3 ms·
"edit: For another example, http://www.mail-archive.com/nanog@merit.edu/msg04890.html http://www.mail-archive.com/nanog@merit.edu/msg04890.html and Vixie's repl
by SwellJoe 16y ago
"edit: For another example, http://www.mail-archive.com/nanog@merit.edu/msg04890.html http://www.mail-archive.com/nanog@merit.edu/msg04890.html and Vixie's reply ("zeal must become the norm.") at http://www.mail-archive.com/nanog@merit.edu/msg04904.html http://www.mail-archive.com/nanog@merit.edu/msg04904.html -- this is simply fundamentalism, and it will not lead to a healthy internet."
This is an 8 year old post. And, I think, it's turned out to be an accurate prediction.
ISPs no longer run open relays, ever. In 2002, an awful lot of them had open relays, and did nothing to prevent spam from their users. Likewise hosting providers; if the server owner was paying the bills, they'd keep the lights on for them, even if they were spewing millions of messages a day into the world.
SMTP authentication has become standard and well-supported by all mail clients and mail servers, and is easy to configure.
DNS is now a fundamental part of the spam prevention regime, and DKIM makes it moreso.
Spamming costs more today, relatively speaking, than it did eight years ago. Not just because of RBLs, but it certainly doesn't hurt. Spammers have to keep moving, constantly, in order to keep sending out their spam. Making it cost more is the only thing that works. Asking nicely doesn't do it.
"It's clear when you enumerate the list of problems that you have to spend time on that you're focusing mostly on things which bother a system administrator -- software updates and that sort of thing. However, I'm focusing on problems which bother users -- business owners, employees, individuals, professionals"
System administrators are the ones who have to fix any problems in the mail server. They see all the problems, not just one email going rogue.
Users also care about spam. Users care a lot about spam. Try turning off your spam filters altogether, and see how much happier your customers are. I bet they'll be really excited to know they aren't missing any mail (especially the 823 messages from a Nigerian prince, and the 348 messages about "テクニックに自信ありますか"--I have no idea what that translates to, it's just a spam in my spam folder right now).
RBLs do reduce spam, and make it harder for spammers to operate. I'll continue to use them (in a limited, weighted, manner) until DKIM or some other authentication mechanism makes them completely unnecessary. Spam is a serious problem, and it takes dramatic solutions to fix it.
It seems to me that all the hoopla has long since past. The problems that RBL maintainers were fighting against are no longer standard practice, and when you run into them it generally means the system administrator has done something wrong. False positives are certainly a bad thing, but they happen in all spam fighting systems.
Anyway, I wouldn't use them as a binary switch and I don't know many people that suggest doing so these days, but I certainly like having them available in SpamAssassin.