3 ms·
> The trolley problem is "there's something everywhere inside my stopping distance, we will inevitably hit something" You assume humans make correct decisions
by bsder 9y ago
> The trolley problem is "there's something everywhere inside my stopping distance, we will inevitably hit something"
You assume humans make correct decisions when faced with that situation. Most of the time humans make incorrect decisions when faced with far less problematic issues.
"Swerve" is normally more reflex than thought. The number of times that drivers "swerve" to avoid something like an animal and then crash headfirst into oncoming traffic, thereby injuring humans, is non-trivial.
- D-Coder 9y ago"Swerve" ha. I think the typical driver in this situation will scream a bad word, jam on the brakes, and skid into whatever is straight ahead. If an autonomous vehicle does better than this at all, it's a win.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoDo I? Nowhere did I bring that up. The TP is a model to compare the possible executions and their outcomes - and yes, human reflexes are not optimized for driving, thus the response is often "crash into other traffic/wayside obstruction", or even "oversteer, flip the car and become briefly airborne". I do agree that "just hit whatever is straight ahead" could be the optimal strategy in many cases, not sure if it makes sense to hardcode it.