4 ms·
Here's a graph depicting Google's quarterly revenue, in billions, versus total number of internet users, also in billions. https://imgur.com/a/eBB9E https://im
by tyingq 9y ago
Here's a graph depicting Google's quarterly revenue, in billions, versus total number of internet users, also in billions. https://imgur.com/a/eBB9E https://imgur.com/a/eBB9E
The gap that opens up between the two roughly shows how much more advertising they are pumping at us. Some of it understandable, like their acquisition of YouTube. A lot of it, though, is just turning search results into nothing but ads above the fold.
Investors are expecting to see that gap grow at the same, or higher pace. From my perspective, that means anything that doesn't advance that goal is a low priority. Whether that's accurate news, quality of the organic search results, etc.
- MarkMc 9y agoPart of the gap can be explained by: (1) Increasing income of internet users, (2) The average user spending more time on the internet, (3) Google getting more effective at matching advertisers with Google users
- tyingq 9y agoI believe that, but nobody other Google really knows how much of the gap is things that are either good/neutral for consumers, and how much of it isn't. Certainly some part of it is pushing the organics down, long forced ads in front of videos, etc. However, investors are expecting that continued ~20% YoY growth...which will further widen the gap. I don't see how that's possible without doing more things that are bad for consumers.
- MarkMc 9y agoI'm actually a Google shareholder and yes I do expect continued 20% growth, at least for the next decade. But increasing the ad/content ratio is only a small component of that growth. Here are my estimates for the major components of Google's revenue growth over the next 10 years: 1. Number of Google users * avg income per user grows 3% per year 2. Time spent on internet by average user grows 5% per year 3. Ad/content ratio gows 3% per year 4. Google ad effectiveness grows 8% per year
- tyingq 9y agoDo some compound interest calculation on some of those and you'll see the problem. Assume they've been doing it for years and years already. There is a hard cap on some of those. Especially ad/content ratio and CTR. At some point, you're done. For many queries, ad/content ratio is already maxed. Like, how do you optimize this further? It's a 2 page ad already, with links out to other ads that pay google. https://imgur.com/a/hAFas https://imgur.com/a/hAFas Also, there is a point where that sours. Some consumers will bail once the ad overhead is too much. Either via ad blockers, or the next "Google".
- MarkMc 9y agoI agree Google's revenue will not grow 20% annually forever, but I don't see any problem with my 10-year projection. When I watch YouTube I see about 30 seconds of ads for every 10 minutes of video content. I could easily see this rising to 60 seconds over the next decade. And the ads I do see are not very well tailored to me: I see cat food ads even though I don't have a cat. I see gambling ads even though I've never gambled in my life. I see ads for a sit-stand desk even though I already bought it. I never see MacBook Pro ads even though I put one in my shopping cart on Apple's website 6 months ago but did not purchase it. (Google has all my photos, all my emails and my location history for past 4 years, so Google should know all this). Google has a long way to go to maximize the effectiveness of their ads.
- majewsky 9y ago> increasing income of internet users If anything, the average income of internet users is decreasing. The majority of people in the rich countries have been online since the 90s and early 2000s. Everyone who's been joining after that is most likely from an underdeveloped or developing country.
- MarkMc 9y agoGood point - I missed that. Your comment reminds me of a story [1] about how a Google engineer once significantly reduced the size of the YouTube video page but average load times got worse. Turns out they were getting lots of new users from third world countries with much worse connection speeds. I also wonder to what degree this effect counters the argument that average incomes in Australia and US have not risen for decades [2]. Perhaps native-born people see their incomes rise, but the average is dragged down by immigrants who typically have lower incomes. [1] http://blog.chriszacharias.com/page-weight-matters http://blog.chriszacharias.com/page-weight-matters [2] http://www.rossgittins.com/2017/09/sorry-but-using-migration-to-boost.html?m=1 http://www.rossgittins.com/2017/09/sorry-but-using-migration...
- mFixman 9y agoAnd, most importantly, (4) Android.
- bigbugbag 9y agoI think your (1) is mistaken, it should be something like google expanding its domination over the web by multiplying the places to show adwords and adsense (gmail, youtube, analytics, maps, android, play store, earth, docs, drive, etc.)
- dna_polymerase 9y ago> Investors are expecting to see that gap grow at the same, or higher pace. It's sad to see Google obey to these Wall Street expectations. I remember reading about the stock structure Larry and Sergey set up before their IPO. They wanted to have control about Google and do good (Remember Don't be evil?). Nowadays they seem to just cater to the shareholders. Products get less great by the day and it really looks like they stopped listening to the users.
- tyingq 9y agoI think they were hoping one of the "other bets" (Waymo, etc) would take that pressure off. No luck thus far though.
- bigbugbag 9y agoI remember quite correctly the "don't be evil" motto and I remember it having a very different meaning than "do good". I also remember that it was among the most misunderstood things at google and that it served google well. I do not remember a time when google listened to the users but I do remember when google went from being a search engine to an advertising network. This is the point in time where the downhill slope started.