5 ms·
> "For one thing, Amazon should pay its workers more and give them better working conditions. It’s laughable that the workers get a 15-minute break when they ha
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
> "For one thing, Amazon should pay its workers more and give them better working conditions. It’s laughable that the workers get a 15-minute break when they have to spend it walking to the break room. It’s completely insane."
Perhaps the rest of society should be more aware of the darkside(s) of the business models they are supporting?
Plenty of multi-nationals - Nike comes to mind - have been pressured into making changes to practices that were not socially acceptable.
Why isn't Amazon being held to the same measuring stick?
Editorial: Why is the public still so naive about the "hidden costs" of cheaper? Certainly, Walmart (for example) and its darkside would be fresh in the minds of the American public. Instead, it seems, the perception is Amazon is the saviour (from Walmart), when the new boss is really the same as the old boss (sans the glossy high tech paint job).
- badestrand 9y ago>> Why is the public still so naive about the "hidden costs" of cheaper? Because it is not true. Apple products are considered luxury goods and the company is known for the horrendous treatment of their workers in Asia. And ALDI is a very cheap supermarket chain in Germany but pays and treats their employees better than some more expensive ones. There might be a correlation but that means nothing for each individual purchase.
- jgamman 9y agoshouldn't you be quoting examples from within the same society? it seems a bit suss to quote a German budget chain acting reasonably responsibly towards its employees as a counter point to an American one. last time i looked labour laws were vastly different between the US and Germany...
- jnbiche 9y ago> last time i looked labour laws were vastly different between the US and Germany... Exactly.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- markshead 9y agoCompanies operating in the United States (like ALDI) are going to be subject to all the same labor laws as any other company operating in the United States. (I believe ADLI is owned by the same parent company as Trader Joes.)
- A_Beck 9y agoALDI has stores in the US, and it looks like they pay higher than the prevailing wage in the US too: https://www.glassdoor.com/Hourly-Pay/ALDI-Hourly-Pay-E7337.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Hourly-Pay/ALDI-Hourly-Pay-E7337.h...
- na85 9y ago> last time i looked labour laws were vastly different between the US and Germany... Labour laws in the US seem to boil down to "should have pulled yourself up by your bootstraps harder" .
- chiefalchemist 9y agoThe Apple example is accurate. But it's also an outlier, and in the context of the discussion even worse. Agreed. Aldi is a great outfit and gets more of my business because of that. It IS possible to live without Amazon. I don't think it's unreasonable for more people to consider trying a bit to consider that.
- markshead 9y agoThe reason ALDI pays employees really well is because the entire store is run with only a few employees at a time. A significant portion of the value you get from the store (cheap prices) is because their labor costs are low. I'd go as far to say that the real thing you are buying at ALDI is products that don't have a lot of labor waste built into the price. I've heard most places have 2 to 4 working at a time, but I've seen stores where a single employee is running everything. Every employee I've seen there is working very hard the entire time. Before they added scanners, they were required to memorize the price of every item in the store. They pay more because they will not get the type of employee they need by paying less. While most of the people who are a good fit for ALDI like it there, you can find many reviews saying the work was too hard and that there was too much pressure. If you look at retired RVers who have written about working at Amazon.com, you'll find many who felt that while the work was hard, it was good work and paid well (especially with holiday overtime) but you had to be willing (and physically capable) of doing hard work. Like you say, the cost of each individual purchase from a company has little to do with how much they pay their employees. There is a much stronger correlation between employees who are doing hard things that add significant value and higher pay.
- yeukhon 9y agoPerhaps search “amazon sweatshop”? They are not hidden at all. Nikes outsources manufacture to contractors outside the US where countries with horrible labor practices and labor laws and enforcement.
- PakG1 9y agoNike now does regular audits of their factories to ensure compliance of good working condition requirements. They've improved since their factory fiascos in the 90s. Don't think they're perfect, but they seem to be trying. https://about.nike.com/pages/transform-manufacturing https://about.nike.com/pages/transform-manufacturing NIKE’S COMMITMENT TO TRANSPARENCY Transparency and accountability are fundamental to Nike’s sustainable business approach. The Nike Manufacturing Map discloses the names, locations and demographic information about the workforce at the factories we contract to make our product, and holds us accountable for our chosen source base.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoWhen i see "...Amazon sweatshops..." on Good Morning America then I'll consider it out in the open. I never said Amazon's practices were hidden. The question is: Why don't most people care about Amazon's practices?
- stevenwoo 9y agoI've stopped impulse buying on Amazon last year and haven't looked back.
- konschubert 9y agoBecause structural problems can not be solved on the individual level. We will not end world hunger by eating less. We will not stop climate change by turning off the light more often. And we will not fix exploitative employment practices by voting with our wallet. The cynic in my thinks that the "vote with your wallet" slogan has been coined by those who want to prevent better regulation. All these things CAN be solved by passing laws and regulation and by building a society that supports and enforces those.
- mikestew 9y agoThe cynic in my thinks that the "vote with your wallet" slogan has been coined by those who want to prevent better regulation. Upvoted for that sentence alone. We have government because I can’t build a road by myself. I also can’t individually smack a company upside the head and tell them “cut it out, this isn’t the society I want to live in”.
- DataWorker 9y agoGlobalization means passing the laws you’re talking about amounts to protectionism. That’s not very popular with anyone but Trump.
- SapphireSun 9y agoI think the bigger idea is that there should be a broader system of international mutual aid. We can't drag down our own labor standards because someone else's is terrible. We need to help raise them up. Only international cooperation can prevent us from accelerating in a race to the bottom.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoWe can't build a road by ourselves. We as individuals CAN decide where we spend your money. Two very different scenarios. You very different level of civic duty. Could regulation help? Sure, Uncle Sam gets lucky from time to time :) But it is never as powerful as the market. Until the market says "screw Amazon" Amazon will continue to do what rewards it and its shareholders.
- oceanghost 9y agoI worry about this daily. More so, does my lifestyle necessitate others being taken advantage of? Is it even be possible to live a moral life?
- chiefalchemist 9y agoI think if you're aware and you're trying that's about as moral as you can get. If I didn't have aging parents to consider I'd go live in a cave, with a massive stack of book.
- oceanghost 9y agoWe may be kindred spirits. My dream is a cabin in the woods with nobody around. Nobody. Wish I'd realized that before I had kids :)
- gdulli 9y agoI find it hard to support Amazon in any way knowing how it treats its employees, both in the warehouses and at corporate. For it to span such different contexts suggests how systemic it really is.