2 ms·
> At the appointed time, I take my phone, passport, birth certificate, SSN card, driver's license and recent electric bill with my address on it to the local SS
by kelnos 9y ago
> At the appointed time, I take my phone, passport, birth certificate, SSN card, driver's license and recent electric bill with my address on it to the local SSA office.
Say I'm homeless and I literally do not have any of those things. How do I prove my identity? (To be fair, I'm not sure how I'd prove my identity under the current system.)
Regardless of this... I can't have a credit card or any kind of loan without owning a smartphone? What if I can only afford a feature phone? What if I simply don't want to own a phone? What if own a Windows Phone, and the software only runs on Android and iOS? What if I'm a developer who wants to start a new phone OS (new huge barrier to entry)?
I suppose I wouldn't be opposed to the option of having this stored on my phone, but what's wrong with just having a smart card with this information on it? If I lose it, it can still be easily revoked and replaced.
- nthj 9y agoIn retrospect, I'm not sure I was clear enough that my proposal was mostly a usability / familiarity hack for the general public. I agree this would only be an option. Specifically, if I'm not in a financial position to own and maintain a smartphone, OR I'm not inclined to trust Apple or Google with my identity, I could acquire a (heavily subsidized?) smart card from the SSA office. If I don't trust a national office with my identity (see the National ID debacle), I can choose not to use the system entirely. Banks can continue to offer to extend me credit by verifying my identity manually. Specifically, I wrote: > no one can be held liable for—and credit decisions may not be made against—accounts that have not been digitally signed for any citizen //who has a verified public key.// My idea being that if Bank of America sends me to collections or pursues a judgement against me, I can take them to small claims for the statutory limit by easily showing the judge that (1) I had a verified public key at the date of the debt and (2) Bank of America cannot provide my digital signature showing I accepted the debt. I'm in and out in a few hours and clear $5K. If the proposal above had even 20% rollout/adoption, that's 65 million people who can sleep a bit more soundly at night knowing their identity is–not perfectly secure—but FAR more secure than our current system.