5 ms·
On the other hand all those other people at Facebook have those jobs because Zuckerberg built the company and hired them. How do you prevent Zuckerberg from pro
by simonh 9y ago
On the other hand all those other people at Facebook have those jobs because Zuckerberg built the company and hired them. How do you prevent Zuckerberg from profiting from doing that without also choking off the funding and investment he needed to grow that company so rapidly in just a few years? If anyone deserves that kind of compensation, isn’t it someone who built a business that provides 20,000 jobs and a free service used by over a billion people every day? Isn’t that the kind of person that, perhaps above most others, knows how to use billions of dollars to do something worthwhile?
How do we make sure he has the resources to build and fund that business, while denying him the funds and resources to do other legal activities as well? Who gets to decide yes you can spend billions on building Facebook, but no you can’t spend it on real estate that’s legal for other people to buy? How do we restrict that by law and ensure the people enforcing those restrictions don’t kill off the next Facebook, or the next holiday resort company, etc? Command economies don’t have much of a track record of economic success.
I say all that without even liking Facebook, I barely use it and am annoyed by a lot of their business practices, but I have no right to tell people which company they should work for or which social network they should use or what company or project allowed by the law that they should or should not fund.
Capitalism is ultimately about the individual freedom of citizens to spend or invest their money as they see fit. How do you justify taking away those freedoms and how to you do so without choking off innovation and growth?
- khazhou 9y agoOn the other hand it WAS NOT Zuckerberg who built the company and hired 20000 people. Zuckerberg hired the first few, those all built the first stage and hired the next round of prople, who built and hired more. The success of FB or any company is due to their combined efforts. And, it’s built over the efforts of hundreds of thousands more who built the critical infrastructure outside FB. Of course Zuck should reap more rewards for his founding and leadership role. But not to the tune of 75 billion dollars. And it should not require billion-dollar paydays to incentivize people to build companies.
- thatswrong0 9y agoIf Zuckerberg didn’t exist, Facebook as it stands would not exist. Everyone he hired agreed to be compensated with the terms he decreed. Every person he gave equity, every person whose salary he directly determined, they all agreed to the terms of their employment. No one was forced to work for him or Facebook. Why should he be forced to relinquish control or equity in his company if literally everyone he worked with agreed to the terms of their employment at his company? Who is the person that should decide “oh, at this point he has enough, he doesn’t deserve more”? You? Some other corrupt government individual? I just don’t understand why you think that random people should be able to determine the fate of a fortune that someone amassed when they had nothing to do with it. He pays his taxes. Facebook pays their taxes as required by law. Why do you think that’s not enough? I understand closing loopholes, but you apparently think we should go further? You think that we should set a hard cap on wealth? How would that not create adverse economic incentives?
- khazhou 9y agoYes, taxes should effectively impose a cap on wealth, reaching 99% tax rate at some point (certainly, when you're in the billions). If a founder decides to move on because he can no longer earn a billion... well, we as a society will just have to live with that tragic loss of leadership, and hope that somebody will be brave enough to take over. Also, I'm not confused about people agreeing to their compensation terms. That's true and not the issue, any more than royalty was "ok" because for many hundreds of years, people were ok with it. There's a funnel that leads to one human being having over 75-million times more than another. We tolerate this today. And here in the tech world, we make apologies for it (even while many still manage to scoff at Wall St)
- thatswrong0 9y agoThe difference is that people voluntarily agreed to the terms of compensation with Facebook.. the same can’t be said of people who deal with royalty existing in their society. People may have been ok with it, but they didn’t have a choice. Your whole argument seems to come from the viewpoint that wealth is zero-sum.. when it so obviously isn’t.
- croon 9y agoOn the other hand in a parallell universe no one would care if it was Myspace or Friendster instead of Facebook. Advancements are made regardless of the fantastical sums awarded just the very few on top.