5 ms·
> So was cursive faster than manuscript? No, it was slower. But fastest of all was a personalized mixture of cursive and manuscript developed spontaneously by p
by crazygringo 9y ago
> So was cursive faster than manuscript? No, it was slower. But fastest of all was a personalized mixture of cursive and manuscript developed spontaneously by pupils around the fourth to fifth grade. Even in France, a quarter of the French pupils who were taught cursive exclusively and were still mostly using it in the fourth grade, had largely abandoned it for a mixed style by the fifth grade.
I was shocked at how cursive could be slower than block letters... but then realized that, yes, if you're doing all the curly things on Q's and Z's and F's then, yes it could be slower.
But nobody does those! A "personalized mixture of cursive and manuscript" is how I write, I just call it cursive, or "partial cursive". But it says that is faster, and presumably students wouldn't learn that if they hadn't learned full cursive at first?
So seems like teaching cursive is useful because in the end students do write faster. Except that maybe we should focus on teaching just the "fast" parts of connecting lowercase letters, and ignore all the fancy curly parts that uppercase letters tend to have?
- HarryHirsch 9y agoignore all the fancy curly parts that uppercase letters You could be talking about Roman Cursive: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_cursive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_cursive You could make a case for that.
- ghaff 9y agoArguably, if you want people to be able to write quickly, you'd teach shorthand or at least some simplified version thereof. In general journalists, who still often take handwritten notes for various reasons, develop their own idiosyncratic sets of abbreviations and notations to let them take accurate notes/quotes quickly.
- ggggtez 9y agoIt's impossible to say whether those children would develop their own style of short hand if they'd never seen cursive to begin with. You don't need to spend hours writing in cursive to notice that certain letter combinations appear together often, and coincidentally start smushing those letters together into some sort of cursive-ish mixture.
- amyjess 9y ago> But nobody does those! A "personalized mixture of cursive and manuscript" is how I write, I just call it cursive, or "partial cursive". But it says that is faster, and presumably students wouldn't learn that if they hadn't learned full cursive at first? I ended up developing something like that in 2009. By that point, I'd long since forgotten everything I was taught in elementary school and just wrote everything in all caps. But I was starting to develop an interest in typography, and I wanted to improve my handwriting. So I started studying italic serif fonts to see how I could do something similar by hand, with the restriction that most letters should be written in one stroke. I found out that my attempts at replicating serifs in handwriting without increasing the stroke count actually had a technical term: semiserif. What I came up with looks kind of like D'Nealian, but with some significant differences. The biggest one is that I put semiserifs on the beginnings of letters and not just on the ends. Another is that I use a two-story g (and I wrote it with an ear for a while before eliminating it). And my z is particularly swashy.