3 ms·
Well, there could be other cases where a business may have disproportional power and use it to exploit the elements of the society. That's when the regulations
by mrtksn 9y ago
Well, there could be other cases where a business may have disproportional power and use it to exploit the elements of the society. That's when the regulations kick in and in this case this is the way the British prefers their society be regulated and protected.
Also, there being many people is not an argument, there are many people doing all kind of things and they stop when measures are taken.
- manigandham 9y agoI'm not sure what your comment is about. What other cases? There are plenty of issues with monopolies but in this case there was a small group that sued and now the ruling affects all drivers. When 99% of a group does not want measures, then it is absolutely a valid argument.
- mrtksn 9y agoCan I see the source of the "99% of a group does not want measures" argument? Anyway, even if that was the case(source please) you can't go against the law. If you ask heroine addicts they would probably want more heroine but if the society decides that it's not O.K. to use heroine, you shouldn't expect your drug business to operate just because the heroine users are happy with it. If you have a problem with the society's choice you can follow the regular democratic routes.
- manigandham 9y agoIt's in the article: 68 drivers in the lawsuit compared to all drivers affected. Nothing was against the law, the drivers were contractors. Whether that classification is correct is what the case was about, and now that the court ruled against, the drivers are must now be treated as employees. This isn't society's choice. Full-time driver employment already exists, but is not something that Uber provided. These few people chose to drive for Uber anyway and demand full-time employment, and then sued for it. They won their case and now all drivers are affected by it. The democratic route would mean majority voting, which is the opposite of what happened with this case.
- mrtksn 9y agohow do you know that other drivers are against? why do you think that the court’s decision was not based on the rule of the law? You are making too many assumptions. Your motivation looks ideological, apparently the british society choose not to go full libertarian.
- manigandham 9y agoYou're conflating many things throughout this thread. What does "based on the rule of the law" or "libertarian" have to do with anything? There was nothing illegal happening with drivers classified as contractors. Whether that classification should change is what was being reviewed by this tribunal and they've decided on a change. No rule of law was ever broken, the situation has changed, just like many rules and regulations are updated and companies adapt from before the change to after. In this case, a very small group create change that affects 100% of the drivers. The fact that only 68 total drivers joined this suit, started by only 2 originally, is a clear signal that it was at the very least not the full intent of the entire driving workforce. Perhaps they should've taken a vote before passing this ruling, especially since these people demanded something from Uber that was already easily attainable elsewhere (eg: a fulltime driving job).
- mrtksn 9y agoSo you think that it was equally possible that they could have been classified as au pairs? These things have a legal framework. And the low number could have easily be do to the disproportionate power of the company over the drivers. You can't claim that if 68 people are taking action those who don't take action are against those 68. And "Libertarian" has to do with the way the relationship between the businesses, the workers and the clients is regulated. Your argument about demand and supply is invalid because UK doesn't function purely on libertarian principles so the state has the right to say if these people are contractors or employees.