5 ms·
I've modded you back up as I have the same question, albeit I think some explanation would help: FreeBSD has the good bits of the Solaris kernel - ZFS and DTrac
by nailer 16y ago
I've modded you back up as I have the same question, albeit I think some explanation would help: FreeBSD has the good bits of the Solaris kernel - ZFS and DTrace - and the common Solaris 10 userspace - toolchain, packaging, etc. - aren't particularly up to date.
- adbge 16y agoFreeBSD supports ZFS v14, which lacks some of the features of ZFS on OpenSolaris, namely data deduplication. However, it is my understanding that porting later versions of ZFS to FreeBSD would require non trivial changes to the FreeBSD kernel, making it unlikely.
- shin_lao 16y agoI'm sorry but could you elaborate on "porting later versions of ZFS to FreeBSD would require non trivial changes to the FreeBSD kernel"?
- lol 16y agoHe's wrong. There's already work going on to port newer ZFS (w/deduplication) to FreeBSD. The biggest outlying question is if it will only be in 9, or if it might make it into 8.x.
- c00p3r 16y agoAdd to this an idiotic attempt to replace SystemV startup scripts with some insanely non-obvious java-based (of course!) crap, badly ported in a great hurry outdated 32-bit userland (when at the same time x86_64 version of Fedora or FreeBSD-ports were several years old), some in-house designed and quite alien packaging system (pkg) and so on. It is dead. As dead as Irix or Tru64 or even OpenVMS.
- rbanffy 16y ago> some in-house designed and quite alien packaging system Looks a lot like apt
- koenigdavidmj 16y agoActually it is on occasion quite cool. For example, it will take a ZFS snapshot before doing package updates, so that if Bad Things (TM) happen you can simply reboot into the system snapshot taken before the update. And it's all copy-on-write, so you only use the disk space for what changed.
- rbanffy 16y agoWe have to admit - it may have weird userland tools and run a slightly old-ish Gnome, but it does tricks no other OS does.
- ssmoot 16y agoSolaris SMF is actually one of the best things about Solaris (IMO). Runit documentation as an init replacement are woefully out of date for most platforms, and Upstart seems like it's still beta at-best. I'm not that savvy, but I know of nothing for Linux or FreeBSD that starts everything up, makes sure it gets restarted if it crashes, notifies you, has maintenance states, supports simple, robust dependencies (process or file-based). The SMF covers these bases very well. Runit seems to come closest on the service side, but it's not nearly as well documented. Monit is almost a suitable substitute (even though that's not really it's goal), but robust dependency support is lacking last I checked.
- nailer 16y ago> Solaris SMF is actually one of the best things about Solaris (IMO)? XML config files? Java when a regular Unix system language like C or Python (or Perl for older folks) would suffice?
- ssmoot 16y agoXML isn't the best perhaps. But it's not a road-block either. New config files are always new. And who cares what it's implemented in as long as it doesn't fall over? I mean, ideally sure. C FTW on resource utilization, but honestly, if the choice is between something that's a bit of a pig, eating up 100MB of RAM vs what...? Really simply put: There is no competition that checks the same boxes that I'm aware of. I'd be genuinely grateful if you can show me an alternative, especially for GNU/Linux and FreeBSD, but most of the alternatives are new early-phase projects with grand goals that may never materialize, or unmaintained. So sure, SMF isn't perfect. What's better?
- c00p3r 16y agoGo back to school and learn the basic principles on which UNIX was built upon. Try to recognize the differences between text file and XML file. Try to understand the difference between 'file /bin/sh' , 'ldd /bin/sh' and /usr/bin/java.
- ssmoot 16y ago