2 ms·
Another case of a small vocal minority creating unwanted regulation for the rest. Over several years and 1000s of rides in the US, 100% of the drivers I've aske
by manigandham 9y ago
Another case of a small vocal minority creating unwanted regulation for the rest. Over several years and 1000s of rides in the US, 100% of the drivers I've asked liked being independent and did not want to be employees. Many of them already had other jobs or were students or retirees that liked making money on the side.
For some reason, people keep forgetting that being a professional driver is easily available through Uber Black or any number of other transportation companies. Anyone who wants a full-time driving job can already get one.
Rulings like these will end up hurting the vast majority of drivers who will now have to show up for full-time shifts at locations and times that Uber determines, while earning less money. Good luck to them.
- steve_gh 9y agoOne issue is that in the UK, there is a tax called "National Insurance" or NI, which was originally intended to fund unempoyment benefits. As an employee, you have to pay a certain % of your wages. But the employer also has to pay a percentage of your salary, and they can't just deduct it from your wage. So, for Uber drivers on a minimum wage (£7.50 an hour), the 13.8% that Uber will pay will bump that up to approx £9 an hour that Uber has to pay. Then they will also require Employer's Liability Insurance (as the drivers are employees), will have to offer pension provision (legally required for all full-time employees in the UK), etc.
- mrtksn 9y agoIs it an absolute must to go to work everyday if you are formally employed? Isn't it possible have the same flexibility if you put it on your employment contract?
- manigandham 9y agoOf course FT employment comes with vacation and sick time, but why would you get the same flexibility? Uber is 100% in charge of determining where and when you work, and you get paid the same hourly/salary regardless of how much work there is, so they'll optimize for riders as much as possible. In the long run it might be better for Uber, more tightly controlled supply will mean cheaper and better rides while drivers make less. I can see surge pricing becoming pure profit when you can just order drivers to be at a certain place instead.
- mrtksn 9y agoWhat about 0 hour contracts? What about literally writing down the flexibility you want in the contract? If you think about it, it's kind of ridiculous to pretend that drivers are running businesses and employing themselves while all they do is ride a car just like an employee. If there's a reason for employees to have certain right, the same reasons should apply to the Uber drivers, therefore they should receive the same benefits.
- manigandham 9y agoWhy would Uber accept those contracts? There are plenty of drivers, they're not going to hire you if you stipulate all these conditions, especially if they're paying a flat wage. > it's kind of ridiculous Why? Many people are individual contractors, what is different about providing transportation as a service?
- mrtksn 9y agoWell, there could be other cases where a business may have disproportional power and use it to exploit the elements of the society. That's when the regulations kick in and in this case this is the way the British prefers their society be regulated and protected. Also, there being many people is not an argument, there are many people doing all kind of things and they stop when measures are taken.
- manigandham 9y agoI'm not sure what your comment is about. What other cases? There are plenty of issues with monopolies but in this case there was a small group that sued and now the ruling affects all drivers. When 99% of a group does not want measures, then it is absolutely a valid argument.
- mrtksn 9y agoCan I see the source of the "99% of a group does not want measures" argument? Anyway, even if that was the case(source please) you can't go against the law. If you ask heroine addicts they would probably want more heroine but if the society decides that it's not O.K. to use heroine, you shouldn't expect your drug business to operate just because the heroine users are happy with it. If you have a problem with the society's choice you can follow the regular democratic routes.