoThose things are clearly evil and clearly demand a response. The "let's ban symptoms and coping mechanisms" bandwagon, on the other hand, gives citizens who are concerned about a situation the feeling that they're helping, disarming and distracting them from actually constructing a better world. The collective loss to society of the solutions that could be built but aren't is quite large. Imagine if we had single-payer health care instead of more regulation on employer-employee relationships. Imagine if we had public housing instead of regulation stonewalling private development. Imagine if we actually built world-class public transportation systems instead of just starving out the parking. Etc, etc.
- hiram112 9y agoAgree with you. I think the whole ObamaCare fiasco is one of those things that the typical millennial liberals on HN have gotten entirely wrong. For years, the mantra here has been that all those red state deplorables who were wary about government health care were voting against their own interests, and ignorant for not wanting it. Trust us. We know better than you. Well now we've seen what's happening. Premiums have skyrocketed for average workers and everyone has been moved to high deductible plans that pay for nothing. My own insurance had gone from decent to worthless, and it costs twice as much. As a single guy who makes a high income, it's no big deal. For many of my coworkers who have a spouse and 3 kids, it has been devastating. And it's getting worse as more states drop plans.