3 ms·
Well, I can try to lay it out more formally: We can divide up the task of running a physical simulation into the part where the state is computed, and the part
by whatshisface 9y ago
Well, I can try to lay it out more formally:
We can divide up the task of running a physical simulation into the part where the state is computed, and the part where the results are made visible to us in a way we understand.
We can also divide computation up into the same two pieces: the actual solving of the problem, and then the task of reading symbols off the Turing tape. Usually, we set up our definitions so that a program isn't thought to "solve" a problem unless the reading-the-answer part is trivial.
Now, for a person living inside a simulation, the reading-the-answer part would become insignificant. Why do they care if we can see in to their universe?
So, if all we want is to make a world for simulated people to live in, why not stuff all of the computational complexity into the reading-the-answer part, and then not do it? They would be perfectly happy with a jumbled-up, uninterpretable state in our world, because they would be living on the inside where it made sense.
So, if that is convincing, then allow me to pitch my universe simulating computer:
Launch two photons into space. The distance between them is the state of the simulation. If you want to look in to the state, you have to solve an incredibly hard exponential problem to map the distance to a certain corresponding wavefunction that you could make sense out of.
However, the inhabitants wouldn't care about whether or not you interpreted their state. So, as far as the simulated are concerned, two photons flying apart do make a simulation!
In my opinion the easiest way to make this reductio-ad-absurdum go away is to reject the idea that the simulated is real.