3 ms·
Sadly, this exact scenario was predicted by multiple people and could have been avoided by making segwit and 2MB activate atomically at the same time. This is a
by wmf 9y ago
Sadly, this exact scenario was predicted by multiple people and could have been avoided by making segwit and 2MB activate atomically at the same time. This is a huge embarrassment for big blockers; they have been completely politically out-maneuvered.
- mbgaxyz 9y agoIt's an embarrassment for the industry as a whole. The "New York Agreement" was a blog post, it was never a legally binding and enforceable contract. There's a strong argument that the "agreement" was designed to fail, as it's hardly a compromise when party A gets what they want immediately, but party B has to wait. In future, all "agreements" should be ignored.
- stepik777 9y ago> The "New York Agreement" was a blog post, it was never a legally binding and enforceable contract. More important is that those who signed simply have no power to change Bitcoin. > There's a strong argument that the "agreement" was designed to fail, as it's hardly a compromise when party A gets what they want immediately, but party B has to wait. Yeah, especially when party A doesn't even sign any agreement.
- wmf 9y agoI think if all the NYA signatories had gone all-in on 2x they could have killed the 1x chain. Between the majority of miners and a bunch of exchanges and payment processors, they probably do have the power. But the backlash and financial losses would have been significant.
- dane-pgp 9y agoTo be fair, the game theory of the Segwit + 2MB blocksize "compromise" was well understood: "Give me the whip!" "Throw me the idol! ... No time to argue!" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJ920fat50M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJ920fat50M This is why Bitcoin Cash was forked off from the legacy chain before Segwit was added.
- makomk 9y agoThe likely reason Segwit was activated when it was is because there was a movement by non-2X supporters to forcibly activate it around that date, and the 2X side blinked first. It's as simple as that. Also, 2X is inherently harder to deploy than Segwit because it's a hard fork, which means that everyone everywhere would have to upgrade their software. Even the proposed timeline for 2X was quite aggressive - more so even the BIP-50 upgrade back in 2013, which unlike 2X was entirely uncontroversial and absolutely necessary because nodes running the old version would end up stuck on different forks from each other.
- wmf 9y agoYes, in retrospect this was a huge win for the UASF because they got segwit activated and no block size increase.
- rothbardrand 9y agoYou don't seem to realize that blocks can be up to 3.7mb for segwit transactions. This whole issue has never been about block size- that's the lie they tell to try and take control. It's all about governance and an attempt for the suits to take bitcoin away from the engineer meritocracy. I understand that-- arguing with core people is sometimes frustrating-- but at the end of the day, core is doing a fantastic job.
- rrhd 9y ago> attempt for the suits to take bitcoin away from the engineer meritocracy. because it's not totally controlled by suits already? Who do think is pouring money into mining this stuff.
- stepik777 9y agoBig blockers made an agreement among themselves, what did they hope for?