10 ms·
This reminds me of the recurring Onion title: ‘No Way To Prevent This,’ Says Only Nation Where This Regularly Happens. I don't understand why the US has ident
by StavrosK 9y ago
This reminds me of the recurring Onion title:
‘No Way To Prevent This,’ Says Only Nation Where This Regularly Happens.
I don't understand why the US has identity theft. Is it because there's no national ID? Here in Europe we don't have any "secret" number that someone can just use to open a bank account in your name.
- yxhuvud 9y agoWe still have identity theft in Europe, though the procedure to accomplish it effectively is usually more involved.
- StavrosK 9y agoHmm, really? I've never heard of any cases, what does it look like?
- ryanlol 9y agoYou get phished, someone sells your info, the buyer empties your bank account over the phone. This and variations are very common in Europe.
- icebraining 9y agoYour posts in this thread would be more helpful with some source. Is it personal experience? Are you an European LEO?
- ryanlol 9y agoPersonal experience. I used to frequent several private forums related to this sort of activity and had many friends who did this for a living. I am fascinated by the inner workings of these things, so naturally I asked lots of questions. There used to be some public discussions on the alphabay forums, which was filled with small time bank fraudsters from both the US and the EU. The EU ones actually seemed much more prevalent. I couldn't find many interesting scrapes quickly, but this one might be worth a look: https://evidencebasedsecurity.org/forums/data/dk/darkode_scrape.zip https://evidencebasedsecurity.org/forums/data/dk/darkode_scr... I'm sure there's an AB forum scrape floating around somewhere too... But not here https://www.gwern.net/DNM-archives https://www.gwern.net/DNM-archives
- gwern 9y ago> I'm sure there's an AB forum scrape floating around somewhere too... But not here https://www.gwern.net/DNM-archives https://www.gwern.net/DNM-archives I believe the AlphaBay forums were integrated into the main site and so would be findable in the AB dump; most DNMs kept their forums on separate .onions so had to be crawled separately.
- ryanlol 9y agoI'm 100% sure the AB forums were separate from the main site and on a different onion address. Perhaps you're confusing with Hansa? I'll grab the dump and check the contents anyway.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jcassee 9y agoSee for example this story about Jeremy Clarkson. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/7174760.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/7174760.stm He published his bank account details (and how to find his address) and dared people to withdraw funds from it. Which people did.
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoTo be fair, people didn't withdraw funds, someone was able to set up a recurring transfer (direct debit) from his account to a charity. Which makes it useless for theft, since the thief would leave definite proof of their identity (receiving account number). The best part, I think, is Clarkson's response: Clarkson now says of the case: "Contrary to what I said at the time, we must go after the idiots who lost the [personal information] and stick cocktail sticks in their eyes until they beg for mercy."
- jandrese 9y agoBank fraud frequently requires the crook to supply an account number to transfer the funds to. This is not a problem if the only activity on the account is: 1. Opened with a fake identity 2. Stolen funds received 3. Stolen funds transferred to a bank with (intentionally) poor record keeping, potentially bouncing around a few more times. Wire transfers seem to be a big hole at the moment.
- TorKlingberg 9y agoThat's in the UK, which has a common law system like the US.
- tialaramex 9y agoThe Direct Debit is 100% reversible. Clarkson didn't reverse it because the people who did it chose a charity and he can afford the money. If you found the money was somehow going to an actual crook you'd reverse it. A utility company Direct Debited money from me when they screwed up and billed me for someone else's supply. I called my bank, said I wanted the Direct Debit cancelled and the money returned, they did it and the money was back in my account the same day. The utility company sent me all manner of outraged paperwork, including threatening to set lawyers on me, but they couldn't magically take my money, and sure enough once they understood their mistake I got an apology and they wrote off all my actual bills for the past 12 months.
- yxhuvud 9y agoSomeone opens an account in your name, order 2fa credentials (to your real address), pick ups the letter and manages to convince the people at the counter that he is you, and voila, full access to all accounts. It was a pretty common one a few years ago. Nowadays I think they require you to go to a bank office to pick it out.
- karmelapple 9y agoAre there statistics for how common it is in various places, and what amounts are typically being stolen?
- harryh 9y agoWhen you go to open a credit card in Europe how do you prove that you are you? What prevents me from pretending to be you?
- StavrosK 9y agoYou have to show national ID, a proof of residence and have your tax number ready.
- harryh 9y agoBut the tax number isn't secret right? So that doesn't do much? What is proof of residence? A copy of your apartment lease or something like that?
- StavrosK 9y agoYes, the tax number isn't secret, it's just to prove that you know it and so they can correlate your tax situation, I think. The biggest proof is the identity document, which is not trivial to forge. Proof of residence is a copy of your lease, or a bill by a power or phone company, basically a piece of formal correspondence with your address on it, so you can sort of prove you live where you say. The bank photocopies all this, so if you forge an ID card to include your photo, they store the photo too, and if you get caught you're in deep trouble, as forgery is a serious crime. I think that's actually what prevents most identity theft here.
- harryh 9y agoYa, so I think the big difference between Europe and the US is that you can open a lot of accounts online in the US so there is no opportunity to examine and copy a physical ID card. I can definitely see how that would raise the difficult of pretending to be someone else.
- kuschku 9y agoI just opened a bank account in Germany via an app. I had a choice between either using my eID for verification, or doing a video call and showing the ID into the camera (in a way that their systems can automatically verify the security measures). It took 20 minutes to go from nothing to having an account, and being able to move money to ans from it.
- jeremyt 9y agoDon't you guys routinely use ACH transfers to buy things, give out your bank info, and just hope everything goes well?
- raverbashing 9y agoHummmm no? Germany might have such a system thought.
- baddox 9y agoI’m pretty sure that ACH is only a USA thing.
- chki 9y agoYes it is. I actually didn't know what it was before looking it up.
- socialist_coder 9y agoThe grandparent comment is using ACH but he means the EU equivalent (whatever it's called, I'm not sure). Paying for things in EU with a direct bank transfer is very common. Almost every online shop takes it, every bill you might need to pay, even when just sending money to a friend - direct bank transfer is common. For me with my German bank account, sending money this way always requires a one time use code. The code is not digital, the bank sends you a list of 100+ codes printed on a piece of paper. So, I'm not really worried at all because there is no possible way for a scammer to get my codes.
- kuschku 9y agoSEPA Direct Debit, yes, is used like that. But abuse is very low, as it requires that whoever does it identifies themselves first at another bank, and opens a merchant account (which has other verifications). And then reversing it is easy, too. And you can't even shop with stolen IBANs at Amazon, because every major retailer will first send you a 1ct transaction with transaction info set to a OTP you use to verify that you own the account.
- lmm 9y agoNot all of Europe has national ID. Here in the UK there's no such thing and no general requirement that you be able to identify yourself (though most banks would require photo ID like a passport or driving license or both before they let you open an account) - on the continent I have to remember to always carry my passport with me, which feels weird and oppressive.
- Nitramp 9y agoAt least as a citizen in Germany, you're not required to carry ID. You are required to own some ID (ID card or passport), and you're required to register the place you live in with the authorities. Not sure what the rules for non-citizens are. In any case, most people I know always carry their ID card with them in their wallet. You don't need it all that often, but you might as well carry it around, and having government issued proof of your identity is actually quite handy in many situations (situations that are handled with SSID and/or credit card in the US).
- lmm 9y ago> You are required to own some ID (ID card or passport), and you're required to register the place you live in with the authorities. Fair enough, but still, that's not a requirement here, and seems weird and oppressive (indeed my memory is that being required to register where you lived was a classic example of the non-free-ness of the Soviet Union). > In any case, most people I know always carry their ID card with them in their wallet. You don't need it all that often, but you might as well carry it around, and having government issued proof of your identity is actually quite handy in many situations (situations that are handled with SSID and/or credit card in the US). Sure, in practice I carry my driving license around most of the time in the UK. But the fact that I don't have to feels important.
- supergarfield 9y agoAs I understand it, the vast majority of people in the UK must tell the tax service when their address changes: https://www.gov.uk/national-insurance/change-of-circumstance https://www.gov.uk/national-insurance/change-of-circumstance
- hendry 9y agoIn Europe fraudsters end up using passport copies and numbers, and the only perhaps good thing is the crime becomes localised, but if you travel into that area you might be in for a shock as I was. And then try to explain it wasn't you in a foreign language. I think the single US system has a chance of being sane to correct if you are a victim. I have lost the battle to clear my name. Different states in Germany for example have different police systems and argh..
- leakybit 9y agoBecause the US has a much bigger consumer credit market. Almost every retail chain offers a credit account to customers. Even with the large amount of losses from fraud the banks and credit issuers accrue, they still make bank because of the high interest rates they charge.