3 ms·
"Here are three examples of people driving cars off the road into a tree" → "Transportation is failing" This isn't software architecture, this is potential/all
by mpweiher 9y ago
"Here are three examples of people driving cars off the road into a tree" → "Transportation is failing"
This isn't software architecture, this is potential/alleged mis-application of three very specific patterns (I am not sure I'd even call them architectural styles).
- alexandercrohde 9y agoWell, I think the author is alleging (and it concurs with my experience) that at a number of companies patterns are misapplied much (most?) of the time [and the more complex the pattern, the less likely it's necessary]. So if the majority of drivers hit trees then yes, transportation would be failing.
- mpweiher 9y agoThat would be just as invalid an overgeneralization. It seems more likely that three drivers are failing. It is less likely that it could be three makes of cars. Generalizing to all cars is ridiculous, generalizing to all of transportation off the charts. Maybe these patterns are being misapplied. Most likely, that's because people misapply stuff all the time. (Paraphrasing Sturgeon: sure 90% of software is crap. That's because 90% of everything is crap). Now it is also possible that these particular architectural patterns are prone to misapplication, though there is little evidence of that. Maybe there is a general tendency to apply over complex architectures (see architecture-astronauts), but even that doesn't mean that "architecture has failed". At best: over-complex up-front architecting is maybe not such a good idea. But any competent architect will tell you that. Minimal, evolutionary architecture is just as much (and in some senses more) "architecture". Every software system has an architecture. There is good architecture, bad architecture, big-ball-of-mud architecture etc. Citing examples of bad or badly applied architecture and claiming "architecture has failed" is a category mistake.
- tootie 9y agoI'd also argue that the cost of misapplying some design patterns is pretty low. I've seen some overengineered solutions before, but they are rarely the cause of project failure.
- hackerfromthefu 9y agoThat depends on lots of factors However what you see after five and ten and more years is often very different than in the early years ..