4 ms·
> You can go to jail for destroying evidence, why would encrypting the data and refusing to provide the password or deleting the key be any different? Specific
by JoshTriplett 9y ago
> You can go to jail for destroying evidence, why would encrypting the data and refusing to provide the password or deleting the key be any different?
Specifically encrypting incriminating data after you have evidence of a crime in an effort to cover it up should be treated as the equivalent of shredding documents. (Assuming, of course, they can prove it, just as they have to prove that you had the documents in question prior to destroying them in order to prosecute you for destroying evidence.)
That's not in any way the same thing as having your data encrypted and refusing to decrypt it.
- Spivak 9y agoI don't really think the timeline is meaningful in this case. Having a rule where people cannot be made to decrypt files is just legalizing document shredding with an extra step. To avoid cases where people legitimately forgot their passwords just assume that the police have video evidence of you unlocking the files just before you were arrested. You know the passphrase and the police could prove it beyond reasonable doubt in court. You just start with your files encrypted with a strong passphrase and refuse to provide it when you get caught. This is different than routine shredding because the moment when they become inaccessible is when you refuse, not the moment you encrypted them. If they were instead physical documents buried somewhere hidden where the police could not possibly find them without your help the court still has the ability to hold you in contempt if you don't produce them. What makes the secret knowledge of their location any different than the secret knowledge of the password?
- AlexCoventry 9y agoEncryption of the file should be treated as a separate step from deletion of the plain text. The latter is destruction of evidence in the case of a crime.
- ohtwenty 9y agoAre you arguing you should legally have to keep a plain text copy of anything you encrypt? I mean I get your train of thought but that seems to be the conclusion
- AlexCoventry 9y agoNo, only that destruction of evidence could pertain to deleting the plaintext of crime-related documents.
- Spivak 9y agoThis is a tough sell when hard drive manufacturers use encryption to implement a secure instantaneous delete. You can't really argue that the files were deleted the moment they were encrypted.
- michaelmrose 9y ago"If they were instead physical documents buried somewhere hidden where the police could not possibly find them without your help the court still has the ability to hold you in contempt if you don't produce them" Are you sure this is so, this sounds awfully similar to compelling you to testify against yourself. Perhaps you are confused.
- kelnos 9y agoNot really. If it is a foregone conclusion that the documents exist, the court can legally compel you to turn them over.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> If it is a foregone conclusion that the documents exist, the court can legally compel you to turn them over. Are you sure? That would imply that you could be compelled to produce documents that are known to exist but were stolen from you. It seems like a faulty premise. If they don't know where the documents are then how could they know they haven't been stolen or destroyed? It's the same problem with encryption keys. Just because you had it yesterday doesn't mean you have it today. People actually lose or forget things, especially under stress. That's one of the main purposes of protection against self-incrimination -- so that the government can't claim you know something that you don't and then hold you in contempt for not telling them.
- Spivak 9y ago> but were stolen from you. You're forgetting that the courts are human and would be sympathetic in this case. If it couldn't be shown that you have access to the documents or you could show they were stolen then you would be fine. > Just because you had it yesterday doesn't mean you have it today Right, which is why I prefaced the discussion with the situations where the police can prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you posses the key/password. We can make it more direct by arresting you immediately after you prove on video that you're capable of decrypting the documents. > can't claim you know something Right, but the difference is we're talking about a case where they can prove you know something. We're firmly in foregone conclusion territory.
- JoshTriplett 9y ago> This is different than routine shredding because the moment when they become inaccessible is when you refuse, not the moment you encrypted them. Not true. The moment you encrypted them, they became inaccessible without your consent.
- dTal 9y agoStrictly speaking, it's the moment you delete the unencrypted originals.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> This is different than routine shredding because the moment when they become inaccessible is when you refuse, not the moment you encrypted them. If it really had anything to do with when you refuse then you could just proactively refuse as soon as you encrypt so it happens at the same time. And it would imply that if you were killed before being asked to decrypt then the government would have access to the data because you never refused, which is obviously not true.
- Spivak 9y agoThe refusal was specific to this situation. The data also becomes inaccessible the moment a person is incapable of producing the password like when they die. When does encrypted data become inaccessible? When you encrypted them or when you forgot the password?
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> When does encrypted data become inaccessible? When you encrypted them or when you forgot the password? Inaccessible to which party? It becomes inaccessible to anyone without the key immediately and inaccessible to anyone with the key when they forget the key. Compare the situation where a person commits a document to memory and then destroys it, but writes down some inscrutable clues to help them remember it. You have some gibberish you can't decipher, if you give them the gibberish they can recreate the original document, but it's only by application of information that exists only in their mind.