6 ms·
By that argument you should also stop using: .org, .ngo, .lgbt, .asia, .aero, .info, .mobi, .pro, , .MN (Mongolia), .AG (Antigua and Barbuda), .BM (Bermuda),
by bryanlarsen 9y ago
By that argument you should also stop using:
.org, .ngo, .lgbt, .asia, .aero, .info, .mobi, .pro, , .MN (Mongolia), .AG (Antigua and Barbuda), .BM (Bermuda), .BZ (Belize), .GI (Gibraltar), .IN (India), .ME (Montenegro), .SC (the Seychelles), and .VC (St. Vincent and the Grenadines), .SG (Singapore) and .HN (Honduras) and more
All are provided or supported by Afilias, the company running .IO.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afilias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afilias
- Multicomp 9y agoFWIW a glance at that wikipedia page does not show any references to the .IO TLD. According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.io https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/.io .IO TLD is run by Internet Computer Bureau - are they the same/related companies?
- bryanlarsen 9y agohttps://www.internetnews.me/2017/04/12/afilias-wins-contract-run-backend-registry-services-io-ac-sh/ https://www.internetnews.me/2017/04/12/afilias-wins-contract...
- tbarbugli 9y agonic.io contact page links to https://www.icb.co.uk/ https://www.icb.co.uk/ which is not reachable
- detaro 9y agoI can't find an obvious source on Afilias running .IO? nic.io doesn't link to it, Afilias doesn't list .io on their homepage as one of "their" TLDs, ... EDIT: Google finds some announcements where registrars tell their customers about a switchover of the registry backend to Afilias June 10th, 2017. Wonder if they run the DNS or not? The nameservers are in IP space owned by ICB, but that doesn't necessarily mean anything.
- cwmma 9y agoyou sure about that? the Wikipedia page on Afilias doens't list IO as one of their domains, and the Wikipedia page on .io says tje 'Internet Computer Bureau' runs it, with them also running the .sh and .ac domains.
- coderholic 9y agoYes it was transferred from icb to affilias in July
- Rotten194 9y agoTheir point was to not run mission-critical API traffic on those domains, which seems reasonable.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- feld 9y agomy .me domain is my primary domain and won't expire for 10 years. Also I've never observed an outage for it like this.
- tbarbugli 9y agoAuthor here: the post is based on my direct experience with .io. It is not very clear to me how Afilias is involved in the operational side of things, AFAIK they might have just acquired the existing .io infrastructure and kept it as it is (and same goes for the way more reliable .org TLD)
- rmetzler 9y agoThis is a blogpost by Planio about moving from .io to .com https://plan.io/blog/post/166816338743/moving-from-planio-to-planiocom https://plan.io/blog/post/166816338743/moving-from-planio-to...
- bringtheaction 9y agoGoing to planio.com redirects to plan.io, so whatever they had to say about moving from .io to .com can't be worth reading.
- mottomotto 9y agoI was curious -- it's actually worth reading. "We have therefore decided to match what we paid for .io domains in the past with donations to the Chagos Conservation Trust and the UK Chagos Support Association. We will continue to do so every year - as long as we will have our .io domain (or the Chagossians start receiving their fair share of the domain business)." I don't fault them for keeping their .io considering the downsides of not doing so.
- tbarbugli 9y ago> Using .io is unfair to the Chagossian People > The reason closest to our hearts is the geopolitical background of .io domains which we only learned about recently. Later in the article: > Of course, we will make sure to redirect all traffic from *.plan.io appropriately so no existing links will break in the future. Which to me sounds like they will keep paying for the .io domain for the foreseeable future.
- 9y ago
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoIt's not an all-or-nothing proposition. Some TLDs are more flaky. Some aren't. There's a whole continuum there, with good TLDs on top and bad TLDs at the bottom. Make your own decision based on this information.
- egeozcan 9y agoCurrently there is one blog post about an outage and a lot of speculation. I don't think there's enough information to make an "informed" decision. On the other hand, if you use .com, and the whole thing breaks, that from a users perspective means "the internet just broke", so your small startup won't be at the top of the list of sites people will complain about.
- asdfaoeu 9y agoThere's been like three IO outages and plus one user registered the nameserver domains to intercept traffic.
- Operyl 9y agoThat makes it sound a lot more malicious than it actually is. Said user is an ex-Googler, did it to see if he could, went "oh shit" and immediately started serving SERVFAIL on it so other nameservers would be used. His intention wasn't to intercept traffic.
- JelteF 9y agoWe were not the only ones affected by the outage: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15293578 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15293578
- devnull42 9y ago.IO is historically terrible and seem to have no idea what they are doing. Being it downtime, security or general DNS policy.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- BinaryIdiot 9y agoIt was my understanding that Afilias purchased .io and kept using the existing infrastructure. I believe they have gotten many TLDs through acquisitions so I'm not sure you can compare all of them fairly.
- ca98am79 9y agono, they do not use the same infrastructure - it was migrated to Afilias. I own a .io registrar and I went through the migration process in June
- HNSucksAss 9y agoToo bad ICANN't failed to do what they should have done: eliminate all limits on TLDs. There's no reason domains shouldn't end with any string... except of course that wouldn't allow ICANN to rip everyone off for hundreds of thousands of dollars each.
- nodesocket 9y agoI have pingdom monitors on my .io domains, to my memory and according to Pingdom there was only one extended outage (Sept 20th) due to domain DNS. I'm growing so weary of people (mostly a developer complex) complaining about everything and expecting perfection from technology products or even worse open source projects.