4 ms·
The flip side of this is that if Uber considers drivers as employees they could also prevent them from driving for their rivals. I think the shift toward the "
by koolba 9y ago
The flip side of this is that if Uber considers drivers as employees they could also prevent them from driving for their rivals.
I think the shift toward the "gig economy" is going to see the creation of a third classification of worker that sits between employee and contractor, likely with the negatives of both. The financial services sector has a version of this by employing large numbers of contractors indirectly through body shops. I wouldn't be surprised if we go that route here too with Uber/Lyft owning the platform yet deferring employment costs to a separate company. Their providers would be businesses, not people, and to sign up to be a driver one would apply at one of those businesses.
- fiftyacorn 9y agoarent zero hour contracts effectively the third classification?
- koolba 9y agoHad to look that up[1] as I've never heard of it before (I'm from the USA and it's a primarily UK concept). Based on my skimming of it, I think you'd still have the platform dealing with businesses, but the businesses would likely hire workers with this type of arrangement. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-hour_contract https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-hour_contract
- danpalmer 9y agoIn certain areas Uber strongly incentivizes drivers to only drive for Uber. This is done by making driving only cost-effective at 40+ hours a week. I understand this doesn't happen (or doesn't work) in some areas, New York comes to mind, but I've never met an Uber driver in the UK for whom it a) isn't a full time job, and b) who drives for other companies as well.
- icebraining 9y agoThis is done by making driving only cost-effective at 40+ hours a week. How do they do that?
- koolba 9y agoPay $x/unit if less than 10 units. Pay $y/unit if between 10 and 40 units. Pay $z/unit if between 40 and 60 units. The values for x and y may be too low to be economical so a driver would need to work more units (hours, miles, whatever) to get the higher z rate. That would preclude them from working for a competitor as there a finite number of hours per week.
- icebraining 9y agoI'm not asking how they could do that. danpalmer says Uber is already making driving only cost-effective at 40+ hours a week, I'm asking how they are doing so.
- koolba 9y agoI’ve seen bonuses for driving at least X hours or Y rides per week. You can only achieve them by being active as a driver for an extended period of time.
- Dobbs 9y agoAs far as I can tell in the UK there aren’t really alternatives. Maybe in parts of London? Outside options seem to be mini cabs, traditional black cabs, and Uber. Lyft for example doesn’t run here.
- Silhouette 9y agoMost big cities in the UK have at least one and often multiple private hire firms, who you can call to book a vehicle to take you somewhere. Usually there are also taxis that you can pick up without booking in advance, which are providing a different kind of service and normally regulated by the local authorities. In practice, the private hire firms often charge on a meter the same as local taxis for local journeys even if they're not technically required to, so a lot of people don't realise there's a difference. There are plenty of alternatives to Uber in most major residential areas of the UK.
- Dobbs 9y agoI listed all of those. My point was that you don't have the situation like in San Francisco where a driver drives for Uber+Lyft+RandomOtherStartup at the same time. A minicab is a minicab, an uber is an uber, and a black cab is a black cab.
- Silhouette 9y agoThe law here in England already recognises other types of employment status, including a possibility of someone being a "worker" but not an "employee". The rights and protections that apply are somewhat different. In addition, we have a variety of rules around contracting/freelancing, "gig" jobs, "zero-hours contracts", and other variations. In some of these cases there are genuine advantages to all parties of working in a certain way, but in other cases a similar-seeming arrangement may be exploitative. Successive governments have tried to deal with these issues, but unfortunately with very little achieved in terms of protecting the vulnerable while in some cases causing significant damage even if the arrangement was all above board and everyone involved was happy with it.
- smileysteve 9y ago> they could also prevent them from driving for their rivals They'd have a really hard time having such a clause stand up in court, especially in California where non-competes traditionally don't stand. Many courts have determined that non-competes only stand if your company is actively paying you(and expecting you to work - in the case of moonlighters working a job after their 8 hour job) unless exclusive knowledge/power exists - which must be compensated for accordingly. Knowledge/power might exist in terms of surging locations; but uber drivers are currently only paid for their time after they accept a ride.