4 ms·
The difference is, though, that the human driver is always capable of pressing it, and you have no way of proving that they certifiably never do in any situatio
by CydeWeys 9y ago
The difference is, though, that the human driver is always capable of pressing it, and you have no way of proving that they certifiably never do in any situation.
If a self-driving car isn't programmed to ever use the horn, though, then that's a different situation. It's easy to prove that it can't ever use the horn because it isn't programmed to do so. That's more akin to a normal car having a horn in it that isn't wired up.
- lmm 9y ago> The difference is, though, that the human driver is always capable of pressing it, and you have no way of proving that they certifiably never do in any situation. Why should that make a difference though? Imagine e.g. a truck backed into a car when the (human) driver didn't press the horn. Is the car driver liable? Whether the driver might have pressed the horn under other circumstances doesn't seem like it has any bearing on that question. We're judged on what we did, not what we might have done - shouldn't it be the same for the software?
- Piskvorrr 9y agoNot quite. We're also judged on intent: "why didn't the driver press the horn? Was it because he was busy not-driving-into something else, because he was busy texting, or because the horn was not connected to the button?". If we were judged only on did/didn't, law would be a straightforward and uninteresting field of human endeavor.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>Whether the driver might have pressed the horn under other circumstances doesn't seem like it has any bearing on that question Replace that with some other subsystem that is practically necessary for safe operation in a commonly encountered subset of driving situation requires manual activation and we require vehicles to have. Lights, wipers, brakes, seatbelts, defrost, etc. See the problem?
- lmm 9y ago> Replace that with some other subsystem that is practically necessary for safe operation in a commonly encountered subset of driving situation requires manual activation and we require vehicles to have. > Lights, wipers, brakes, seatbelts, defrost, etc. > See the problem? No, I really don't. I think a human driver would and should obviously be prosecuted for not using lights, wipers, brakes, or defrost in a situation that called for them (seatbelts have specific laws about them). It's not at all obvious to me that this would ever happen with the horn.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>No, I really don't. I think a human driver would and should obviously be prosecuted for not using lights, wipers, brakes, or defrost in a situation that called for them (seatbelts have specific laws about them). It's not at all obvious to me that this would ever happen with the horn. The point is that code that can't use those systems is no better than them not existing which is not something we're ok with. Society accepts that it's not unreasonable for whoever calling the shots (human or not) to misjudge a situation and not use some system when they should and that this may result in a crash. Society does not tolerate a vehicle that does not have those systems. Code that cannot use those systems is effectively the same as not having them.
- dkersten 9y agoOne has the ability to use the horn, the other does not. Not having the ability to use the horn is the same thing as not having a horn at all. Having a horn and the ability to use it, but choosing not to, for whatever reason, is very different from not having the ability to begin with.
- squeaky-clean 9y agoYes, the human is liable in that situation. The car manufacturer does not become liable just because the human did not press the horn. But if your car can only press the horn programmatically, and you never add the code to allow the horn to function, you don't actually have a horn, that's the vehicle's problem.