4 ms·
The package manager is mostly a win. I almost never have problems installing things on Linux. I remember lots of problems (usually driver related) for Windows,
by the_af 9y ago
The package manager is mostly a win. I almost never have problems installing things on Linux. I remember lots of problems (usually driver related) for Windows, back in the day (disclaimer: last version of Windows I ever touched was Windows 7).
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoThat's because Windows has a similar problem. Registry, shared libs placed in system directories, hardcoded paths, uninstallers that don't work, etc. These things don't have to work like this. The package manager solves a problem that shouldn't even be a problem in the first place.
- the_af 9y agoOk, but then we haven't found a Windows advantage. I think Windows is a pain to use [1]; everything about it seems second-rate to me. My theory is that familiarity matters a lot: now that it's been years since I last touched a Windows PC, everything seems weird, difficult and awkward about it. Someone equally unfamiliar with both Windows or a user-friendly Linux like Ubuntu wouldn't have a harder time with the latter. "These things don't have to work like this" is a fine sentiment -- and one with which I agree on principle! -- but I suspect package managers themselves started that way: "this is unnecessarily difficult, let's fix it". My bet is that with almost every solution, you'll trade one set of problems for another :) ---- [1] To be fair, I'm talking about Windows circa Windows 7. Just as I'm annoyed by people who claim "you cannot game on Linux" because they last touched a distro a decade ago and keep talking about problems from the past, so I should admit I've no idea how usable Windows is these days. Maybe it got better... just like Linux did.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoI wasn't making an argument for Windows' advantages, though there are many. To list a few: modern display server and compositing window manager that can handle multi-gpu multi-monitor seamlessly, doesn't explode when you add or remove a display, can recover from graphics driver crashes and install and use graphics drivers without a reboot, and doesn't drop all your windows while doing so. When people say you can't game on Linux, they mean it the same way one might say you can't game on a phone: it isn't impossible, it's just that you'll have a worse experience, and there's nothing Linux offers to them to justify the extra hoops to jump through and other downsides. If you've made "gamer" part of your identity, that's probably pretty important to you. But my point was really, who gives a shit how Windows does it? Aim to be better than Windows where you can instead of trying to offer a cheap Windows knock-off. And honestly, package managers don't fix anything, they just cover it up with automation and bring a lot of limitations along. For instance, you can't install 2 different versions of the same application (unless the package repository is specifically designed so you can do that for certain applications), you can't install applications to alternate paths, and you can't move applications around. Until AppImage came along Linux had no concept of a portable application, which is usually a pretty trivial thing in Windows. But instead of saying "wait, why are we installing applications this way? can we just do that differently and eliminate the problem?" they went ahead and wrote a complicated centralized database that tracks nearly every file on the system and its relationships just to try and avoid issues that, frankly, have no reason to exist in the first place. DOS had tons of applications and not a goddamned one of them required a package manager to get installed. Sorry if this is a little ranty, it just irks me that so often OSS developers (Linux Desktop devs especially) seem to choose the most complex possible answer to any given problem.
- the_af 9y agoI've no problem with multi-monitor setups with Linux, but it doesn't matter because nobody cares about seamless multi-gpu multi-monitor setups, compositing windows managers, or systemd (which someone else bizarrely mentioned in the comments elsewhere, as if it mattered) or any other such technicalities -- that's not the reason regular people use or don't use an OS. We believe this sort of stuff matters because we're nerds and know too much for our own goods, but it honestly doesn't matter to regular users. They want to use their PCs to watch movies, browse internet, play the occasional game, edit some simple documents, use a spreadsheet, and get some stuff done. It certainly doesn't matter for the kind of uses discussed in TFA: administrative software. > [gaming on Linux] isn't impossible, it's just that you'll have a worse experience, and there's nothing Linux offers to [gamers] to justify the extra hoops to jump through and other downsides "Worse" is relative. Worse than Windows? True. OS X is also worse than Windows for gaming, but it's still praised by a lot of people. When people say "you can't game on Linux", they are simply mistaken or believe things that were true a decade ago. I know this because I own and play lots of AAA games on Linux. Sometimes I have to manually edit a config file or install a library... the horror! (Still nothing compared to getting some games to run on DOS back in the day... do you remember HIMEM, DOS4GW and all the other black magic you had to do just to get some goddamn games to run?) > If you've made "gamer" part of your identity, that's probably pretty important to you. If you've made "gamer" part of your identity, none of this matters. You either own tons of consoles and/or have a very expensive PC setup. You're also in the minority, so again: who cares (in the context of this discussion)? I confess I find the rest of your rant about package managers very hard to follow. Your comparison to DOS seems bizarre to me. DOS was nothing at all like a modern OS, and applications have changed (and multiplied!) since the old days, as I'm sure you remember.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago> They want to use their PCs to watch movies, browse internet, play the occasional game, edit some simple documents, use a spreadsheet, and get some stuff done. Except for the getting stuff done part, those are tablet users (I mean, they really only need a browser and may as well be using a tablet or ChromeOS). This sort of strawman "average" user, and the obsession with catering to them while at the same time insisting on your own superiority, is what has doomed the Linux Desktop to what it is today. You can tell yourself all you want that it's everyone else's fault Linux Desktop has a market share south of 4%, but it won't make it true. Also digging the "works fine for me!", straight out of the Linux Evangelist playbook from 1995.
- slededit 9y agoThe problem for me is this weird concept of tying my application updates to my OS updates. If I want the latest Visual Studio I don't need to update my whole OS first. But without adding untrusted repos updating clang Somehow requires updating everything.
- flukus 9y ago> If I want the latest Visual Studio I don't need to update my whole OS first. "apt-get install visual-studio" would do this, it would only update dependencies of visual studio, which is pretty identical to what a stand alone visual studio installer would do. > The problem for me is this weird concept of tying my application updates to my OS updates. The only alternative seems to be bundling what should be in the OS with the application, which is why your printer driver is a 600MB download. This way is much more secure though because the OS pushes security updates, having random apps with random old binaries on your computer is a growing security threat. The equifax breach was an example of this, had the library they were using been provided by the OS it would have been much more likely to be patched. > But without adding untrusted repos updating clang Somehow requires updating everything. What do you mean here? Updating clang should only require a handful of developer tools to be updated.
- slededit 9y ago> "apt-get install visual-studio" would do this, it would only update dependencies of visual studio. When I install VS I don't want other applications sharing dependencies with it to get upgraded or change. > What do you mean here? Updating clang should only require a handful of developer tools to be updated. No because the newer clang is not in the repo. By policy most distros will only backport security fixes not provide updates to applications.
- flukus 9y ago> When I install VS I don't want other applications sharing dependencies with it to get upgraded or change. Generally they won't change, you'll just get the security updates you would/should have installed anyway. > No because the newer clang is not in the repo. It sounds like you're adding a more bleeding edge repository that contains much more than just clang, is that correct? On debian based distro's I believe this can be done by pinning, but it's been quite a while since I've done that, from memory I do think it was a bit of a pain to setup correctly.