3 ms·
A) I think we're talking about modification-resistant fingerprinting methods, not just a simple hash of the data. B) That's a support nightmare; it would be ne
by kelnos 9y ago
A) I think we're talking about modification-resistant fingerprinting methods, not just a simple hash of the data.
B) That's a support nightmare; it would be nearly trivial to start submitting false reports from a ton of accounts without establishing a pattern so those accounts could easily be ignored. Regardless, how do you prove that you "own an image" (what does that even mean?) and that it was reported as an "intimate photo" maliciously?
I agree that FB's current solution is really bad, and if it were me, I certainly wouldn't pro-actively send in photos of myself, but I'm at a loss for how they can address A & B.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> That's a support nightmare; it would be nearly trivial to start submitting false reports from a ton of accounts without establishing a pattern so those accounts could easily be ignored. What's stopping me from flooding false reports now? Arguably, only reviewing the image they already have once a hash matches is less work, since they wouldn't have to review all incoming reports, only matched ones.
- alsetmusic 9y ago> Arguably, only reviewing the image they already have once a hash matches is less work, since they wouldn't have to review all incoming reports, only matched ones. They would still need to investigate reports that didn’t match known hashes, but you’re right that this would be beneficial. Images that match a known hash could be prioritized during review.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoDon't they have to do that now anyway?
- phkahler 9y agoThe solution is to hash it locally and send the hash to Facebook without saving a local copy. Simple as that. Sure, someone could still do a lot of work to intercept or reverse engineer it and make an app to circumvent the hashing. But even if such an app existed, it would be obscure and people trying to upload unauthorized pics wouldn't bother or even know it exists. If you've got pics you don't want on the internet, the first rule is to not upload them to anywhere on the internet. Actually the real first rule is not to take them. Flash people your bits in person instead.
- icebraining 9y agoActually the real first rule is not to take them. Flash people your bits in person instead. Assuming you were the one to take the pictures, of course, and not got them from your ex-partner that's trying to pressure you by threatening to publish them on FB.